You remember the barn. That specific, heavy-duty sense of dread when the floorboards creak and you realize the old man looking at you isn't just "old-school"—he's dangerously hopeful. If you played Telltale’s The Walking Dead Season 1 back in 2012, Hershel Greene was likely your first real taste of how badly things could go wrong, even when you try to do the right thing.
Most people know Hershel from the AMC show as the moral compass, the wise mentor with the beard who eventually met a tragic end at the prison. But the Hershel Greene walking dead game version is a different beast entirely. This isn't the TV version. It’s the comic canon version, and honestly? He’s a lot more "prickly" than the guy Scott Wilson played.
Why the Game Version of Hershel Feels So Different
Basically, the Telltale game is set in the comic book universe, not the TV universe. That’s why Hershel looks a bit younger, has a different hair color, and carries himself with a much sharper edge. When Lee and Clementine stumble onto his farm in Episode 1, "A New Day," the world hasn't fully collapsed yet. It’s day two. People are still calling the walkers "monsters" or "sick people."
Hershel is a veterinarian by trade, and in the game, he's voiced by Chuck Kourouklis. He’s not the "Grandpa of the Apocalypse" here. He’s a grieving widower trying to keep his family safe while stubbornly refusing to believe the world is actually ending.
The Interrogation in the Barn
One of the most stressful parts of meeting Hershel is the "truth" mechanic. While he’s bandaging Lee’s leg, he grills you. He asks how you got hurt, who Clementine is, and why you’re out there.
If you lie? He knows.
He’s a man who has spent his life reading animals and people. If you tell him you’re Clementine’s neighbor or that you were just "passing through," he catches the contradictions. It’s a brilliant bit of writing because it establishes right away that in this world, your reputation with NPCs actually matters. Even if he kicks you out regardless, his parting words about "the honesty of strangers" stick with you for the rest of the series.
The Choice: Saving Duck vs. Saving Shawn
This is the big one. The moment that defines your relationship with Kenny for the next three seasons.
Shawn Greene, Hershel's son, is working on the fence with Duck (Kenny’s son). Walkers attack. You have a split second to choose who to help.
- If you save Duck: You’re prioritizing a child, which feels right, but you’re leaving Shawn to get torn apart by walkers under a tractor.
- If you save Shawn: You try to lift the tractor, but the walkers are too many. Kenny grabs Duck and runs, leaving you—and Shawn—to fail.
The catch? Shawn dies no matter what. It’s a scripted death. But the fallout is what matters. If you don't try to save Shawn, Hershel’s rage is cold and absolute. He blames Kenny for being a coward and he blames you for not helping his "boy."
What Most People Miss About Shawn’s Death
There is a massive piece of lore hidden here that ties directly into the comics. In the comics, when Rick Grimes eventually arrives at the farm months later, he discovers Hershel has been keeping "turned" family members in the barn.
Shawn is one of them.
The game shows us the exact moment Shawn turns. When Hershel carries his son's body away, he isn't going to bury him. He’s going to put him in that barn. It’s the origin story of one of the most famous (and messed up) plot points in the entire franchise. Knowing that Shawn is rotting in that barn while Lee and Kenny drive away is a heavy realization.
Fact-Checking the "Crossover"
Wait, if this is the comic universe, where are Maggie and Beth?
Honestly, they’re just inside the house. Because the game focuses so tightly on Lee’s perspective, you only interact with the family members who are outside. Maggie is mentioned by name, and if you look at the family photos in the house, you can see the scale of the Greene family. In the comics, Hershel had seven children. The show trimmed that down significantly, but the game stays true to the larger, more chaotic family dynamic that Robert Kirkman originally wrote.
📖 Related: Why Call of Duty Black Ops Multiplayer Weapons Always Break the Meta
Actionable Insights for Your Next Playthrough:
- Be Honest: If you want the "best" interaction with Hershel, tell the truth about the police car and the accident. He won't trust you more, but he’ll respect you slightly more.
- Save Shawn for the Dialogue: Even though Shawn dies, trying to save him changes your dialogue options with Kenny in Episode 3. You can actually call Kenny out for being a coward at the farm when you’re arguing on the train.
- Observe the Background: Look at the barn doors before you leave. The foreshadowing for what’s about to happen inside that building is subtle but chilling.
The Hershel Greene we see in the game is a man at the very start of his downward spiral. He hasn't become the leader Rick meets yet. He's just a dad who lost his son and is about to make a series of very bad, very human mistakes.
Next Steps for TWD Fans:
Check your save file in Episode 3 to see how you handled the "train argument" with Kenny. If you helped Shawn at the farm, use that leverage to make Kenny see reason about Duck. If you're looking for more comic-to-game connections, keep an eye on Glenn’s dialogue before he leaves for Atlanta—it sets up his first appearance in the comic books perfectly.