You’d think putting the Internet’s favorite "cool dad" in a room with the most intense method actor of our generation would result in some kind of weird cinematic chemical fire. Honestly, it kind of did. When Ari Aster announced that Pedro Pascal and Joaquin Phoenix would lead his 2025 neo-Western Eddington, the vibe was equal parts "take my money" and "wait, how is that going to work?"
It works because they are total opposites.
Phoenix is the guy who famously stays in character until the cameras stop rolling, often looking like he’s vibrating at a frequency the rest of us can’t hear. Pascal, on the other hand, has this effortless, "I’m just happy to be here" charisma that makes you feel like you've known him since middle school. In Eddington, that friction isn't just a behind-the-scenes fun fact; it’s the literal engine of the movie.
✨ Don't miss: Why These Films You Have to See Actually Changed How We Think
The Lockdown Feud You Didn't Know You Needed
Set in a fictional, dusty New Mexico town during the peak of the 2020 pandemic, the movie casts Joaquin Phoenix as Joe Cross, a sheriff who is... well, he’s a lot. He’s an asthmatic lawman who refuses to wear a mask and spends half his time nursing a 20-year-old grudge.
Enter Pedro Pascal.
He plays Mayor Ted Garcia, the guy trying to follow the rules and keep the town from imploding. The movie is basically a high-stakes, satirical standoff between these two. It’s not just about politics, though. It’s personal. There are rumors of an old affair involving the sheriff's wife (played by Emma Stone), and things get messy fast.
There is one specific scene that people haven't stopped talking about since the Cannes premiere. Pedro Pascal’s character actually slaps Joaquin Phoenix while Katy Perry is blaring in the background. Phoenix mentioned in a Collider interview that the energy in those scenes was "electrifying" because they were allowed so much freedom to be spontaneous.
What Really Happened at Cannes?
If you were on social media around May 2025, you probably saw that awkward red carpet clip. You know the one—where Joaquin starts to wave at the crowd, and Pedro suddenly reaches out and pulls his hand down.
The internet went into a tailspin.
People were theorizing everything from a secret feud to Pedro "saving" Joaquin from accidentally making a controversial gesture that could be misread in a photo. The reality? It looked like a classic "older brother" move. Pascal was likely just being protective of his co-star, who famously finds the circus of red carpets a bit overwhelming.
Later at the press conference, the bond was way more obvious. A reporter asked a heavy question about the film’s emotional depth, and Joaquin—in his typical "I don't want to talk" fashion—just smiled and passed the microphone to Pedro. No words. Just a look that said, "You handle this one, buddy." Pascal didn't miss a beat. He picked it up, made the room laugh, and kept moving.
Two Different Worlds, One Screen
It’s interesting to look at how they approach the work.
- Joaquin Phoenix is all about the internal struggle. He plays Cross with this tragicomic, desperate energy that feels like it’s going to boil over at any second.
- Pedro Pascal brings a different kind of weight. He’s been vocal about how this movie triggered his own "doomscrolling" habits, using the role to explore how we all got so disconnected.
During a joint interview with Dazed, they actually got deep into why they liked working together. Pascal admitted he’d been trying to work with Joaquin for years, even writing letters to get into The Sisters Brothers back in the day. Joaquin’s response? He just laughed and admitted he doesn't know anything about movie genres.
Why Their Collaboration Matters Now
We’re living in 2026, and the world hasn't exactly gotten less polarized since the events depicted in Eddington. Seeing these two actors represent the "two souls of America"—as some critics put it—is weirdly cathartic. They aren't just playing heroes and villains; they’re playing deeply flawed, sometimes "horrible" people who are stuck in different realities.
The movie didn't just rely on their star power. Ari Aster (the guy who gave us Hereditary and Midsommar) used them to poke fun at the conspiracy culture and the social isolation we all felt. It’s a "Western" where the guns are basically our phones.
Next Steps for the Fan and Film Buff:
If you’re looking to catch up on this duo, start by watching the Eddington teaser trailer to see the visual contrast between the two. Then, check out the A24 "Memory Lane" video where they react to each other’s old headshots and movie clips—it’s the best way to see their actual off-screen dynamic. Finally, if you missed the theatrical run, look for the 4K release which includes the Ari Aster Q&A from the Museum of the Moving Image, where he breaks down how he kept the peace between two such different acting powerhouses.