You know that feeling when you're sitting on the Belt Parkway, staring at the bumper of a 2014 Honda Civic, wondering if you'll ever see your family again? That is the quintessential Long Island to Staten Island experience. It’s a trek. It's barely 20 miles from the edge of Nassau County to the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge, but those miles are some of the most psychologically taxing stretches of asphalt in the United States.
It's basically a gauntlet.
People who don't live in New York think of it as a quick hop between two suburbs. They’re wrong. Honestly, crossing from Long Island to Staten Island is less of a drive and more of a strategic military operation that requires perfect timing, a specific set of podcasts, and a very high tolerance for the smell of exhaust. Whether you’re heading to a wedding at The Vanderbilt or you're one of the thousands of "super-commuters" making this trip daily for work, you've probably realized that the GPS is a liar. It says 45 minutes. You know it’s ninety.
The Verrazzano-Narrows: The $19 Doorbell
The centerpiece of this entire journey is the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge. When it opened in 1964, it was the longest suspension bridge in the world. Robert Moses, the controversial master builder of NYC, saw it as the final link in his vision of a highway-connected city. But for the modern traveler, it’s basically a massive, beautiful, incredibly expensive toll booth.
As of early 2026, the tolls are no joke. If you don't have E-ZPass, you're looking at a bill that feels like a light dinner. Even with the discount for New York residents, it’s a significant line item in a monthly budget.
But here’s the thing: the bridge is also a marvel. On a clear day, as you crest the upper level heading westbound, the skyline of Manhattan hangs to your right like a matte painting. To your left, the Atlantic opens up. It’s the one moment on the trip where you might actually feel like you’re in a movie instead of a traffic jam.
Why the Belt Parkway is Actually Your Worst Enemy
If you're coming from Long Island, you usually have two choices: the Belt Parkway or the Southern State/BQE mess. Most people default to the Belt because it "looks" shorter on a map.
It isn't.
The Belt Parkway was designed for 1930s cars going 35 miles per hour. It’s narrow. It has no shoulders. If a single car gets a flat tire near Pennsylvania Avenue, the entire South Shore of Long Island effectively stops moving. You’ve seen it. I’ve seen it. We’ve all sat there near JFK airport, watching planes take off and wishing we were on one, just to fly over the mess.
📖 Related: How far is Fort Lauderdale to Jacksonville Florida: The Real Drive Time and Routes
The bottleneck at the Conduit is legendary. This is where the traffic from the Shore Parkway and the Belt merges, and it’s usually where dreams go to die. If you’re making this trip, you have to understand the "Conduit Factor." It’s an unpredictable variable that can add 20 minutes to your trip for no reason other than the universe is feeling spiteful that day.
Public Transit: The Long Island to Staten Island "Odyssey"
Let's talk about the train. Or rather, the lack of a direct one.
If you want to go from Long Island to Staten Island via public transit, you better have a book. A long one. War and Peace maybe.
- LIRR to Atlantic Terminal: You start by taking the Long Island Rail Road into Brooklyn.
- The R Train: From Atlantic Terminal, you hop on the R train and ride it all the way down to 86th Street or 95th Street in Bay Ridge.
- The S79 Bus: Once you're in Bay Ridge, you catch the S79 Select Bus Service. This bus is the unsung hero of the outer boroughs. It takes you across the bridge.
Total time? Probably two and a half hours.
There is also the "Manhattan Method," where you take the LIRR to Penn Station, subway down to South Ferry, and take the Staten Island Ferry. It’s more scenic, and you get a beer on the boat, but it's not exactly "efficient" for a daily commute. You’re essentially traveling three sides of a square.
The SI Ferry: Not Just for Tourists
The Staten Island Ferry is actually a vital link for those who work in Lower Manhattan but live in Nassau. Some people find it easier to drive to a garage in St. George, park, and ferry over. But for the reverse—getting to Staten Island—it’s mostly used by people who have no other choice.
✨ Don't miss: Russian on the Map: Why It Covers So Much Ground and What That Actually Means
According to data from the New York City Department of Transportation (NYCDOT), the Staten Island Ferry carries over 22 million passengers annually. A small but dedicated percentage of those are Long Islanders who have figured out that the "commuter's zen" of a 25-minute boat ride is better than the "commuter's rage" of the Gowanus Expressway.
The Cultural Divide: Is Staten Island Just "East Long Island?"
There’s a long-standing joke that Staten Island is basically just a piece of Long Island that got lost. Culturally, they share a lot. Big hair (historically), great pizza, a specific brand of suburban grit, and a fierce loyalty to local delis.
But talk to someone from Tottenville, and they’ll tell you they have nothing in common with someone from Massapequa. The geography dictates the culture. Staten Island is isolated by the water in a way that Long Island isn't. Long Island has the vastness of Suffolk County—farms, wineries, the Hamptons. Staten Island has the Greenbelt and the haunting remains of Fresh Kills (which is now a stunning park, by the way).
Planning the Trip: The "Sweet Spot" Windows
If you absolutely have to drive from Long Island to Staten Island, you need to be a student of the clock.
The Morning Rush: If you aren't past the Verrazzano by 6:15 AM, you’ve already lost. Between 7:00 AM and 9:30 AM, the eastbound and westbound lanes of the Belt Parkway are essentially a parking lot.
The Mid-Day Lull: There is a brief window between 10:30 AM and 1:30 PM where you might actually hit the speed limit. This is the time for errands or visiting grandma.
✨ Don't miss: Global Entry O'Hare: Why Your ORD Layover Doesn't Have To Suck
The Evening Surge: It starts at 2:45 PM because of school buses and shift changes at the hospitals and airports. By 5:00 PM, the Gowanus Expressway (which feeds into the bridge) is a sea of red brake lights.
Real Expert Tip: The "Gowanus vs. Belt" Debate
Every local has a theory.
"Take the Gowanus, it’s faster," says one.
"The Belt is more consistent," says another.
Here is the truth: The Gowanus Expressway (I-278) is higher capacity but more prone to catastrophic accidents. The Belt is prettier but tighter. My advice? Use Waze, but don't follow it blindly. If Waze tells you to get off at an exit you’ve never heard of to "save 4 minutes," stay on the highway. Those side streets in East New York or Flatbush will swallow those 4 minutes in three stoplights.
Logistics and the Hidden Costs
It’s not just the gas and the tolls. It’s the wear and tear.
Driving from Long Island to Staten Island daily adds about 40 to 50 miles to your odometer. Over a year, that’s 12,000 miles just for work. You’re looking at more frequent oil changes, brake pads that wear down from constant stop-and-go, and the inevitable "New York Pothole" alignment issues.
Specific areas to watch out for:
- The Verrazzano Upper Level: Often closed for construction or high winds. Always check the MTA website or Twitter (X) before you leave.
- The BQE Merge: Near the Prospect Expressway, the lanes shift in a way that defies logic. Stay in the center.
- Staten Island Expressway (I-278): Once you get on the island, you aren't done. The "SIE" is notorious for being backed up from the bridge all the way to the Goethals.
Why Do People Do It?
With all this hassle, why is the Long Island to Staten Island route so busy?
Economics. Staten Island has become a hub for logistics and warehousing, especially with the Amazon fulfillment centers on the West Shore. Meanwhile, many people living in Nassau and Suffolk work in civil service—firefighters, police officers, and sanitation workers—who are frequently stationed in Staten Island.
There’s also the family factor. The Italian-American and Irish-American migrations of the 20th century saw families split between the two islands. Sunday dinner is a powerful motivator. If Nonna is making lasagna in Great Kills, you’re getting on the Belt Parkway. Period.
Actionable Steps for a Better Journey
If you're making this trek regularly, stop winging it.
- Audit your E-ZPass: Ensure you’re on the "Pay Per Trip" or "NY Resident" plan. If you're a Staten Island resident, you get a significant discount on the Verrazzano, but you have to prove residency. Long Islanders don't get the same break, but you should still check for "Commuter Plans" if you're crossing more than 10 times a month.
- Download Offline Maps: Cell service can be spotty under the steel structures of the BQE or near the airport. Having the map downloaded saves your GPS when the bars drop.
- The "Bathroom Break" Strategy: There are almost no gas stations directly on the Belt Parkway once you leave Nassau. The last reliable stop is usually the Mobil near JFK. After that, you’re stuck until you hit the service stations on the Staten Island side. Plan your hydration accordingly.
- Check the Wind: If you’re driving a high-profile vehicle (a van or a tall SUV), be aware that the Verrazzano has wind restrictions. In 40+ mph gusts, they will close the upper level or ban empty trailers. This happens more often in the winter than you'd think.
- Podcast Over Radio: The signal for many FM stations drops out when you’re in the shadows of the bridge or the industrial areas of Brooklyn. Load up your phone. You'll need something to keep your blood pressure down when you're moving at 4 mph.
Crossing from Long Island to Staten Island is a rite of passage for any true New Yorker. It’s a test of patience, a drain on the wallet, and a lesson in urban geography. But once you pull off the expressway and see the Verrazzano in your rearview mirror, there’s a certain sense of accomplishment. You made it. Now, you just have to figure out how to get back.
Next Steps for the Savvy Traveler
- Monitor the MTA Bridge and Tunnel alerts via their official app for real-time closures on the Verrazzano.
- Compare LIRR monthly passes against the cost of gas and tolls if you are considering switching to public transit; often, the LIRR-to-Subway-to-Bus route is cheaper, even if it is slower.
- Investigate the "Staten Island Ferry" parking options in St. George if your destination is anywhere near the North Shore; it might save you the stress of the Staten Island Expressway.