It is hard to imagine anyone else as Ellie. Honestly, the character is so tied to Ashley Johnson that separating them feels like a mistake. Back in 2013, when Naughty Dog first dropped the game, most players just thought of her as the "voice actor." But that’s a massive understatement. She didn't just talk. She lived the character.
Ashley Johnson actually shaped who Ellie became. Originally, the script had Ellie as a more passive character—someone Joel had to protect constantly. Ashley pushed back. She wanted Ellie to be a fighter. She wanted her to be capable, even when she was scared. Because of that input, Neil Druckmann and the team at Naughty Dog redesigned Ellie’s gameplay mechanics. They made her more active in combat. They let her take out hunters with a switchblade instead of just hiding in a locker.
🔗 Read more: Why The Legend of Heroes Trails of Cold Steel Is Still the Most Ambitious RPG Series Ever Made
The Performance Behind Ellie the Last of Us Ashley Johnson
People often forget that 85% of what you see on screen in the games is Ashley’s physical movement. It’s motion capture. Every nervous twitch, the way she holds her knife, and that specific teenage slouch—that’s all Ashley Johnson. She wasn't just standing in a booth reading lines; she was wearing a spandex suit with ping-pong balls on it, crying in a soundstage to make those scenes with Joel feel real.
You know that ending in the first game? The "Okay" scene?
Ashley has been vocal about how she interpreted that moment. While fans debate if Ellie believed Joel’s lie about the Fireflies, Ashley played it with the mindset that Ellie totally knew he was lying. She chose to accept the lie because she didn't want to be alone. Her biggest fear was always being left behind, a theme that carried through to the Left Behind DLC and into the sequel.
In The Last of Us Part II, things got much darker. Ashley had to research PTSD and the physical effects of anxiety to portray an older, broken Ellie. It wasn't just about sounding older. It was about carrying the weight of Joel's death in every step.
🔗 Read more: College Football 25: Why the Long Wait for an NCAA Football Video Game Actually Paid Off
That Weird Likeness Controversy
Here is a bit of trivia that some newer fans might have missed. When the first trailer for The Last of Us came out, people thought Ellie looked exactly like actor Elliot Page. At the time, Page was actually starring in another Sony game, Beyond: Two Souls.
It got a bit awkward. Page even mentioned it in a Reddit AMA, saying it wasn't "appreciated" that they used his likeness. Naughty Dog denied it was intentional, but they eventually changed Ellie’s character model during development. Why? To make her look more like Ashley Johnson. They wanted the character to reflect the person actually bringing her to life. If you look at the 2013 Ellie versus the 2022 Remake version, you can see how much more of Ashley’s facial structure is in there now.
How the HBO Show Honored the Original Ellie
When the HBO series was announced, fans were worried. How do you replace Ashley? You don't. You find someone who can bring a different energy while respecting the foundation. Bella Ramsey did exactly that, but the creators knew they couldn't do the show without the original Ellie involved.
The Full Circle Moment
In the Season 1 finale, Ashley Johnson played Anna, Ellie’s mother. It was a poetic, "surreal" experience, according to her. She literally gave birth to Ellie on screen after metaphorically giving birth to her in the games a decade earlier.
Seeing her fight off an infected while in labor was a brutal reminder of where Ellie’s grit comes from. It also gave fans a concrete reason for Ellie’s immunity—the bite happening right as the umbilical cord was cut. That wasn't in the games. It was a new layer added for the show, and having Ashley be the one to deliver that information felt right.
But she wasn't done yet. In Season 2, she made a "voice cameo" that hit fans right in the feels. During the credits of the second episode, a haunting version of the song "Through the Valley" plays. This is the same song Ellie sang in the very first teaser for Part II back in 2016. HBO used a blend of her original recording and a new version she did just for the show.
Why Her Impact Still Matters in 2026
We are now over a decade into this franchise, and the discussion around Ellie the Last of Us Ashley Johnson hasn't slowed down. She set a standard for what performance in gaming could be. Before her, many characters felt like archetypes. She made Ellie a person.
- Humanity: She insisted on Ellie having flaws, like her temper and her occasional selfishness.
- Vulnerability: Ashley’s background in music (she’s a talented singer and multi-instrumentalist) influenced Ellie’s love for the guitar.
- Legacy: She remains a consultant and a figurehead for the community, often appearing at conventions to discuss the deep psychological roots of the character.
If you are a fan who has only watched the show, you're only getting half the story. The games offer a different kind of intimacy. You aren't just watching Ellie; you are responsible for her. And through Ashley's performance, you feel every bit of that responsibility.
To truly understand the depth of this character, you should look into the "Grounded" making-of documentaries. They show the raw footage of Ashley and Troy Baker (Joel) working together. It’s essentially a masterclass in acting. They didn't have sets or costumes. They just had each other and the script.
If you want to dive deeper into how this character was built, I recommend checking out the official The Last of Us podcast. Ashley goes into detail about specific scenes, like the harrowing "David" encounter in the winter chapter. It’s heavy stuff, but it explains why this character has such a grip on pop culture. You can also find her "Through the Valley" cover on most streaming platforms if you want to hear that haunting Season 2 ending without the credits rolling.