If you ask a casual fan about the Alice in Chains vocalist, they usually picture one of two things. Either they see the haunting, wide-eyed stare of Layne Staley during the MTV Unplugged session, or they think of William DuVall, the man who stepped into the impossible shoes of a legend.
But honestly? Both of those answers are sort of incomplete.
💡 You might also like: Conor McGregor and Jake Gyllenhaal: What Really Happened on the Road House Set
Alice in Chains has never really been a "one-singer" band. It’s a common misconception that’s persisted since the early nineties. People treat Jerry Cantrell like he's just the guy playing the riffs, but he’s basically been a co-lead since the Sap EP in 1992. Without that specific, eerie blend of two voices, the band wouldn't even sound like Alice in Chains. It would just be another heavy rock group.
The Layne Staley Era: More Than Just a "Grunge Snarl"
Everyone talks about Layne's "snarl." You’ve heard it—that guttural, gravelly power in "Man in the Box." But what people miss is the technical insanity of what he was actually doing. Layne wasn't just screaming. He had this weird, masterful way of using vowel closure and "twang" (a vocal coach term for engaging the epiglottis) to cut through Jerry’s wall of down-tuned guitars.
He was a natural tenor. Even so, he could drop into these vibrating, low baritone notes that felt like they were coming from the floorboards.
- The Audition Myth: There's a story that Jerry Cantrell "waited him out." Jerry had the band—Sean Kinney and Mike Starr—but they needed Layne. Layne was busy with a funk project and didn't want to join. So, the guys literally auditioned the worst singers they could find, including a male stripper, right in front of Layne until he finally snapped and said, "Okay, fine, I’ll do it."
- The "Two-Headed" Monster: By the time they recorded Dirt, Layne and Jerry were singing together so tightly you couldn't tell where one voice ended and the other began. This wasn't standard backup singing. It was two lead parts competing for space.
When Layne passed away in 2002, most people thought the band was done. I mean, how do you replace a guy whose voice sounded like a wounded animal and an angel at the same time? You don't. You change the dynamic.
Why William DuVall Was the Only Logical Choice
When the band reunited in 2006, the internet was... well, it was the internet. People were skeptical. How could this guy from an Atlanta punk/hardcore background (Neon Christ) front Alice in Chains?
✨ Don't miss: The Bo Peep and Woody Toy Story Relationship: What Actually Happened Between Films
But William DuVall didn't try to be a Layne Staley impersonator. That’s why it worked.
DuVall came from a band called Comes with the Fall. Jerry Cantrell had actually toured with them for his solo work, Degradation Trip. They already had the chemistry. Honestly, if they had hired some kid from a tribute band who sounded exactly like Layne, it would have felt like a cheap Vegas act.
DuVall brings a different kind of energy. He's more of a classic rock-and-roll frontman in terms of his stage presence, but his voice has this grit that sits perfectly under Jerry’s harmonies. On albums like Black Gives Way to Blue and Rainier Fog, the "Alice sound" is still there. It’s just evolved.
📖 Related: Have You Seen Andy Movie: The Chilling Truth Behind the Documentary and the 1976 Disappearance
Is Jerry Cantrell Actually the Main Alice in Chains Vocalist?
Here’s the part that gets elitist fans riled up: Since the comeback in 2006, Jerry Cantrell has taken over a huge portion of the lead duties.
In the early days, Layne was the focal point. But if you listen to "Heaven Beside You" or "Over Now" from the mid-nineties, that’s all Jerry. Fast forward to 2026, and the modern lineup is basically a dual-lead-vocalist setup. Jerry handles the melodic, brooding stuff, and William provides the power and the higher-register "bite" that the songs need to stay heavy.
The Secret Sauce: 4th and 5th Harmonies
What really makes the Alice in Chains vocalist sound—whoever is behind the mic—is the use of dissonant intervals. Most rock bands use "perfect" harmonies (thirds and fifths). Alice in Chains uses fourths and "blue notes" that sound slightly "off" or "wrong."
It creates a sense of tension. It’s why their music feels so dark even when it’s acoustic. Jerry Cantrell grew up in choir (he was actually the choir president in high school), and he brought that "scary church music" vibe to the band. He’s gone on record saying he used to perform 14th-century Gregorian chants. You can hear that influence in almost every chorus they've ever written.
How to Tell the Eras Apart (A Quick Guide)
If you're diving into the discography, it’s easy to get lost in the transition.
- The Facelift Era (1990): Pure Layne power. Very metal-influenced. High screams and a lot of vibrato.
- The Dirt/Jar of Flies Era (1992-1994): The peak of the harmony. This is where Layne and Jerry perfected the "single voice" effect.
- The Self-Titled/Tripod Era (1995): More experimental, darker, and where Jerry started taking more leads because Layne's health was declining.
- The Modern Era (2009-Present): DuVall and Cantrell. It’s cleaner, the production is crisper, but the "sludge" is still there.
Actionable Insight for Fans and Musicians
If you're a singer trying to capture this style, don't just focus on the distortion in the voice. Focus on the vowel shapes. Layne and William both use "open" vowels—even on high notes—which gives the voice that massive, round sound.
If you're a listener, try this: put on "Would?" and use your car's balance settings to lean into the left or right speaker. You’ll hear how distinct the two vocal tracks are, and how they only "become" Alice in Chains when they hit your ears at the same time.
The band's story is one of survival. They didn't replace a singer; they honored a legacy while finding a way to keep the engine running. Whether it's the 1990s or 2026, the vocal identity of this band remains one of the most unique "accidents" in rock history.
To truly understand the evolution of the Alice in Chains vocalist, start by listening to the MTV Unplugged performance of "Brother," then immediately switch to "Stone" from The Devil Put Dinosaurs Here. You'll hear the through-line—it's not about one man; it's about the harmony.