All Dr Who Actors: What Most People Get Wrong

All Dr Who Actors: What Most People Get Wrong

Honestly, trying to count every single one of the all Dr Who actors who have stepped into the TARDIS is a bit like trying to count every grain of sand on a beach that keeps regenerating. You’d think it would be a simple list. Fourteen, maybe fifteen names?

Wrong.

Most fans start with William Hartnell and end with Ncuti Gatwa. But if you actually dig into the BBC archives, the "official" number is a mess. Between "Morbius Doctors," "Fugitive Doctors," and that time David Tennant decided to come back just to confuse the numbering, the history of all Dr Who actors is a chaotic, wonderful disaster.

The Foundation: Why William Hartnell Almost Wasn't the One

It started in 1963. William Hartnell wasn't some young heartthrob; he was a 55-year-old character actor known for playing tough military types. Think "Sgt. Grimshawe" from Carry On Sergeant. Basically, he was the guy you hired if you wanted someone to bark orders at a bunch of recruits.

He was crotchety. He fluffed his lines constantly (fans call them "Hartnellisms" now). But he made the show. Without his transition into the "grandfather" figure, the show dies in 1966. When his health failed, the producers didn't cancel the show. They invented "renewal"—later called regeneration.

Then came Patrick Troughton.

Total 180. He was a "cosmic hobo." Baggy trousers, a recorder, and a bowl cut. If Hartnell was the strict teacher, Troughton was the weird uncle who let you stay up late. This shift proved the character could change faces and survive. It’s the only reason we're still talking about this in 2026.

The Scarf, The Cape, and the Celery

By the 70s, the show was a juggernaut. Jon Pertwee took over and turned the Doctor into a dandy who knew aikido and drove a vintage car called Bessie. He was stuck on Earth for most of his run, which sounds boring, but it gave us UNIT and the Master.

Then, the big one. Tom Baker.

If you ask a random person on the street to name any of the all Dr Who actors, they usually picture the guy with the ridiculously long scarf. Fact check: that scarf was an accident. The costume designer, Begonia Pope, was given way too much wool and just kept knitting. Tom loved it. He stayed for seven years—the longest run of any lead actor.

After him? A deliberate move toward youth.

  • Peter Davison: The youngest Doctor at the time (29). He wore a stick of celery on his lapel. Why? Nobody really knew until his final episode.
  • Colin Baker: He got the short end of the stick. The BBC was starting to hate the show. They gave him a technicolor dreamcoat and scripts that were, frankly, a bit mean-spirited.
  • Sylvester McCoy: He started as a clown and ended as a dark, manipulative chess player. He was the one who saw the show get cancelled in 1989.

The Wilderness Years and the Big Comeback

For sixteen years, the show was effectively dead on TV, except for a 1996 movie starring Paul McGann. He’s the most tragic of all Dr Who actors because he only got one TV movie, but he’s gone on to record hundreds of hours of audio dramas. He’s arguably more "Doctor-y" than anyone else because he had to do it all with just his voice for decades.

2005 changed everything. Russell T Davies brought it back with Christopher Eccleston.

Eccleston was "Northern." He wore a leather jacket. No scarf, no celery. He was a survivor of a "Time War." He only stayed for 13 episodes because of behind-the-scenes friction with the higher-ups, but he laid the groundwork for the modern obsession.

Then came the "Golden Era" of David Tennant and Matt Smith.
Tennant was the fanboy who grew up to be the lead. He actually married Peter Davison’s daughter (who also played the Doctor's daughter in the show—time travel is weird). Matt Smith followed him, looking like a "young man built by an old man," and somehow made bow ties cool again.

The Modern Shakeups: Capaldi, Whittaker, and Jo Martin

Peter Capaldi was a return to the "older Doctor" vibe. He was a punk rock philosopher. Then, the show broke its biggest glass ceiling: Jodie Whittaker.

✨ Don't miss: Why the Take the 10 Cast Still Feels Like a Time Capsule of 2017 Indie Comedy

People argued. People cheered. But she was the Doctor. Period. During her run, showrunner Chris Chibnall dropped a bomb: The Fugitive Doctor. Played by Jo Martin, she was a "secret" incarnation from before the First Doctor. This turned the numbering on its head. Suddenly, the "Thirteenth" Doctor was actually... well, we still don't know the exact number.

The 2023-2026 Era: Tennant’s Return and Ncuti’s Reign

In a move nobody saw coming, David Tennant returned in 2023 as the Fourteenth Doctor. Not the Tenth again—the Fourteenth. He stayed for three specials before "bi-generating."

This was a first.

Usually, the old guy leaves and the new guy arrives. This time, they split. Tennant’s Doctor stayed on Earth to retire with Donna Noble, while Ncuti Gatwa’s Fifteenth Doctor flew off in a new TARDIS.

Ncuti Gatwa brought a literal "new energy." He’s the first Doctor born outside the UK (Rwanda) and the first to openly showcase a queer identity in the role. His performance in "The Reality War" (2025) cemented him as one of the greats, blending high-fashion sensibilities with the ancient loneliness the character is known for.

The "Hidden" Doctors You Didn't Know About

You can't talk about all Dr Who actors without mentioning the guest stars who technically played the role:

  1. John Hurt (The War Doctor): The bridge between the "Classic" and "New" series. He was the warrior who didn't want the name.
  2. David Bradley: He played William Hartnell in a biopic, then played the First Doctor so well they brought him into the actual show to replace the long-deceased Hartnell.
  3. Richard Hurndall: The original "replacement" First Doctor for the 20th Anniversary in 1983.
  4. The Morbius Doctors: In 1976, we saw a bunch of faces on a screen that were supposed to be pre-Hartnell Doctors. They were actually just members of the production crew in costumes. For 40 years, fans ignored them. Now, they're "canon" again.

How to Actually Watch Them All

If you’re trying to catch up on the legacy of all Dr Who actors, don't try to go in order. You'll burn out by the middle of the 60s because so many episodes are missing (literally—the BBC wiped the tapes).

Instead, try a "Sampling Menu":

  • Watch "City of Death" for Tom Baker’s wit.
  • Watch "The Caves of Androzani" for Peter Davison’s sacrifice.
  • Watch "Blink" for a Tenth Doctor masterclass (even though he's barely in it).
  • Watch "Heaven Sent" to see Peter Capaldi act by himself for 50 minutes.

What’s Next for the TARDIS?

As of 2026, the show is in a fascinating spot. With the bi-generation, we technically have two Doctors active at the same time. While Ncuti Gatwa is the lead, the "parked" Fourteenth Doctor is still out there. Rumors of a spin-off for Jo Martin’s Fugitive Doctor refuse to die.

The most important thing to remember is that the "next" actor is always just around the corner. Every time someone says, "This person will ruin the show," they're usually proven wrong by the next Christmas special.

Actionable Insights for New Fans:

  • Don't get hung up on numbers. The show is 60+ years old; the "continuity" is a suggestion, not a law.
  • Check out Big Finish. If you love an actor who left too soon (like Paul McGann or Colin Baker), they have hundreds of full-cast audio plays that continue their stories.
  • Start with "Rose" (2005) or "The Church on Ruby Road" (2023). These are designed as entry points for people who don't want to watch grainy black-and-white footage from the 60s.