You’re standing in a filthy bathroom, staring at a mirror. The man looking back at you, James Sunderland, looks like he hasn’t slept in weeks. Or maybe years. He’s 29, but the weight of the world makes him look 40. He just got a letter from his wife, Mary. The problem? Mary has been dead for three years. Or has she?
That’s how one of the greatest psychological horror stories starts. It isn't just about jump scares. It’s about a man who is "figuratively and literal fog," according to Mike Druker. James isn't your typical hero. He isn't a badass like Leon Kennedy or a powerhouse like Kratos. He’s a store clerk. He’s a guy who jumps down literal bottomless holes because he has nothing left to lose.
James Sunderland: What Most People Get Wrong
There’s a massive debate that’s been raging since 2001 and flared up again with the 2024 remake. Some people say James was "emotionless" in the original game because the PS2 couldn't handle facial expressions. That’s just flat-out wrong. Takayoshi Sato, the original CGI director, actually fought to make James look dissociated and fatigued on purpose.
✨ Don't miss: Why Die in a Fire FNAF Still Hits Different a Decade Later
James isn't stoic because of bad tech. He’s stoic because he’s suffering from a massive psychotic break. His brain is basically trying to "delete" the memory of what he did. Honestly, he’s a classic case of an unreliable narrator. You’re playing as a guy who is lying to himself every second you're holding the controller.
The Maria Paradox
Then there’s Maria. She looks like Mary, talks like Mary, but she’s... "spicier." She wears a cheetah print skirt and acts seductive. She is a manifestation of James’s repressed sexual frustration and his idealized version of his wife. She dies. Then she comes back. Then she dies again. Every time she dies in front of him, it’s the town—or James’s own mind—forcing him to relive the trauma of losing Mary over and over. It’s an endless loop of punishment.
Why the Fog Matters
In most games, fog is a way to hide loading screens. In Silent Hill 2, the fog is James’s mind. It’s his suppression. He can’t see the truth, so he can’t see the town.
Did you notice that every character sees a different version of the town?
- Angela Orosco sees everything on fire because of the abuse she suffered.
- Eddie Dombrowski sees a world full of people mocking him.
- Laura, the little girl, doesn't see any monsters at all because she has no guilt.
James sees monsters that are fleshy, twitchy, and often restrained. The Lying Figure, that thing that looks like it’s in a fleshy straitjacket? That’s James. He’s emotionally trapped. He’s bound by his own secrets.
The Pyramid Head Connection
Everyone loves Pyramid Head. He’s the series icon now. But for James, Pyramid Head is a very specific, personal executioner. He wears a giant metal "cage" on his head. It’s heavy. It’s a burden. Just like James’s guilt.
When you see Pyramid Head "interacting" with other monsters, it isn't just random horror imagery. It’s a reflection of James’s darker, more violent urges and the shame he feels about them. Pyramid Head exists because James wants to be punished. He feels like a murderer, so he creates a monster to hunt him down and finish the job.
The Moment of Truth
When James finally watches that videotape in the Lakeview Hotel, the fog lifts. He remembers. He didn't lose Mary to a disease three years ago. He killed her. He smothered her with a pillow because he couldn't handle the "burden" of her illness anymore. Or maybe he did it to end her suffering. The game never gives you a 100% clear answer on his motive, and that’s why it’s brilliant. He’s a "remorseful murderer," a man who did something monstrous out of a mix of love, exhaustion, and selfish desire for his old life back.
How to Understand the Endings
The way you play determines what happens to James. It’s one of the few games where your "vibe" actually changes the story.
If you constantly check Mary’s letter and ignore Maria, you might get the Leave ending. This is the "good" path where James accepts his actions and tries to move on.
But if you play recklessly, staying at low health and examining the knife Angela gave you, you’re signaling that James is suicidal. That leads to the In Water ending. It’s devastating. James decides he can’t live with the truth and drives his car into the lake to be with Mary forever.
💡 You might also like: Minecraft How to Make Roller Coaster Builds Actually Feel Fast
Then there’s the Maria ending. James chooses the fantasy. He leaves the town with Maria, but as they walk away, she starts coughing. It’s a hint that the cycle is just going to start all over again. He hasn't learned a thing.
Actionable Insights for Players
If you're diving into the remake or revisiting the original, keep these things in mind to get the most out of James's story:
- Pay attention to the corpses. Many of the bodies you find in the streets of Silent Hill actually use James’s character model. It’s a subtle hint that he’s already "dead" inside or seeing his own demise everywhere.
- Listen to the radio. The static isn't just a monster detector; it’s the sound of James’s fractured psyche trying to tune into a reality he’s blocked out.
- Check the map notes. James scribbles on the map. In the original, his handwriting and notes get more frantic as his mental state deteriorates.
- Watch the eyes. In the remake, Bloober Team used modern facial capture. Watch James’s eyes during the "Leave" ending versus the "Maria" ending. The subtle shifts in how he looks at the women tell you everything about his level of denial.
James Sunderland remains one of gaming's most complex figures because he isn't a villain you can just hate. He’s a deeply flawed human being who broke under the pressure of grief and resentment. Whether he deserves redemption or a watery grave is entirely up to how you see him through the fog.