Let’s be real for a second. Most pirate media is kind of a joke. We’ve been fed a steady diet of "yo-ho-ho" caricatures and Disneyfied swashbucklers for decades. Then Black Sails arrived on Starz and basically burned the entire genre to the ground. It didn't just give us a prequel to Robert Louis Stevenson’s Treasure Island; it gave us a gritty, hyper-literate, and deeply tragic deconstruction of what it actually means to be a "monster" in a world run by empires.
The Black Sails characters aren't just archetypes. They are desperate people trapped between the encroaching "civilized" world and the chaotic freedom of Nassau. You’ve got legends like Captain Flint, but then you’ve also got the real-life historical figures like Anne Bonny and Jack Rackham woven into the fiction. It’s a mess of shifting loyalties. It’s brutal. And honestly? It’s some of the best character writing in the history of television.
Captain Flint and the Weight of the Useless War
James Flint is the sun that every other character orbits, whether they want to or not. Toby Stephens played him with this terrifying, simmering rage that felt like it could melt the screen. At first, you think he’s just a greedy pirate looking for a Spanish treasure galleon, the Urca de Lima. But as the seasons peel back the layers, you realize Flint isn't a pirate because he likes gold. He’s a pirate because he’s at war with the very concept of England.
Flint’s backstory—his transition from Lieutenant James McGraw of the Royal Navy to the scourge of the West Indies—is a masterclass in tragedy. His relationship with Thomas Hamilton and the betrayal by Lord Hamilton didn't just break his heart; it broke his soul. He decided that if the world was going to call him a monster for who he loved and what he believed, he would become the most efficient, terrifying monster the world had ever seen.
But here’s the thing about Flint: he’s exhausting. He demands total loyalty and gives back nothing but more trauma. He kills his friends. He lies to his crew. He’s a "great man" in the historical sense, which basically means he’s a disaster for everyone around him. You love him, you hate him, and you definitely don't want to sail with him.
Long John Silver’s Evolution from Grifter to Myth
If Flint is the heart of the show, John Silver is the voice.
When we first meet Silver, he’s a nobody. He’s a cook. He’s a silver-tongued opportunist who just wants to survive. Luke Arnold’s performance is incredible because you see the exact moment the "Long John Silver" legend starts to take over the man. It starts as a survival tactic. He realizes that if people are afraid of you, they won't kill you.
The relationship between Flint and Silver is the actual core of the series. It’s a weird, toxic, deeply intimate friendship-slash-rivalry. Silver spends most of the show trying to avoid becoming a leader, only to realize he’s better at it than Flint is. By the time he loses his leg and gains that terrifying reputation, he isn't even sure where the "act" ends and his true self begins.
One of the most fascinating aspects of his character is his relationship with Madi. Through the Maroons, Silver finds something worth fighting for that isn't just his own skin. It complicates his "grifter" persona. It makes his eventual decisions in the series finale feel earned, even if they're heartbreaking for those of us who wanted a different ending.
The Women Who Actually Ran Nassau
You can't talk about Black Sails characters without acknowledging that the women were usually the smartest people in the room.
Eleanor Guthrie: The Power Broker
Eleanor Guthrie is a polarizing character, and that’s being generous. People love to hate her. She’s cold, she’s pragmatic, and she’s obsessed with the idea of Nassau becoming a "legitimate" trade hub. She’s the one who funds the pirates, but she also has no problem selling them out if it serves the bigger picture.
Her arc is a downward spiral of compromise. She starts as the Queen of Nassau and ends up a pawn of the British Empire, but her motivations never change. She wants order. She wants a legacy. And in a world that treats women like property, she fought like a hellcat to own the ground she stood on.
Anne Bonny: The Blade of the Show
Anne Bonny is a revelation. Played by Clara Paget with very little dialogue but immense physical presence, she is the emotional anchor of the Rackham/Bonny duo. She’s a survivor of horrific abuse who finds her power through violence and a very specific kind of loyalty.
What’s great about Anne is that the show doesn't try to make her a "strong female lead" in the boring, modern sense. She’s messy. She’s confused about her sexuality. She’s incredibly lonely. Her bond with Jack Rackham is the only genuinely pure thing in the entire show. They are partners in every sense of the word, even when things get weird with Max.
The Historical Remix: Jack Rackham and Woodes Rogers
"Calico" Jack Rackham is the guy who cares about the brand. He understands that in the pirate world, your reputation is your only currency. Toby Schmitz plays him with this witty, foppish charm that masks a brilliant tactical mind. He’s the one who designs the Jolly Roger. He’s the one who realizes that if they can't win with cannons, they have to win with stories.
Then you have Woodes Rogers. Historically, he’s the guy who "cleaned up" the pirates. In the show, he’s portrayed as a man who genuinely believes he is the hero of the story. He’s not a mustache-twirling villain. He’s a debt-ridden governor trying to bring "civilization" to a place that doesn't want it. Watching him slowly descend into the same brutality he claims to despise is one of the most satisfying arcs in the later seasons.
Why These Characters Work Where Others Fail
Most shows struggle with consistency. They change character motivations to fit the plot. Black Sails never did that. Every betrayal, every murder, and every alliance felt like it was born out of who those people were at their core.
- The dialogue actually matters. These people don't just talk; they orate. They use language as a weapon.
- Morality is a gray smear. There are no "good guys." Even the "villains" have points that make sense if you look at it from their perspective.
- The stakes are permanent. When a character dies in this show, it leaves a massive hole. Think about Mr. Scott or Charles Vane. Those deaths changed the trajectory of the entire narrative.
Speaking of Charles Vane—we have to mention him. Zach McGowan played Vane like a feral animal with a heart of gold. He represented the "old way" of piracy. No politics, no empires, just the sea and the freedom to be a wild thing. His sacrifice in Season 3 is arguably the turning point of the entire series. It turned a pirate rebellion into a full-blown revolution.
The Myth vs. The Reality
The show constantly plays with the idea of how history is written. Flint knows that the British will write the history books, and they will paint him as a mindless killer. That’s why he embraces the persona. He wants to be the thing that keeps the kings of Europe awake at night.
The Black Sails characters are all fighting against being forgotten. Jack wants his name on a flag. Eleanor wants her name on a city. Flint wants his name to be a warning. In the end, most of them get exactly what they wanted, but at a cost that is almost too high to pay.
How to Get the Most Out of a Rewatch
If you’re heading back into the world of Nassau, pay attention to the small stuff.
- Look at Silver’s eyes. Watch how he observes people before he speaks. He’s always "reading" the room to see which version of himself he needs to play.
- Notice the color palette. As the seasons progress and "civilization" arrives, the vibrant, sun-drenched Nassau starts to feel colder, grayer, and more claustrophobic.
- Listen to the score. Bear McCreary’s hurdy-gurdy heavy music isn't just background noise; it’s the heartbeat of the characters. It gets more complex as they do.
The true legacy of these characters isn't that they were pirates. It’s that they were human beings trying to find a way to exist in a world that had no place for them. Whether it's Madi's fierce leadership of the Maroons or Billy Bones' tragic descent into obsession, everyone is just trying to hold onto a piece of themselves before the tide comes in.
💡 You might also like: Why The Santa Clause 2 is Actually the Most Important Movie in the Trilogy
To truly understand the depth of this show, you have to look past the ship battles. Those are great, don't get me wrong. The boarding of the Spanish Man o' War is incredible television. But the real "action" is two people sitting in a cabin, drinking rum, and dismantling each other's souls with words.
If you haven't seen the show in a while, go back and watch the scenes between Flint and Mrs. Barlow. Their relationship is the key to understanding why Flint is so hell-bent on destruction. It’s not about the money. It was never about the money. It was about the fact that they were once good people who were discarded by a system that valued order over humanity.
Next Steps for Fans
If you've finished the show and find yourself missing these characters, here's how to keep the vibe alive:
- Read "Treasure Island" again. But this time, read it with the knowledge of who these people "were" in the show. It turns the book from a children’s adventure into a ghost story about the survivors of a failed revolution.
- Research the real-life pirates. Characters like Israel Hands, Ben Hornigold, and Mary Read (who appears late in the show) all have fascinating, bizarre historical records that the show references in really clever ways.
- Check out the "Black Sails" soundtrack. Specifically, the track "The Curse of Captain Flint." It encapsulates the entire tragedy of the character in about four minutes.
- Analyze the political parallels. Look at how the show handles the concept of "civilization" vs. "savagery." It’s incredibly relevant to modern discussions about power and who gets to define what is "legal."
The world of Black Sails is finished, but the characters stay with you. They aren't just names in a script; they’re warnings about what happens when you decide to fight the world. And honestly? I’d take Captain Flint’s rage over a boring hero any day of the week.