Look, we've all been there. You're standing in the Shattered Sanctum, Minthara is looking at you with that terrifyingly intense Drow gaze, and she asks for the location of the Emerald Grove. Your gut says "protect the innocents," but a part of you—maybe the part that wants a cool Paladin companion or just wants to see the world burn—is tempted to spill the beans. Deciding to raid the grove BG3 is probably the most significant "moral alignment" test in the first twenty hours of Larian’s masterpiece. It isn’t just a simple combat encounter. It's a fundamental shift that locks you out of massive chunks of content while opening a very specific, blood-soaked door to others.
Most players shy away from it. The game definitely nudges you toward being a hero. But if you're playing a Dark Urge character or just a self-serving mercenary, the raid is a masterpiece of level design and consequence.
Why People Actually Choose This Path
Honestly, the main reason anyone does this is Minthara. Let’s be real. Until the later patches, raiding the Grove was the only "legit" way to get the Vengeance Paladin into your party. Even now, with the "sheepthara" glitches and knockout methods, the raid remains the most narratively consistent way to earn her loyalty. You aren't just doing it for the loot; you're doing it for a unique perspective on the Absolute’s cult that you simply don't get if you play the "good" guy.
There’s also the sheer mechanical challenge. Defending the Grove is a siege where you have the high ground and oil barrels. Attacking it? You're the one charging into the bottleneck. You have to deal with Zevlor’s hellriders, the druids' prickly magic, and the fact that you’re essentially wiping out every merchant you’ve met so far. It’s a gut-punch. If you haven't seen the emotional fallout of this choice, you haven't experienced the full range of Baldur's Gate 3’s writing.
The Immediate Fallout: What You Lose Forever
Before you commit, you need to know what goes poof. It’s a lot. If you raid the grove BG3, you are effectively ending several major questlines before they even get a chance to breathe.
Wyll leaves. Immediately. He’s a "Blade of Frontiers," and he’s not going to sit around while you massacre refugees. Karlach will also likely bail or refuse to join you if she’s already in the camp. You lose the best blacksmith in the game, Dammon. Without Dammon, Karlach’s heart quest is basically dead in the water, even if you managed to keep her around through some weird mechanical trickery.
You lose the Tiefling kids. Mol’s story? Gone. The strange ox? Probably dead. Alfira, the bard who gives you one of the best Warlock armors in the game (Potent Robe) in Act 2? She won’t be there to give it to you because she’ll be a corpse in the dirt. It’s a heavy price. You’re trading long-term gear and quest rewards for immediate gratification and a Drow companion who is, admittedly, very cool.
🔗 Read more: Why the Bow Summon in Solo Leveling: Arise is Actually Broken
Executing the Raid: A Tactical Nightmare
If you’ve decided to go through with it, talk to Minthara at the Goblin Camp. Once you give her the location, she heads out. You’ll meet her at the gates. This is where the game gives you one last chance to flip the script, but let’s assume you’re staying "evil."
The fight happens in stages. First, you have to breach the gate. The Tieflings have positioned themselves on the ramparts with bows. If you’re smart, you brought some fire resistance or some way to jump high. Minthara will lead the charge with her goblins and a couple of ogres. Don't let the ogres do all the work; they're meat shields, sure, but the druids inside the inner sanctum are the real threat.
Once the gate falls, the carnage moves to the hollow. This is where it gets uncomfortable. You’ll find NPCs you’ve talked to, traded with, and maybe even helped, now cowering or fighting for their lives. The druids will often lock themselves in the Emerald Grove’s inner chamber. To get to them, you have to bypass the thorns.
- Focus the Casters: Druids like Rath or Kagha (if she's still alive) can ruin your day with Moonbeam or Entangle.
- Use the Goblins: They are expendable. Send them into the line of fire first to soak up reactions and Opportunity Attacks.
- The Zevlor Factor: Zevlor is a paladin. He hits hard. Do not let him get a Smite off on your squishy Wizard.
The Aftermath and the Goblin Party
After the blood stops flowing, you head back to camp for a "celebration." This is one of the darkest scenes in the game. While your goblin "friends" are getting drunk and bragging about the murders, your companions' reactions will vary from horrific approval to absolute disgust. This is the moment you can romance Minthara. It’s a high-intensity scene that cements your transition into a villainous or at least deeply compromised protagonist.
✨ Don't miss: Why Jet Set Radio Games Still Feel Like the Future
But here is the kicker: the game feels emptier afterward. The Grove was a hub. Without it, the rest of Act 1 feels a bit like a ghost town. You’ll find yourself wandering the Shadow-Cursed Lands later on and noticing all the people who should be there but aren't. It makes the world feel reactive, but also lonely.
Common Misconceptions About the Raid
A lot of people think you must kill everyone yourself. You don't. You can actually trigger a civil war between the Druids and the Tieflings beforehand by stealing the Idol of Silvanus or exposing Kagha. If they kill each other, Minthara’s job is much easier.
Another misconception? That you can't get Halsin. Well, you can't. If you raid the grove BG3, Halsin will either die in his cage or come after you in a fit of rage. There is no world where the Archdruid joins the person who butchered his students. You are choosing Minthara over Halsin. Period.
📖 Related: Spyro the Dragon PS1: What Most People Get Wrong About the Original
Is It Worth It?
From a pure "power gaming" perspective? Probably not. The loot you get from the Tieflings in Act 2 and 3 usually outweighs what you get from the goblins. The Potent Robe alone is enough to make most Warlock players stay on the straight and narrow.
However, from a roleplaying perspective, it’s incredible. It changes the tone of the entire 100-hour campaign. Your interactions with the Absolute’s True Souls in Act 2 feel different. You aren't an interloper; you're a "hero" of the cult. Or a double agent. The nuance Larian built into the "evil" path is often overlooked because it’s so heartbreaking to execute.
Strategic Steps for Your Next Playthrough
If you're going to commit to the raid, do it with a plan. Don't just stumble into it.
- Strip the Merchants: Before starting the raid, buy everything useful from Arron and Dammon. Once the raid starts, they become enemies or corpses, and their inventories reset or disappear.
- Complete "Find the Nightsong": Or at least get the intel from the camp. You want to make sure you've squeezed every bit of XP out of the goblin camp before you turn the Grove into a graveyard.
- Check Your Companions: If you really want to keep Gale, you’ll need to pass a high Persuasion check to keep him from leaving after the massacre. Prepare your Charisma buffs.
- The Minthara Recruitment: Remember that she doesn't actually join your party until Act 2 at Moonrise Towers. You’re doing this for a future investment, not an immediate party member.
Choosing to raid the grove BG3 isn't just a combat choice; it’s a narrative pivot. It’s messy, it’s cruel, and it’s one of the best examples of player agency in modern RPG history. Just don’t expect to feel like a "good" person when the dust settles and the goblins start their bonfire.