So, you’re scrolling through Netflix, craving that specific brand of Stephen King dread. You want to see Church the cat looking ragged. You want to see a toddler in a yellow raincoat doing things no toddler should do. But here’s the thing: finding a Pet Sematary movie on Netflix is a total roll of the dice depending on where you actually live. Licensing deals are a mess. One day it's there, the next it's gone, replaced by a generic "titles related to" screen that feels like a slap in the face.
It’s frustrating.
Most people don't realize that there are actually four distinct films under this umbrella now. You’ve got the 1989 classic that traumatized a generation with Zelda in the back room. There’s the 1992 sequel with Edward Furlong that’s honestly better than people give it credit for. Then came the 2019 big-budget remake with Jason Clarke, and most recently, the 2023 prequel Bloodlines. If you’re searching specifically for a Pet Sematary movie on Netflix, you’re likely hitting a wall because Paramount—who owns the rights to the franchise—has been pulling their heavy hitters over to Paramount+ to beef up their own library.
The Streaming Shuffle: Where the Movies Actually Live
Let’s be real. Netflix isn't the horror powerhouse it used to be for licensed content. They’ve pivoted hard toward "Netflix Originals." Because Pet Sematary is a Paramount property, it’s rarely a permanent resident on the "Big N."
In the United States, as of early 2026, the Pet Sematary movie on Netflix situation is usually "null and void." You’ll find Pet Sematary: Bloodlines almost exclusively on Paramount+. The 2019 remake pops up on Max or Hulu occasionally. If you're in the UK or Canada, sometimes the 1989 original drifts onto Netflix for a few months during the "Spooky Season" (October), but it never stays. It’s a nomadic franchise. It moves around like the Wendigo in the woods.
Why does this happen? Money.
Licensing a Stephen King property costs a fortune. Netflix would rather spend that cash on Stranger Things or a new Mike Flanagan series than pay Paramount a recurring fee for a 35-year-old movie about a cursed burial ground. If you see it on your dashboard, watch it immediately. Don't put it in your "My List" and wait. It’ll be gone by Tuesday.
💡 You might also like: Why 10,000 Reasons Lyrics Still Hit Different After All These Years
Why We Keep Coming Back to the Micmac Burying Ground
What is it about this story? Honestly, it’s probably King’s darkest work. Even he was scared of it. He famously stuck the manuscript in a drawer and didn't want to publish it because he thought he’d gone too far with the death of a child.
The 1989 film, directed by Mary Lambert, captured that gloom perfectly. It’s got a raw, low-budget feel that makes the supernatural elements feel dirtier and more dangerous. Fred Gwynne as Jud Crandall is iconic. "Sometimes, dead is better." We all say it. We all know the accent. It’s burned into the collective consciousness of horror fans.
When the 2019 remake hit theaters, fans were split. It changed a major plot point—switching which child dies—and while some appreciated the fresh take, purists hated it. But that’s the beauty of horror. We argue about it. We rank them. And then we go back and watch the one we hate anyway just to feel something.
The Problem with "Related Content"
If you search for Pet Sematary movie on Netflix and it isn't there, the algorithm tries to trick you. It’ll show you Eli, The Ritual, or maybe In the Tall Grass. These are great! In the Tall Grass is actually a Stephen King/Joe Hill adaptation. It’s got that same "trapped in nature" vibe. But it isn't Pet Sematary. It doesn’t have the sour ground.
- The Ritual: Good if you want forest monsters.
- 1922: Another King adaptation on Netflix that deals with guilt and buried secrets.
- Gerald's Game: High-tier King, but strictly psychological.
If you’re desperate for that specific "resurrection gone wrong" trope, 1922 is your best bet on the platform. It’s bleak. It’s got rats. It’s got a husband making terrible choices. It’s the spiritual cousin to Louis Creed’s descent into madness.
Breaking Down the 2023 Prequel: Bloodlines
Recently, Pet Sematary: Bloodlines dropped. It stars David Duchovny and Henry Thomas. It’s a prequel set in 1969, focused on a young Jud Crandall. Most people searching for a Pet Sematary movie on Netflix are actually looking for this one because the marketing was everywhere.
The reviews were... mixed.
Some critics felt it explained things that didn't need explaining. Do we really need to know the origin of the curse? Maybe not. Mystery is usually scarier. But it did dive deep into the lore of Ludlow, Maine. It showed that the town was rotten long before the Creeds showed up. If you have a Paramount+ subscription, it’s worth a look for the gore alone. If you’re waiting for it to hit Netflix? Don’t hold your breath. Paramount keeps their "Originals" close to the chest.
How to Actually Watch Pet Sematary Right Now
If the Pet Sematary movie on Netflix search failed you, you have a few practical moves. You don't have to just give up and watch The Office for the tenth time.
- Check the "JustWatch" App: This is a lifesaver. You type in the movie, and it tells you exactly which service has it in your specific country. It saves you ten minutes of clicking through apps with a remote.
- The "Grandfathered" Physical Media: This is why people still buy 4K Blu-rays. No licensing agreement can take a disc off your shelf. The 1989 version looks incredible in 4K—the colors of the Pet Sematary itself really pop.
- Digital Rental: It’s usually $3.99 on Amazon or Apple. It’s less than a latte. If you really want to see Gage Creed with a scalpel, just pay the four bucks.
Comparing the Versions
The 1989 original wins on atmosphere. It’s got that 80s grit. The 2019 version wins on technical acting—Amy Seimetz is phenomenal as Rachel Creed, portraying grief in a way that feels uncomfortably real. Bloodlines wins on world-building.
The 1992 sequel is just weird. It’s got Clancy Brown (Mr. Krabs himself) chewing the scenery. It’s more of a "fun" horror movie than a "depressing" one. It’s perfect for a Friday night with pizza, whereas the original is more of a "stare at the wall in silence afterward" type of experience.
The Cultural Impact of the Sour Ground
Why does this story persist? Why are we still searching for it on every streaming platform?
It’s about the "What If."
Everyone has lost someone. A pet, a parent, a child. King taps into that universal, desperate desire to have just five more minutes. He takes that beautiful sentiment and turns it into a nightmare. He reminds us that the barrier between life and death exists for a reason. When Louis Creed ignores the warnings—from Victor Pascow’s ghost or Jud’s stories—he isn't just being a "dumb horror movie protagonist." He’s a man blinded by grief. We relate to him, and that’s what makes it hurt.
The Pet Sematary movie on Netflix (when it’s actually there) remains one of the most-watched horror titles because it’s a "foundational" scare. It’s like The Exorcist or The Shining. It’s a rite of passage.
Pro-Tips for Horror Fans on Netflix
Since the selection is always changing, you have to be smart about how you use the search bar. Netflix uses "hidden codes" for genres. If you type "8711" into the search bar, it pulls up the entire "Slasher and Serial Killer" subgenre. "10944" gives you "Cult Horror."
Often, if Pet Sematary isn't available, searching for "Stephen King" will bring up the Netflix-exclusive King movies like Mr. Harrigan's Phone or In the Tall Grass. They aren't the same, but they share that Maine-inspired DNA.
Also, keep an eye on the "Leaving Soon" section. Netflix usually posts a list at the end of every month. If you see a Pet Sematary movie on Netflix listed there, it’s your final warning.
Your Next Steps for a Spooky Night
Stop wasting time scrolling. If you’ve searched for Pet Sematary movie on Netflix and found nothing, don't let it ruin the vibe.
First, check if you have a library card. Most people forget that apps like Libby or Hoopla let you stream movies for free through your local library. They often have the 1989 Pet Sematary available because it’s a legacy title.
Second, if you're a die-hard King fan, look into the Kingcast podcast. They have episodes breaking down every single one of these movies, including the 2023 prequel. It’s the best way to deep-dive into the lore without having to deal with the headache of streaming rights.
Finally, if you do find it on a service, watch it with the lights off. No phones. The tension in Pet Sematary relies on the quiet moments—the wind in the trees, the sound of a truck on the highway. Don't let a stray TikTok notification ruin the jump scare.
The ground is sour, but the movies are still great. Happy hunting.