You’ve seen the movies. Maybe you’ve even seen the grainy "sonar footage" on late-night TV that claims to show a grid of streets at the bottom of the Atlantic Ocean. Most of us grew up thinking of Atlantis as this high-tech underwater utopia where people wear flowing robes and probably talk to dolphins. But when you actually ask the question—Atlantis: what is it—the answer is way less about mermaids and way more about a very specific guy in ancient Greece who was trying to win a political argument.
Honestly, it's a bit of a letdown if you’re looking for aliens.
Atlantis first appears in the written record around 360 B.C. It wasn’t an ancient legend passed down through songs or cave paintings. It was a plot device. The philosopher Plato introduced the island in two of his dialogues, Timaeus and Critias. He describes a massive naval power that existed 9,000 years before his own time, sitting right past the "Pillars of Hercules," which we now call the Strait of Gibraltar.
It was huge. It was powerful. And then, in a single day and night of misfortune, it vanished into the sea.
The Plato Problem: Fact or Fiction?
If you want to understand the origins of the story, you have to look at what Plato was actually doing. He wasn't a geographer. He wasn't a historian in the way we think of them today. He was a philosopher interested in the "ideal state."
In his story, Atlantis wasn't the hero.
The hero was actually ancient Athens. Plato depicted Atlantis as a corrupt, technologically advanced, and arrogant empire that tried to enslave the Mediterranean. The "noble" Athenians were the ones who stood up to them and won. The destruction of Atlantis by earthquakes and floods was presented as a divine punishment from the gods for the city's hubris. Basically, Atlantis was a cautionary tale about what happens when a society gets too big for its boots and loses its moral compass.
💡 You might also like: Temperature Hong Kong June: Why the Humidity Changes Everything
For centuries, nobody really thought it was real.
Aristotle, who was Plato’s most famous student, supposedly said that Plato "invented it to illustrate a point and then destroyed it." During the Middle Ages, the story mostly sat on a shelf gathering dust. People had bigger things to worry about, like the plague and feudalism, than a sunken city from a Greek dialogue. It wasn't until the Renaissance, when European explorers started hitting the Americas, that the "Atlantis: what is it" conversation got weird again. When sailors found a "New World," they started wondering if this was the "lost continent" Plato had mentioned.
The Man Who Created the Modern Myth
We can mostly blame—or credit—a guy named Ignatius L. Donnelly for the way we think about Atlantis today. In 1882, he published Atlantis: The Antediluvian World.
Donnelly was a U.S. Congressman and a bit of a pseudo-science enthusiast. He argued that Atlantis was a real place and that it was the "mother" of all human civilizations. He looked at the pyramids in Egypt and the pyramids in Mexico and decided they couldn't possibly have been built independently. To him, there had to be a "missing link" in the middle of the Atlantic that taught everyone how to build them.
His book was a massive bestseller. It changed the narrative from a Greek philosophical myth to a literal mystery that needed solving.
Since then, we’ve had everything from Edgar Cayce, the "Sleeping Prophet," claiming he saw visions of Atlanteans with giant energy crystals, to Disney movies and Aquaman. The problem is that none of these modern interpretations have any basis in the original text or in actual geology. Plate tectonics tells us that continents don't just "sink." They drift. The seafloor of the Atlantic has been mapped extensively, and there isn't a continent-sized hole where Atlantis could have been.
Real Places That Might Be the "Real" Atlantis
Even if the literal "continent in the Atlantic" is a bust, historians still argue over whether Plato based his story on a real event. There are a few candidates that actually make sense from a historical perspective.
💡 You might also like: Elevation Pollock Pines CA: Why 4,000 Feet Changes Everything
- The Minoan Eruption on Thera (Santorini): Around 1600 B.C., a massive volcanic eruption ripped the island of Thera apart. It triggered tsunamis that devastated the Minoan civilization on nearby Crete. The Minoans were a seafaring power with advanced plumbing and art. When they suddenly "vanished" or declined after the catastrophe, it left a massive mark on the ancient world's collective memory.
- Doggerland: This was a real landmass that connected Great Britain to mainland Europe. It was swallowed by rising sea levels at the end of the last Ice Age. While it doesn't fit Plato's timeline perfectly, it's a genuine example of a "lost world" under the North Sea.
- The Eye of the Sahara (Richat Structure): In recent years, YouTubers and armchair archaeologists have pointed to this geological formation in Mauritania. It looks like concentric rings from space, which matches Plato’s description of the city’s layout. However, geologists say it's a natural dome that eroded over millions of years, not a man-made city. Plus, it's hundreds of miles from the coast.
- Helike: This was a Greek city that actually sank into the Gulf of Corinth in 373 B.C. after an earthquake. It happened during Plato's lifetime. It's very likely that he saw or heard about this disaster and used it as inspiration for his fictional island's demise.
Why the Mystery Persists
We love a good mystery. It's human nature to want to believe there's more to the world than what’s on the map. The idea of a lost golden age is deeply comforting—if humans were once that great, maybe we can be again. Or maybe it's just the thrill of the hunt.
Scientific oceanography has debunked the "mid-Atlantic continent" theory. Dr. Ken Feder, an archaeologist who specializes in debunking "fringe" history, points out that if Atlantis existed 9,000 years before Plato, we should find its trash. Archaeology is basically the study of ancient garbage. We find stone tools and campfire remains from that era all over the world, but we find zero evidence of a global seafaring empire with bronze-age technology.
It just isn't there.
But "Atlantis" has become a shorthand. Now, when people ask Atlantis: what is it, they aren't always asking about the Greek myth. They're asking about the possibility of lost knowledge. They're looking for a connection to a past that feels more magical than our current reality.
Actionable Steps for the Curious
If you want to look into this without falling down a rabbit hole of total nonsense, here is how you should actually investigate the topic:
- Read the Source: Don't trust a documentary. Go to a library or use a site like Project Gutenberg to read Plato’s Timaeus and Critias. It's surprisingly short. You'll notice immediately that it sounds more like a political speech than a historical record.
- Study the Minoans: If you want a real-life "lost civilization" that was genuinely impressive, look into the Minoan culture on Crete. Visit the Palace of Knossos if you ever get the chance to go to Greece. The frescos and engineering are better than anything in a sci-fi movie.
- Check the Bathymetry: Use Google Earth to look at the "ridges" in the Atlantic Ocean. You'll see the Mid-Atlantic Ridge, which is a volcanic mountain range under the water. It’s where the Earth’s plates are pulling apart, which is the opposite of where a continent would "sink."
- Visit Real Sunken Cities: If you want to see underwater ruins, look at Pavlopetri in Greece (the world's oldest submerged city) or the sunken remains of Port Royal in Jamaica. These are real, tangible places you can actually study.
Ultimately, Atlantis is a mirror. It reflects our own fears about societal collapse and our hopes for human greatness. Whether it was a real island or just a clever metaphor, it has successfully survived for over 2,000 years, which is more than most real empires can say.