Trading in Adopt Me is a total adrenaline rush. You’re standing in the middle of a crowded Adoption Center, trade requests are popping up every three seconds, and someone just threw a Shadow Dragon into the window. Your heart is racing. Is your offer fair? Are you overpaying? This is exactly why almost every serious player keeps an adopt me value list open in a side tab. But here’s the thing: if you follow those lists blindly, you’re probably going to lose your best pets.
Values change. Fast.
The economy of Adopt Me isn’t like a standard RPG where a sword has a set price. It’s more like a chaotic stock market run by pre-teens and hardcore collectors. One day a pet is the "it" thing, and the next, everyone is panic-trading it for whatever they can get. Understanding how to read these lists—and when to ignore them—is the difference between building a Mega Neon dream team and ending up with a backpack full of Lunar Oxen that nobody wants.
Why Every Adopt Me Value List is Technically Wrong
Let's be real for a second. No single list can ever be 100% accurate. Why? Because value is subjective. You might see a site claiming a Frost Dragon is worth "X" amount of points, but if the person you're trading with absolutely hates dragons and loves Owls, those points don't matter.
Most popular resources, like Adopt Me Real Values or the various community-run spreadsheets on Discord, use a point system. They try to quantify "demand." But demand is fickle. A pet can have high "value" on paper but low "demand" in the server. Try trading a Diamond Griffin. On paper, it’s a legendary pet from a long-term egg. In reality? Most players will barely give you a decent ultra-rare for it because the demand is non-existent.
The most reliable lists are usually the ones updated daily by high-tier traders who spend 10+ hours a day in "Rich Servers." They track what people are actually saying yes to. If you're looking at a list that hasn't been touched in two weeks, it's basically ancient history.
The Great "Preppy" Value Shift
You can't talk about values without talking about the "preppy" values. This is a massive sub-culture in the game that completely ignores traditional rarity.
Suddenly, a Cow—which is just a Rare pet from the Farm Egg—became worth more than many Legendaries. Why? Because it’s "cute" and fits a certain aesthetic. If you're using an adopt me value list that only calculates rarity based on drop rates, you’re going to get sharked. Sharking is when an experienced player takes advantage of a "noob" who doesn't realize their "low rarity" pet is actually a high-demand collector's item.
Understanding the "Big Three" Value Metrics
When you're staring at a trade window, you need to mentally check three different boxes.
- Rarity/Age: This is the baseline. How old is the egg? Is the pet still obtainable? A Shadow Dragon is the king because it cost Robux in 2019 and will never return.
- Demand: Does it look cool? Is it a "preppy" favorite? Pets like the Strawberry Shortcake Bat Dragon have insane demand regardless of their actual "math" value.
- Liquidity: How easy is it to trade away? This is where many people mess up. They trade one high-tier pet for five "okay" pets that equal the same value. Now they're stuck with five pets that nobody wants to offer for. You want "liquid" pets—pets that everyone is looking for.
How Neon and Mega Neon Multipliers Actually Work
It’s not just $4 \times 1 = 4$.
Making a Neon takes ages. You have to age up four pets from Newborn to Full Grown. That time investment adds a "labor cost" to the pet. Usually, a Neon is worth a bit more than four of the same pet, but only if the pet is high-tier. For common pets, a Neon might only be worth three decent Rares.
Mega Neons are even weirder. A Mega Neon Legendary is often the "holy grail" of any adopt me value list. But watch out for the "Mega downgrade" trap. Sometimes, it’s actually easier to trade four Neon Crows than it is to trade one Mega Crow. Why? Because fewer people have an offer big enough for the Mega. You limit your market when you go too high.
Common Scams Involving Value Lists
This is the dark side. Scammers love to create "fake" value lists or point to obscure websites they've manipulated to make their bad offer look good.
"Look at this site, it says my Minion Egg is worth your Frost Dragon!"
No. It isn't. If someone is pushing a specific, weird-looking adopt me value list on you during a trade, cancel it immediately. Stick to the well-known community trackers. Sites like Hennessyxy's Value List (which used to be a staple on Reddit) or the Moxxi/Bolt lists have been vetted by thousands of players. Even then, use them as a guide, not a law.
Another trick is the "Overpay" lure. Someone offers you a huge "overpay" on a value list for your high-tier pet, but they ask you to add a "small" pet first or use a middleman you don't know. If a deal feels too good to be true based on the current market values, it's a scam. Period.
💡 You might also like: Why PC Game Cheats GTA Vice City Still Rule the Streets of 80s Miami
The Psychology of the "Win"
Every trade has a winner and a loser, right? Not necessarily.
A "Small Win" (SW) is when you get slightly more value than you gave. A "Big Win" (BW) is when you basically robbed them (fairly). A "Fair" (F) trade is the goal for long-term reputation. If you're always hunting for "Big Wins," people in rich servers will stop trading with you. They'll label you as a "Value Hugger."
Sometimes, taking a "Small Lose" (SL) is actually smart. If you're trading a hard-to-move pet (low demand) for a pet that is slightly lower in value but has insane demand, you’ve actually improved your position. You now have an asset you can flip quickly.
High-Tier Values: The "High Roller" Club
Once you get into the realm of Giraffes, Bat Dragons, and Shadow Dragons, the math changes. These pets don't follow the same rules as a Neon Dog.
- Shadow Dragon: Still the undisputed heavyweight.
- Bat Dragon: Closing the gap. Many people prefer the look of the Bat, so the "gap" in value is shrinking every year.
- Giraffe: Slowly slipping. It’s old, it’s rare, but the demand isn't what it used to be compared to the dragons.
- Frost Dragon: The "unit of measurement." Most high-tier adopt me value list creators use the Frost Dragon as $1.0$. Everything else is measured in "Frosts." A Shadow might be worth $2.5$ Frosts, for example.
If you're new, don't worry about these yet. Focus on "Potions."
Ride and Fly potions are the currency of the middle class. They have a very stable value. If you have a few Ride potions, you can almost always get a decent legendary pet from someone who is "potion broke."
💡 You might also like: Cleaning Out the Days Gone Cemetery Nest Without Getting Ripped Apart
Tips for Staying Ahead of the Market
Stop hanging out in standard servers. If you want to see what pets are actually worth, you need to join "Trading Servers." Look for servers that are full (48/48 players). These are where the real moves happen.
Observe. Don't trade for the first 10 minutes. Just watch the chat. What are people asking for? What are they screaming "ABC FOR NEON TURTLE" about? If you see five people looking for a Turtle and zero people selling one, the value of that Turtle is currently higher than any adopt me value list will tell you.
Also, pay attention to the update calendar. When a new egg is about to drop (like the transition from Urban to Desert to the next), the "old" pets briefly spike in value as people realize they can't get them anymore. Then they dip. Then, years later, they skyrocket. It’s all about the long game.
The "No-Potion" Paradox
Here is a weird one for you: A high-tier pet (like a Parrot) with no potions on it is actually worth more than a Fly-Ride version to collectors.
Why? Because most people put potions on them immediately back in the day. "No-pot" high-tiers are incredibly rare. It’s like a "mint condition" toy still in the box. If you find an old legendary without any potions, do NOT feed it a potion. You will literally be erasing value.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Trade
Don't just jump in. Be calculated. The players who have the best inventories aren't just lucky; they're disciplined. They know the numbers, but they also know the people.
- Check multiple sources: Compare at least two different value lists before committing to a high-tier trade.
- Verify the "Demand" factor: Ask yourself, "If I get this pet, can I trade it away in 5 minutes?" If the answer is no, ask for an overpay.
- Ignore the "Trust Me" vibes: If someone says "I'm over," verify it yourself. Their list might be out of date or intentionally misleading.
- Keep your "No-Pot" pets clean: If you have an old pet from 2019-2020 with no tricks or potions, keep it that way until you find a serious collector.
- Use Frost Values for big trades: Once you're trading for things like Owls or Parrots, stop thinking in "pets" and start thinking in "Frost Dragon fractions." It makes the math much cleaner.
Trading is a skill. Like any skill, you’ll get better the more you do it. You’ll probably make a few bad trades starting out—everyone does. I once traded a Crow for a bunch of stuff that turned out to be worthless. It happens. You learn, you update your mental adopt me value list, and you move on to the next server. The market never sleeps, and there's always someone looking for exactly what you have in your backpack.