/pic2486914.jpg)
You bought the box. It’s huge. It’s heavy. It’s sitting on your coffee table like a monolithic tribute to terrible jokes and even worse people. But if you’re like most of us, you didn't just buy the Cards Against Humanity Bigger Blacker Box hidden card hunt; you bought a storage solution that happens to have a secret. Or at least, it used to.
Honestly, the "secret" isn't much of a secret anymore if you spend ten minutes on Reddit, but the physical reality of getting to it? That’s where things get messy. People have literally shredded their $15 investment looking for a piece of cardboard that might not even be there depending on which version they own.
It’s a gamble. A weird, paper-based gamble.
The Mystery of the Cards Against Humanity Bigger Blacker Box Hidden Card
Let’s get the logistics out of the way first. Cards Against Humanity (CAH) has released several versions of their storage cases. The original "Bigger Blacker Box" was the one that started the craze. It was long, rectangular, and felt surprisingly sturdy. Inside the lid—specifically behind the black paper lining—was a single card.
It wasn't just any card. It was a card that usually made people feel a mix of triumph and "wait, I paid for this?"
Usually, the card was The Biggest, Blackest Dick. Classy, right? That’s CAH for you. But here is the kicker: as the product evolved into the "Bigger Better Blacker Box" (and subsequent iterations like the Triple Fat Box), the location and even the existence of the hidden card changed. Some people started tearing apart their expensive organizers only to find... glue. Just glue and sadness.
✨ Don't miss: The Orange Box Half Life: Why We Never Got a Deal This Good Again
How to tell if your box actually has it
Before you go grab a box cutter and start acting like an amateur surgeon, look at the bottom of your box. If you have the version released around 2013-2015, you’re in the prime "hidden card" era. The original Bigger Blacker Box had a very specific construction. The lid had a secondary layer of cardboard.
If you press firmly on the center of the inside of the lid, do you feel a slight rectangular bump? If it feels perfectly flat and solid, stop. You are about to destroy a perfectly good box for no reason.
The Cards Against Humanity Bigger Blacker Box hidden card isn't just a myth, but it’s version-dependent. In the later "Bigger Better Blacker Box," the company actually moved the secret. Instead of being in the lid, many users found a hidden card—often a procedurally generated "Unique Card"—tucked inside the foil packaging or hidden in the bottom lining of the box itself.
The Surgical Approach: How to Get It Out
If you’ve confirmed there is a bump, you have a choice. You can be a barbarian and rip the paper lining out, or you can be precise. Most collectors suggest using a literal X-Acto knife.
You aren't cutting the outer shell. You’re cutting the thin, black paper lining on the inside of the lid.
- Feel for the edges of the card through the paper.
- Lightly score a three-sided flap.
- Peel it back carefully.
- Realize you just spent five minutes doing surgery on a box to get a card about male anatomy.
Is it worth it? Probably not for the gameplay value. But for the completionist? It’s the Holy Grail. There is also a secondary hidden card in some versions located in the very bottom of the box, tucked under the foam inserts. Sometimes it’s a card, sometimes it’s just a joke printed on the cardboard.
Why CAH does this anyway
Cards Against Humanity has always been a company built on "anti-marketing." They sold literal bull excrement for Black Friday. They dug a hole in the ground for no reason. Hiding a card inside the packaging is just an extension of their brand. It rewards the people who are obsessive enough to poke and prod at their products.
It also creates a secondary market. You’ll see "The Biggest, Blackest Dick" cards hovering on eBay for $20 to $50 sometimes, which is hilarious considering the entire box usually costs less than that. People want what they can't easily see.
Variations and Disappointments
We have to talk about the "Bigger Better Blacker Box" (the 2017-era redesign). This box is square-ish and much larger. If you bought your box in the last few years, the lid trick likely won't work.
In this version, CAH got a bit more creative. Some users reported finding a card hidden behind the "This box is empty" or "This is a box" text printed on the inner flap. Others found that the "secret" was actually just the fact that the box came with a set of blank cards you were supposed to write on yourself.
The most common "hidden" element in the modern boxes isn't even a card anymore; it’s the Box Expansion. This is a small pack of cards that is often tucked into the packaging material itself, hidden in plain sight under the cardboard spacers. It’s less about destruction and more about just looking under the hood.
The "Hidden" Card in the Triple Fat Box
The latest behemoth, the Triple Fat Box, supposedly fits everything ever made by CAH. Does it have a hidden card? The consensus among the board game community (and the poor souls who have sacrificed their boxes to find out) is: No. At least, not in the traditional "buried in the cardboard" sense. CAH seems to have moved away from the "destroy your product" model and toward the "here is a weirdly placed expansion pack" model. If you’re digging into a Triple Fat Box with a knife, you’re likely just making a mess.
✨ Don't miss: Far Cry 5 Prepper Stash Locations: Where to Find Every Hidden Cache
Is the card even good for the game?
Look, let's be real. Cards Against Humanity isn't exactly a game of high strategy. It’s a game of "who can be the most shocking."
The hidden cards are almost always "Power" cards. They are high-impact, very offensive, and designed to win a round instantly. "The Biggest, Blackest Dick" is a classic for a reason—it’s the ultimate low-brow punchline. But if you play with the same group of people every week, the shock value wears off.
The real value of the Cards Against Humanity Bigger Blacker Box hidden card is the story. "Oh, this card? I had to cut open the lid of my box to get it." That’s a better conversational hook than the joke on the card itself.
Common Misconceptions
- "Every box has one." False. Only certain production runs of the original long box and some early square boxes.
- "It’s a different card every time." Mostly false. It’s almost always the same one, though some rare versions had "The Biggest, Blackest Dick" with shiny foil lettering.
- "You’ll ruin the structural integrity of the box." True, if you're messy. If you use a sharp blade and just cut a small slit, the box will hold up fine. It just won't look "mint" anymore.
Technical Details: Identifying Your Version
If you’re still unsure, check the copyright date and the manufacturer info on the bottom.
- 2013-2014 Long Box: High chance of a lid card. Check for the "bump."
- 2015-2016 Long Box: Mixed results. Some have it, some don't.
- 2017+ Square Box (Bigger Better Blacker): Likely no lid card, check the bottom spacers or the "secret" pack included in the middle row.
- 2020+ Triple Fat Box: No hidden cardboard cards reported.
The Psychology of the Hidden Card
There’s a reason this is such a searched-for topic. It taps into that primal "buried treasure" instinct. It’s the same reason people love Easter eggs in video games or secret menus at fast-food joints. We want to feel like we’ve seen something the average consumer missed.
CAH knows this. They’ve built an entire empire on making their customers feel like they are "in" on a joke that the rest of the world (especially "polite" society) doesn't get. Finding the hidden card is the ultimate "I’m in the club" moment.
Practical Next Steps for Box Owners
If you are currently holding a knife and staring at your game shelf, take a breath.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Cuckoo Clock in It Takes Two is the Game’s Most Chaotic Level
First, empty the box completely. Remove every single card. Check the bottom of the empty channels. Sometimes cards get stuck under the dividers during shipping, and people mistake these for "hidden" cards when they’re really just "misplaced" cards.
Second, use a flashlight. Shine it across the surface of the inner lid at an angle. This "raking light" will reveal any shadows caused by a card tucked behind the paper. If the light shows a perfectly smooth surface, put the knife away.
Third, if you do decide to cut, don't go deep. The paper lining is thin. You don't want to pierce the actual outer cardboard of the box, or you’ll have a hole in your lid forever. Just a light nick is enough to see what's behind the curtain.
Lastly, if you find nothing, don't feel bad. Thousands of people have "autopsied" their boxes only to find nothing but industrial adhesive. It’s part of the CAH experience. The disappointment is practically a feature.
What to do now:
- Check your box’s manufacture date on the bottom panel.
- Perform the "flashlight test" on the inside of the lid to check for rectangular shadows.
- If you find a card, consider putting it in a sleeve immediately—the glue residue on the back of hidden cards can attract hair and dust, making them stand out (in a bad way) in your deck.
- If your box is the newer "Triple Fat" version, save your time and don't cut it open; just enjoy the massive amount of storage space you paid for.
The hunt is fun, but at the end of the day, it's just more cardboard for the collection.
Actionable Insight: If you're buying a used box specifically to find the card, always ask for a photo of the inside lid. If you see a weird flap or a messy tear, the previous owner already beat you to it. If it’s pristine, you might have a hidden gem—or just a very empty lid.