Finding a clean copy of the Red Gyarados 123/123 from the 2010 expansion is basically the Holy Grail for Johto fans. Honestly, it’s not even just about the money, though a PSA 10 will definitely set you back thousands. It's the nostalgia. It’s the vibe. The Pokemon HeartGold card list represents a weird, experimental era for the TCG where the Pokemon Company decided to throw out the old rulebook and try something truly wild.
You’ve got cards that literally come in two halves. You’ve got "Prime" Pokemon with those creepy, zoomed-in CGI faces that look like they're staring into your soul. If you’re digging through your old attic or looking to buy in, you need to know that this isn't a standard set. It’s a 123-card masterclass in how to do a remake right.
What's Actually on the Pokemon HeartGold Card List?
The base HeartGold SoulSilver (HGSS) set dropped in February 2010. It was the first time we saw the silver and gold borders that defined the era. It wasn't just a cosmetic change. They moved the evolution circle, changed the font, and introduced a "legendary" feel that most modern sets still haven't quite recaptured.
Total card count? 123. But wait—there’s also that weird Alph Lithograph secret rare that doesn't follow the normal numbering.
Most of the list is a love letter to the Johto region. You’ll find the classics like Arcanine, Ninetales, and the starters. But the real meat of the set is the high-rarity stuff.
- Rare Holos (1-13): These are your standard shiny cards. Arcanine (#1) and Gyarados (#4) are the standouts here.
- The Prime Cards (105-110): These replaced the Level X cards from the Platinum era. They have those distinct "spiky" borders. Typhlosion Prime and Feraligatr Prime were massive in the competitive scene back in the day.
- LEGEND Cards (111-114): This is where it gets crazy. Ho-Oh and Lugia each take up two separate cards. You had to have both the top and bottom half in your hand to play them. If one half got knocked out, your opponent took two prize cards. High risk, high reward, and the art was literally breathtaking.
- The Red Gyarados (#123): This is a secret holo rare. It’s a reference to the Lake of Rage. It’s arguably the most iconic card in the entire set.
Why the Prime Cards Still Matter
A lot of people think Primes were just "worse EX cards," but they were actually super interesting for the game's health. They didn't have a special name like "Typhlosion ex." They were just "Typhlosion." This meant you could only have four of that Pokemon in your deck total, including the non-Prime versions.
Typhlosion Prime (#110) was the engine for so many Fire decks. Its "Afterburner" Ability let you attach a Fire Energy from your discard pile to one of your Pokemon. You’d take 10 damage for it, but in a fast-paced game, that energy acceleration was everything.
Donphan Prime (#107) was another monster. For just one Fighting Energy, it could hit for 60 damage with "Earthquake." Sure, it dealt 10 damage to all your benched Pokemon, but Donphan had 120 HP and a Poke-Body called "Exoskeleton" that reduced incoming damage by 20. It was a tank before tanks were cool.
The Mystery of the Alph Lithograph
If you ever pull a card that looks like it's written in Unown and has a giant "ONE" at the bottom, don't throw it away. That’s the Alph Lithograph. There are actually four different versions across the HGSS era sets, but the one from the base HeartGold SoulSilver set lets you look at your face-down prize cards.
It’s a secret rare. It doesn't have a standard number. In the early 2010s, players were confused by it, but today, it’s a collector's dream because of how unique it looks in a binder. It’s basically a piece of Pokemon history that feels like a real artifact from the Ruins of Alph.
Market Value: What Should You Look For?
Let's be real—collecting is expensive now. If you're looking at the Pokemon HeartGold card list with dollar signs in your eyes, focus on the "Big Three."
- Lugia LEGEND (113/114): The art is a panoramic shot of Lugia underwater. It’s gorgeous. Finding both halves in mint condition is getting harder every year.
- Ho-Oh LEGEND (111/112): Similar to Lugia, this is a two-piece puzzle. The colors are vibrant, and it looks incredible when framed.
- Gyarados (123/123): The "Shiny" Gyarados. It’s the only card in the set with a three-digit number that matches the set total but acts like a secret rare.
A PSA 10 Red Gyarados recently sold for over $4,000. Even an ungraded, "lightly played" version can cost you $70 to $100. The Primes are more affordable, usually hovering between $20 and $60 depending on the Pokemon. Meganium and Blissey are on the lower end, while Typhlosion and Gengar (from the later Triumphant set) command a premium.
🔗 Read more: Finding Everything on the BG3 Act One Map Without Losing Your Mind
Is It Worth Completing the Set?
Honestly? Yeah.
Unlike the massive 200+ card sets we get today in the Scarlet & Violet era, the HeartGold SoulSilver list is manageable. 123 cards plus a secret rare. It’s doable. The art style is also consistent. It has this "hand-painted" feel in the backgrounds that modern CGI cards sometimes lack.
If you're starting out, try to snag the "Common" and "Uncommon" cards first. Cards like Professor Oak’s New Theory and Pokemon Collector were staples back then and are still relatively cheap. They have great art of the Johto characters like Elm and Oak, which adds a lot of flavor to a binder.
One thing to watch out for is the "Reverse Holo" versions. Every card from 1-104 has a reverse holo variant. These have a special "shimmer" on the card body rather than the art box. If you're a completionist, that actually doubles your checklist to over 200 cards.
🔗 Read more: Why The Fallout New Vegas Lucky Shades Are Actually The Most Important Item In The Game
Practical Steps for Collectors
If you've got a stack of these cards or you're looking to buy, here is what you need to do right now.
Check the bottom right corner. If it says "123/123," look at the color of the Gyarados. If it's red, you've found the prize. Next, look at the borders. Real HGSS cards have a very specific gold/silver sparkle. If the border looks dull or the font seems "off," it might be a fake. Fakes were rampant during this era.
Verify the LEGEND halves. If you have a top half of Lugia, you specifically need card #113. The bottom half is #114. They aren't interchangeable with other sets like Unleashed or Undaunted.
Lastly, use a site like TCGplayer or PriceCharting to check the latest sales. Don't go by "listed" prices on eBay; look at "sold" listings. That's the only way to know what people are actually paying in 2026.
Keep your Primes in top-loaders. Those silver borders chip easily. One tiny "whitening" spot on the back can drop the grade from a 10 to a 7, cutting the value by 70%. Be careful with them. These cards are over 15 years old now—treat them like the relics they are.