It is rare. Usually, when a developer releases DLC, you get a few extra guns, a map pack, or maybe a flashy three-hour mission that feels like it was cut from the main game just to squeeze an extra twenty bucks out of your wallet. Hearts of Stone Witcher 3 isn't that. It’s different. Honestly, CD Projekt Red managed to tell a story here that is tighter, darker, and more emotionally draining than the hunt for Ciri ever was. You aren't chasing a world-ending prophecy this time. You’re just a guy trying not to lose his soul to a man who can stop time by tapping a spoon against a table.
Geralt is a professional. We know this. But in this expansion, he’s out of his depth.
You start out thinking it’s a standard monster contract. A giant toad is living in the sewers of Oxenfurt. Simple, right? Kill the frog, get the gold, go home. But within an hour, Geralt is a prisoner on a ship headed for Ofir, his face is branded with a glowing mark, and he’s indentured to Gaunter O'Dimm. The pacing is frantic. Then it slows to a crawl. Then it breaks your heart.
The Man of Glass and the Problem with Immortality
Gaunter O'Dimm is the best villain in the entire Witcher franchise. Better than Eredin. Better than Detlaff. Why? Because you can’t hit him with a silver sword. He is an enigma. If you pay attention during the main game, you actually meet him at the very beginning in White Orchard. He’s the "Master Mirror" who tells you where to find Yennefer. He was there the whole time, hiding in plain sight.
The core of Hearts of Stone Witcher 3 revolves around the pact between O'Dimm and a nobleman named Olgierd von Everec. Olgierd is a complicated mess. He’s immortal, but he has a "heart of stone." He can’t feel anything. No love, no fear, no taste for fine wine. It’s a classic "deal with the devil" trope, but written with such grit that it feels fresh. Olgierd isn't necessarily a bad guy, he’s just a man who made a desperate choice and lost his humanity in the process.
Most players struggle with the moral choice at the end. Do you let O'Dimm take Olgierd’s soul, or do you risk your own to save a man who has done terrible things? There is no "good" ending. Just shades of gray. That’s the Witcher brand.
A Wedding, a Ghost, and a Heist
The mission structure in this DLC is wild. One minute you’re being possessed by the ghost of Olgierd’s dead brother, Vlodimir, and forced to attend a wedding. This is probably the funniest writing in the whole series. Seeing Geralt—the grim, brooding butcher of Blaviken—doing a backflip and hitting on bridesmaids while possessed by a hedonistic ghost is gold. It’s a necessary breather.
Then the tone shifts. Hard.
The heist mission, "Open Sesame!", brings a bit of Ocean’s Eleven to the Continent. You’re recruiting a crew to break into a high-security vault. You have to choose between two different burglars, and your choice actually matters for how the job goes down. It’s small-scale compared to the Wild Hunt, but the stakes feel more personal. You aren't saving the world; you’re just trying to fulfill a dead man’s wishes so you can get a brand off your face.
The Painted World of Iris von Everec
If you want to talk about art direction, we have to talk about "Scenes from a Marriage." This quest is a masterpiece. You enter the painted world of Olgierd’s wife, Iris. The visuals change to look like moving oil paintings. It’s haunting. It’s beautiful. It’s also incredibly depressing.
You learn the truth about Olgierd and Iris. It wasn't a fairy tale. It was a domestic nightmare fueled by black magic and regret. The boss fight against Iris’s Greatest Fear—a multi-armed, teleporting version of Olgierd—is one of the most mechanically challenging fights in the game. You can’t just mash the attack button. You need your signs. You need your oils. You need to be patient.
The "Rose of Remembrance" choice at the end of this quest is one of those moments where you just stare at the screen for five minutes trying to decide what to do. Taking the rose ends Iris's suffering but effectively erases her existence. Leaving it keeps her in a loop of eternal sorrow. There is no win here.
Gameplay Mechanics: Runewrights and Viper Gear
It isn't all just "sad dad" stories and demon deals. Hearts of Stone Witcher 3 introduced some actual mechanical depth to the late-game experience.
- The Runewright: This guy is a money pit. You’ll spend thousands of crowns just to get him started, but the enchantments he offers are game-changers. Putting "Severance" on your swords increases the range of Whirl and Rend. It makes Geralt feel like a whirlwind of death.
- The Viper School Gear: Finally, we get a high-level version of the starting armor. It looks sleek. It’s practical. It has high poison resistance, which is great if you’re running an alchemy build.
- New Monsters: Arachnomorphs are the stuff of nightmares. They move fast, they web you up, and they retreat when you get close. They require a completely different tactical approach than a standard drowner or ghoul.
The difficulty spike in this DLC is real. If you jump into it right after finishing the main story without being properly leveled, the Toad Prince will absolutely wreck you. He’s a gear check. If your build is sloppy, he’ll punish you for it.
✨ Don't miss: Lemony Snicket’s A Series of Unfortunate Events Game: What Most People Get Wrong
Why We Are Still Talking About It in 2026
The reason this expansion stays in the conversation is simple: it’s a tight narrative. The main game is sprawling and sometimes loses its way in Skellige. Hearts of Stone Witcher 3 stays focused. It’s a character study of three people: Geralt, Olgierd, and Gaunter O'Dimm.
We see a side of Geralt that is more vulnerable. He’s being manipulated by forces he doesn't understand. He can’t just out-muscle Master Mirror. He has to out-think him. The final confrontation in O'Dimm's pocket dimension is a riddle, not a sword fight. That’s a bold move for an action RPG. It trusts the player to be smart.
Shani also returns. For fans of the first Witcher game, her inclusion wasn't just fanservice. She provides a grounded, human perspective in a story filled with ghosts and demons. Her relationship with Geralt feels more "real" than the high-stakes drama with Yen or Triss. It’s a quiet romance that reminds you why Geralt does what he does—to protect people like her.
Actionable Insights for Your Next Playthrough:
If you’re booting up a new save or going through New Game Plus, here is how to get the most out of this content. First, do not ignore the "Taxman" in Oxenfurt. If you’ve been using exploits to get money, he’s going to call you out on it. It’s a hilarious fourth-wall-breaking moment. Second, make sure you collect all the pieces of the Viper gear during the heist mission and the visit to the von Everec estate; you can’t go back for them later.
For the best narrative experience, try to complete this DLC before you finish the main quest line. There is unique dialogue if you talk to Gaunter O'Dimm about Ciri. He won't give you a straight answer, obviously, but the hints he drops are chilling and add a whole new layer to the "Master Mirror" persona.
Lastly, invest in the Runewright early. The "Deflection" enchantment, which reflects all arrows, makes dealing with bandit camps significantly less annoying. It’s expensive, but in the long run, it saves you a lot of frustration during the "Blood and Wine" expansion that usually follows. Focus on your alchemy. Superior Golden Oriole makes the Toad Prince fight a joke because the poison actually heals you instead of killing you. Use the tools the game gives you. Don't just swing your sword and hope for the best.
Hearts of Stone isn't just an add-on. It’s the soul of the game. It’s a reminder that in the world of the Witcher, the most dangerous monsters aren't the ones with claws—they’re the ones who offer you exactly what you wished for.