Look, we all knew it was coming. Every year around Easter, San Diego Studio drops a scavenger hunt that sends the entire community into a collective frenzy, and the MLB The Show 25 egg hunt is no different. It is basically a digital tradition at this point. You load up the game, see a bunch of cryptic "Hints" in the Programs menu, and realize you’re going to be spending your Tuesday night playing modes you usually ignore just to get that shiny 99 OVR card.
It is honestly a bit of a love-hate relationship.
You’ve got the hardcore grinders who solve these in three hours. Then you’ve got the rest of us, squinting at a clue about "beating a bird" and wondering if that means a specific team or just a really weird coincidence in a Mini Seasons game.
The MLB The Show 25 egg hunt isn't just about the cards, though. It’s about that specific brand of chaos that happens on social media when everyone is trying to figure out if Egg 7 is broken or if they just haven't hit enough triples yet.
The Reality of the MLB The Show 25 Egg Hunt Clues
If you’re new to the Great Egg Hunt, here’s the deal: SDS doesn’t give you direct instructions. They give you "vibe" clues.
One might say "The Easter Bunny likes to play in the sand." Sounds simple, right? Wrong. That could mean playing a game in a specific stadium, or it could mean getting a certain number of saves with a pitcher who has a "sand" related name. Actually, usually, it’s just playing a game in a specific localized mode like Showdown or Conquest.
✨ Don't miss: Finding Those Old Map Locations in Tears of the Kingdom is Actually Worth the Headache
The sheer variety of tasks is what makes the MLB The Show 25 egg hunt both brilliant and incredibly frustrating. You cannot just sit in Ranked Seasons and hope to finish it. The game forces you to touch grass—or at least the digital version of it in Retro Mode or Moments.
Why People Get Stuck on Egg 5
There is almost always one egg that acts as a gatekeeper. In previous years, it was the "Hit a Home Run with a Catcher in a Battle Royale game" requirement. People hated it. Why? Because you have to draft a specific lineup and then hope your opponent doesn't quit the moment they see you’re fishing for an egg.
In the MLB The Show 25 egg hunt, the bottleneck usually revolves around the "Hidden" locations in Conquest. You’ll be flying across the map, taking over territories, hoping for a pop-up. If you aren't paying attention to the specific requirements for the hidden nodes, you’ll clear the whole map and realize you missed the one spot that actually triggers the reward.
It’s tedious. But the rewards? They’re usually some of the best early-to-mid-cycle cards in Diamond Dynasty.
Cracking the Code: Where the Eggs Are Usually Hiding
History repeats itself in San Diego. While the specific player rewards change, the logic behind the MLB The Show 25 egg hunt follows a fairly predictable pattern. You can almost bet your stubs on where these things are tucked away.
The "Main Menu" Egg. This is the "is it plugged in?" of the hunt. Usually, you just have to navigate to a specific screen, like the Collections tab or the Shop, and the egg just appears. It’s a freebie to get you hooked.
The Bird Hunt. SDS loves puns. If a clue mentions birds, go beat the Blue Jays, Cardinals, or Orioles in a CPU game. It’s a classic move.
Event Participation. You probably have to win a game in the current Event. Not just play—win. This is where the casual players start to feel the heat.
The "Marathon" Egg. This one usually involves tallying up a specific number of stats, like 1,000 PXP with "Egg Hunt" series players or just a massive amount of strikeouts across any mode.
The Showdown Special. You’ll likely have to complete a specific Egg Hunt Showdown. These are usually easier than the Extreme Showdowns, but one bad RNG swing on a perfect-perfect flyball can ruin your run.
Honestly, the best way to handle the MLB The Show 25 egg hunt is to stack your lineup with whatever players you earn from the first few eggs. Most of the later missions require using those specific cards to unlock the "Big Reward" at the end of the program.
Common Misconceptions About the Hunt
People always think there’s a secret time limit. "Oh, I have to do this by Sunday or the eggs disappear!" Usually, that’s not true. While the event might be themed around Easter, the Program itself often stays live for a while. However, if you want the cards to actually be "meta" and usable in your lineup, you need to get them fast. A 97 OVR outfielder is a god in April; by June, he's just bench depth or collection fodder.
Another mistake? Thinking you can do it all in Play vs Friends. SDS shut that door a long time ago. You’ve got to do this in "meaningful" games.
The Strategy for Efficiency
Don't just jump in. That's how you waste four hours.
Instead, look at the missions that overlap. If you need to get 500 PXP with a certain player and also need to win a game against the Braves, do them at the same time in a 9-inning CPU game. It sounds obvious, but you’d be surprised how many people do these one by one.
The MLB The Show 25 egg hunt is a test of your ability to multi-task.
Also, keep an eye on the community forums. Sites like DaddyLeagues or the official MLB The Show subreddit are usually ahead of the curve. By the time you've finished the second egg, some guy named "ShowKing24" has already finished the whole thing and posted the exact requirements for all 10 eggs. Use that resource. Don't be a hero.
🔗 Read more: How to get better at FC 25 Reddit: The Crowdsourced Secrets Pros Won't Tell You
Is the Final Reward Worth It?
Every year, the "Golden Egg" reward is a polarizing card. Sometimes it’s a high-contact hitter with no speed. Sometimes it’s a pitcher with a funky delivery that makes people rage-quit in the third inning.
But even if the card doesn't fit your "god squad," the program usually gives out a ton of Packs, Stubs, and XP. If you’re trying to finish the Season 1 XP Reward Path, you literally cannot afford to skip the MLB The Show 25 egg hunt. The XP chunks attached to these eggs are massive.
What to Do Right Now
If the program just dropped, stop what you’re doing and head to the Conquest map first. It is the most time-consuming part of the MLB The Show 25 egg hunt, and it’s where you can grind out most of the "Tally X amount of stats" missions simultaneously.
Check your inventory for any "Egg Hunt" vouchers or items. Sometimes SDS hides things in plain sight within the packs you’ve already opened.
Next Steps for Completion:
✨ Don't miss: New York State Lottery Results Midday: Why You’re Probably Checking the Wrong Numbers
- Audit your lineup: Ensure every player contributes to an active Egg Hunt mission.
- Target the CPU first: Knock out the "Beat Team X" missions on Rookie or Veteran to build confidence and stack stats quickly.
- Focus on the Event: If there is a limited-time Egg Hunt event, do that before it expires, as those eggs are often the hardest to get later.
- Check the "Moments" tab: Often, a single, solitary moment is tucked away under a "Seasonal" category that awards an egg.
Basically, just keep playing. The eggs will come. Just don't throw your controller when you give up a 450-foot bomb to a CPU-controlled Joey Gallo on a "hidden" mission. It happens to the best of us.