You’re probably playing too fast. Most people treat this game like it’s Grand Theft Auto with horses, sprinting from one yellow mission marker to the next. That is the quickest way to miss about 40% of what makes this game a masterpiece. If you want a real red dead redemption 2 strategy guide, you have to start by slowing down. Honestly, the game forces it on you anyway. Arthur moves like he’s walking through molasses, and there’s a reason for that. Rockstar designed the pacing to match the era—a dying frontier where every bullet and every skin counts.
I’ve spent hundreds of hours in the shoes of Arthur Morgan. I’ve found the rare horses, lived through the camp upgrades, and accidentally shot my way out of Saint Denis more times than I can count. This isn't just about clicking heads. It's about systems. Systems that the game barely explains, leaving you to figure out why your horse is agitated or why your health core is constantly flashing red.
The Core System Mystery
Forget the bars. Look at the circles.
🔗 Read more: Finding the Expedition 33 Manor Door Locations and Why They Matter
The most fundamental part of any red dead redemption 2 strategy guide is understanding the difference between Cores and Bars. Your Bars are your immediate resource. If your Health Bar hits zero, you die. Simple. But your Cores? Those determine how fast those bars regenerate. If your Stamina Core is empty, your stamina bar will barely move. You’ll be gasping for air after a ten-foot jog.
Eating isn't just a roleplay mechanic. It’s survival. If you don't eat, Arthur becomes underweight, which actually gives you a stamina bonus but makes you take more damage. If you overeat, you become "Big Arthur," taking less damage but tiring out faster. Most players just ignore this and wonder why they’re getting dropped in two shots by a O'Driscoll with a cattleman revolver.
Keep some cooked Big Game Meat on you. It’s the gold standard. Hunt a gator in the swamps near Bayou Nwa, season it with some Wild Mint, and you get a gold Health Core for a full day. It’s basically a cheat code that the game just lets you have.
Don't Buy a Horse
Seriously. Stop going to the stables in Valentine or Strawberry and dropping $450 on a mid-tier Morgan or Kentucky Saddler. It’s a waste of money you could be spending on camp upgrades or better guns.
Instead, head up to Lake Isabella in the Grizzlies. There’s a White Arabian that spawns on the western shore. It’s fast. It’s elite. It’s free. You just have to be patient enough to break it without getting bucked off into the freezing water. If you want something sturdier that won't buck you at the first sight of a snake, look for the Perlino Andalusian near Brandywine Drop. It’s a war horse. It’s a tank. It’s also free.
Your bond with the horse is everything. Reach Level 4 bonding as fast as possible. You get the drift (skidding) and the piaffe (side-stepping), which are genuinely useful for navigating tight forests or dodging trees during a high-speed chase. Brush your horse. Feed it. It’s a living tool, not a car.
The Camp is Not a Burden
A lot of players treat Pearson and Dutch like nagging parents. They ignore the camp ledger and just sleep in the woods. This is a mistake.
✨ Don't miss: Basketball Dynasty RNG Codes: Why Your Luck Isn’t Just Random
You need to prioritize the Leather Working Tools and the "Next in Line" map upgrade. Why? Because the map unlocks Fast Travel from your campfire in the wilderness. It saves you literal hours of riding across the Heartlands. Also, Pearson can craft the Legend of the East Satchel. This is the single most important item in the game. It increases your carrying capacity for almost every item from 5 or 10 to 99.
Imagine never having to leave a perfect pelt behind because you’re "carrying too much." That’s the dream. It requires a lot of hunting—perfect deer, elk, panther, and wolf pelts—but the payoff is massive.
Hunting for Perfection
You need three-star pelts. Anything less is trash for crafting.
- Study the animal first. Use your binoculars. It’ll tell you the quality.
- Use the right tool. Small birds need Small Game Arrows. Rabbits need the Varmint Rifle. Deer need a Bolt Action Rifle or a Bow with Improved Arrows.
- The Buck Antler Trinket. Go kill the Legendary Buck northwest of Strawberry. Take its antler to a Fence. This trinket gives you a higher chance of getting a perfect pelt even if your shot wasn't 100% clean. It’s a game-changer for completionists.
Handling the Law and Bounty Hunters
The bounty system in RDR2 is brutal. If you’ve got a $300 bounty in Lemoyne, you’re going to have bounty hunters breathing down your neck every ten minutes. It makes fishing or hunting almost impossible.
A pro tip for this red dead redemption 2 strategy guide: if you’re broke and can't pay your bounty, just surrender. Walk up to a lawman, pull your weapon, then immediately holster it and hit the "Surrender" prompt. You’ll spend a few nights in jail, lose whatever pocket change you had, but your bounty will be cleared. It’s a great way to "reset" a region if things have gotten too heated.
Just don't do this if you’re carrying thousands of dollars. The game takes a percentage of your cash for the "fine." Spend your money on clothes or guns first, then go to jail.
Money is Everywhere if You Stop Looking for Jobs
You don't need to do missions to get rich. The world is littered with gold bars.
🔗 Read more: Finding the Best Princess Peach Coloring Pages Printable Online for Free
There’s a derailed train in a ravine near Cotorra Springs. If you can climb inside the vertical car, there are two gold bars waiting for you. That’s $1,000 right there. Then there’s the Strange Statues puzzle near Window Rock. Solve it—it’s a simple prime number pattern—and you get three more bars.
The "Limpany" gold bar is another easy one. Visit the burned-out town near Horseshoe Overlook. Check the sheriff's office. Look under the desk. Boom. $500.
Combat Nuance: More Than Just Deadeye
Everyone knows how to use Deadeye. You mark the targets, you pull the trigger, everyone falls down.
But have you tried the "Dolphin Dive"? While aiming, press the jump button and a direction. Arthur will throw himself into the dirt. It breaks the lock-on of NPCs and can save your life during a shootout in an open field with no cover.
Also, clean your guns. I can’t stress this enough. A dirty gun loses damage, fire rate, and reload speed. If you see black smoke coming out of your barrel, you’re overdue for some Gun Oil. You can buy it at any general store, or just loot it off the hundreds of bodies you’ll leave behind.
The Honor Balance
High Honor gives you discounts at shops (up to 50% off!) and unlocks specific outfits. Low Honor gets you more loot from bodies and more "intimidating" dialogue. Honestly, High Honor is better for the story. It changes the way people treat Arthur and even changes the ending of the game. If your honor is low, just go to Saint Denis and greet every single person you see. "Hey Mister!" is the fastest way to become a saint in the eyes of the game's engine.
Hidden Mechanics People Miss
- The Trapper is your friend. Most people sell their legendary pelts to Pearson. Don't. Take them to the Trapper. He’s the only one who can make the cool bear-head hats and snake-skin boots.
- Recipes. You can find pamphlets for explosive slugs and incendiary buckshot. Check under floorboards in abandoned shacks. These make the late-game combat much more "explosive."
- The Fence. Don't just sell your jewelry. Check the crafting menu. Things like the Owl Feather Trinket or the Bear Claw Talisman give you permanent stat buffs.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Playthrough
If you want to master the game, follow this specific order of operations next time you load into Chapter 2:
- Go to the Fence. Sell any starting loot and buy the Reinforced Lasso. It makes bounties way easier because people can't wiggle out of it.
- Hunt the Legendary Buck. Get that trinket immediately. It makes every other hunt less stressful.
- Upgrade Dutch's Lodgings then Arthur's. Unlock that Fast Travel map. It’s the single best quality-of-life improvement available.
- Find the White Arabian. Head to the snow. It’s better than any horse you’ll find for the first half of the game.
- Explore Limpany and the Train Wreck. Get your seed money. Don't wait for the game to give you a heist. Go take the gold that’s already sitting there.
This world is deep. It’s heavy. It’s meant to be lived in, not just "beaten." Stop sprinting. Look at the trees. Pet the dog in Valentine. That’s the real way to experience everything this game has to offer.