Johnny Football. The name itself carries a weight of "what ifs" and "could've beens" that still haunts sports bars from College Station to Cleveland. But if you really want to understand the chaotic arc of the former Heisman winner, you have to look at the women who were in the passenger seat while the wheels were coming off.
Manziel’s dating history isn’t just a list of names. It’s a roadmap of his highest highs and his absolute rock bottoms. Most recently, the world watched him reunite with his ex-wife, Bre Tiesi, on the 2024 season of Selling Sunset. It was weird, right? Watching a former NFL star get house-hunting advice from the woman he reportedly cheated on years ago.
But Bre is only one chapter. From the legal battles with Colleen Crowley to the recent Valentine’s Day split with Josie Canseco, the "Johnny Manziel ex girlfriend" search usually uncovers more drama than a season of Succession.
🔗 Read more: Machine Gun Kelly and Megan Fox: What’s Actually Happening Right Now
The Bre Tiesi Era: From Paris to Divorce Parties
If you’ve watched Selling Sunset, you know Bre Tiesi as the confident, no-nonsense agent with a son by Nick Cannon. But back in 2016, she was the "saving grace" for a Manziel who had just been booted from the NFL.
They moved fast. Like, "engaged in Paris after a few months" fast. Johnny told anyone who would listen that Bre was the one who pulled him out of his downward spiral. They had a private courthouse wedding in 2018, but by 2019, the whole thing imploded.
Bre didn't hold back on social media. She basically told followers that "vows were broken," hinting heavily at infidelity. By the time the divorce was finalized in 2021, she threw a massive "divorce party" in Miami with a cake that said "I do, I did, I'm officially done."
💡 You might also like: Kelly Ripa Oscar Dress: What Most People Get Wrong About Her Red Carpet Style
Why the 2024 Reunion Mattered
On Selling Sunset, Manziel actually showed a level of self-awareness we haven't seen before. He admitted to being "a lost, depressed kid" who was "drinking every night" behind her back. It felt like a rare moment of genuine accountability.
The Darkest Chapter: Colleen Crowley
We can't talk about Johnny’s past without talking about Colleen Crowley. This wasn't just a breakup; it was a legal and personal catastrophe that effectively ended his NFL career before it could even start.
In early 2016, Crowley filed an affidavit that was harrowing to read. She alleged that Manziel dragged her by the hair, hit her so hard she lost hearing in one ear, and threatened to kill both of them.
- The Outcome: A misdemeanor assault charge.
- The Deal: Manziel reached a "conditional dismissal" agreement. He had to take anger management and stay away from her for two years.
Crowley has largely stayed out of the spotlight since then, which, honestly, is understandable. That period remains the most somber reminder of how volatile things were during the peak "Johnny Football" years.
The Recent Split: Josie Canseco (2024-2025)
Just when it looked like Johnny had finally settled into a "normal" life, things shifted again. In 2024, he started dating Josie Canseco, the daughter of MLB legend Jose Canseco.
On paper, they were a celebrity match made in heaven. Both grew up in the shadow of famous, sometimes controversial fathers. Josie, a Victoria’s Secret model, seemed to give him the "princess treatment" he never quite mastered in previous relationships. They went Instagram-official at Stagecoach and even posted some pretty intimate (and later deleted) videos for his 32nd birthday in late 2024.
The Breakup: It ended right around Valentine's Day 2025. Reports suggested that while Johnny was a "great boyfriend," he still had "work to do on himself."
It’s a recurring theme. The "work" is never quite finished.
Other Notable Names in the Mix
- Kenzie Werner: A Houston-based model he dated around 2022-2023. This one got messy when photos of her with facial injuries appeared on her Instagram with a caption blaming Johnny. She later claimed she was "hacked" and that the photos were unrelated to him.
- Lauren Hanley: Way back in his Texas A&M days. She was the prototype for the "Johnny Football" girlfriend—blonde, model, and often seen with him at clubs during his Heisman run.
Why We Still Care
Honestly? It's the train wreck factor. People want to see if he’s actually changed. Each new "Johnny Manziel ex girlfriend" represents a new attempt at a comeback. Whether it's the 2023 Netflix documentary Untold: Johnny Football or his appearances on reality TV, we are looking for a redemption arc that hasn't quite stuck yet.
If you’re following his story, the pattern is clear: a high-octane start, a period of public devotion, and a quiet (or loud) exit once the old habits creep back in.
✨ Don't miss: Malcolm-Jamal Warner Net Worth: What Most People Get Wrong
Moving Forward
If you are looking for lessons from the Manziel saga, look at the women who moved on. Bre Tiesi built a powerhouse career in real estate. Josie Canseco continues to dominate the modeling world. The insight here isn't about the quarterback; it's about the resilience of the people who survive the whirlwind of a high-profile, high-chaos relationship.
Check out the latest episodes of Selling Sunset for the most recent look at how Johnny handles his past, or follow the social media updates of his recent exes to see how they've successfully pivoted away from the "Johnny Football" shadow.