You’ve seen the comments. "It’s basically a glorified PS4 version." Or my personal favorite: "The Series S can't handle the grass textures."
Honestly? Most of that is just noise from people who haven't actually spent fifty hours grinding Diamond Dynasty on the little white box.
The reality of playing MLB The Show Xbox Series S in 2026 is a bit more nuanced. It’s a tug-of-war between impressive optimization and the undeniable reality of budget hardware. If you're looking for that pristine 4K experience, you're in the wrong place. But if you want to know if the game actually plays well when the bases are loaded in the bottom of the ninth?
That's a different story.
The Frame Rate Trap on Series S
Here is the thing about baseball sims: frame rate isn't just a "nice to have" feature. It’s the difference between timing a 102-mph heater from Paul Skenes and looking like a fool.
On the Xbox Series S, MLB The Show 25 and its predecessors target 60 frames per second. Most of the time, it hits it. But "most of the time" is a dangerous phrase when you're trying to hit a slider.
💡 You might also like: Why the Google Doodle Gnome Game Is Still Low-Key Addictive Years Later
I’ve noticed—and plenty of people on the forums have backed this up—that the game can get "choppy" during specific pitching cameras or in stadiums with heavy assets (looking at you, Yankee Stadium). The console tries to output at 1440p, but sometimes it bites off more than it can chew.
Pro Tip: If your game feels sluggish, go into your Xbox system settings and manually force the resolution to 1080p. It sounds counterintuitive to lower your resolution in 2026, but the stability gain is massive. You'll stop seeing those micro-stutters during the delivery, which is where they hurt the most.
Why 2025 Changed the Game Pass Script
For years, Xbox players had a "cheat code." We got the game for "free" on day one with Game Pass. It was the ultimate bragging right over PlayStation users.
Then MLB The Show 25 happened.
Sony San Diego and MLB changed the locks. For the first time since the series jumped to Xbox, the game was not included in Game Pass at launch. It was a gut punch. Suddenly, Series S owners—many of whom bought the console specifically because it was a cheap way to play The Show via subscription—were staring at a $69.99 price tag.
Is it worth the seventy bucks?
If you're coming from MLB The Show 24, it’s a tough sell. The new "Front Office Experience" in Franchise mode is cool, and the "Path to 99" in Road to the Show adds some much-needed RPG depth. But the engine is starting to show its age. Because the game still supports the Nintendo Switch, the "physics" and "hitting engine" are fundamentally capped.
The Series S Performance "Secret"
Believe it or not, the Series S actually has one advantage over the Series X and PS5: Load times.
Wait, what?
📖 Related: Marvel Rivals Spiderman Settings: Why Your Sensitivity Is Probably Killing Your Combos
No, it's not actually faster. But because the textures it's loading are lower resolution, the "ShowTech" engine moves through data like a hot knife through butter. You can jump from the main menu into a Diamond Dynasty game in about 8 seconds.
What You Lose (And What You Keep)
- Stadium Creator: Yes, it’s here. Unlike the old-gen versions, the Series S gets the full Stadium Creator. It’s a bit more prone to crashing if you go overboard with the props, though.
- Grass and Cloth Physics: This is where the budget shows. The new grass technology introduced in '25 looks lush on a Series X. On the Series S, it looks... okay. It’s a bit flat. The jersey folds and "dynamic motion" are there, but they aren't as crisp.
- The Crowd: Crowds are noticeably lower resolution. If you spend your time staring at the fans in the third row, you’re going to be disappointed. But then again, why are you doing that?
Is Cross-Play Broken?
Short answer: No.
Longer answer: It’s complicated. MLB The Show Xbox Series S supports full cross-play with PS5 and Switch. In my experience, playing against a PS5 user is seamless. However, playing against someone on a Switch can feel "heavy." There’s a weird latency normalization that happens to make the game fair for the slower hardware.
If you’re a competitive Ranked Seasons player, you might find yourself turning cross-play off just to ensure you’re getting the cleanest possible connection.
🔗 Read more: How to use hydraulics in GTA V without looking like a total rookie
The Verdict on the "Little Console"
Most people get it wrong because they expect the Series S to be a "mini" Series X. It’s not. It’s a specialized machine.
For MLB The Show Xbox Series S to really shine, you have to treat it like a performance machine, not a beauty pageant contestant. Stick to 1080p. Turn off the "Action" cameras if you see frame drops.
It’s the best value in sports gaming, even without the Game Pass safety net. You get the same Diamond Dynasty content, the same "Storylines" celebrating legends, and the same pinpoint pitching mechanics as the guys who spent $500 on their consoles.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Check Your Storage: The game is now hovering around 100GB. If you're on the original 512GB Series S, you’re going to need to clear some space.
- Toggle Resolution: Before starting your first game, go to Xbox Settings > TV & Display Options > Resolution. Switch to 1080p for a smoother 60fps experience.
- Link Your Accounts: Go to TheShow.com and link your Xbox Live and MLB accounts immediately. This ensures your progress carries over if you ever upgrade consoles.