You remember the voice. That deep, booming, slightly menacing baritone that seemed to suck the oxygen out of the room. Usually, it was doing a pitch-perfect (and arguably cruel) impression of Tim Gunn saying, "Make it work." But if you strip away the drama, the singing about Red Lobster, and the "villain" edit that defined Season 2, you're left with the actual santino project runway designs. And honestly? They were a total paradox.
Some people call him a visionary who was too big for the small screen. Others? They saw a guy who couldn't sew a straight line to save his life and hid it behind a mountain of ruffles. Looking back at it now, 20 years later, the truth is way more complicated than just "he was the mean guy who made weird clothes."
The Highs, the Lows, and the Nicky Hilton Dress
If you want to understand the Santino Rice aesthetic, you have to look at the scores. Most contestants either "get" the show or they don't. Santino was a seesaw. He won two challenges, which is impressive, but he also landed in the bottom two four times. He was basically living on the edge of elimination every single week.
His biggest "win" was the Nicky Hilton challenge. Designers had to create a red carpet look for the socialite, and Santino actually nailed it. It was sleek, it was glamorous, and it proved he could actually design for a real person when he wasn't trying to over-concept things into oblivion.
But then, you had the "Intergalactic Deer People."
👉 See also: How the How to Train Your Dragon Live Action Post Credit Scene Could Change Everything for the Franchise
Yeah. That happened.
In a challenge where they had to create a garment based on a floral shop, Santino sent out a model in a literal brown jumpsuit with what looked like twigs coming out of her head. It was bizarre. It was camp. The judges hated it. Michael Kors looked like he wanted to crawl under the table. This was the Santino pattern: he'd give you a masterpiece, then follow it up with something that looked like it was found in a dumpster behind a Jo-Ann Fabric.
The "Pattern Maker" vs. "Designer" Feud
One of the most famous moments in Project Runway history was when Santino went after the eventual winner, Chloe Dao. He called her a "brilliant pattern maker" but said she wasn't a "designer."
Basically, he was trying to say that Chloe had the technical skills—the math, the sewing, the construction—but lacked the "soul" or the "innovation" of a true artist. It was a massive insult at the time. Ironically, many critics pointed out that Santino's own technical skills were... let's say, lacking.
💡 You might also like: Personajes del Chavo del 8: Por qué nos siguen doliendo tanto después de 50 años
There's a notorious story from the challenge where designers had to make outfits for each other. Santino was paired with Kara Janx. The jumpsuit he made for her was literally falling apart minutes before the runway. The sleeve was ripped. Instead of admitting it, Santino allegedly told Kara to stay quiet and then told the judges the rip happened because she was "jumping for joy" because she loved the outfit so much.
Talk about gaslighting.
He relied heavily on "the glue gun method" of fashion. If a garment didn't fit right or the seams were messy, he’d just pile on more fringe, more beads, or more ruffles. It was a "more is more" philosophy that worked for TV, but it drove the judges crazy because they knew it was hiding a lack of basic tailoring knowledge.
The Finale at Olympus Fashion Week
Despite the drama, Santino made it to the Top 3. Showing at Bryant Park back then was the holy grail for a young designer. His final collection was... well, it was very Santino.
- The Vibe: It was heavy on the "boudoir" look.
- The Texture: Lots of lace, delicate silks, and his signature earthy tones.
- The Critique: Nina Garcia and Michael Kors were split. They'd been telling him all season to "edit," to take the "tacky shit" off. So, he finally listened. He sent out a collection that was much more restrained.
And you know what happened? The judges told him they missed the "tacky shit."
You can't win. They felt the collection lacked the "oomph" and the "theatrics" that made him famous in the first place. He ended up taking third place, behind Daniel Vosovic and Chloe Dao. It was a bitter pill to swallow for a guy who genuinely believed he was the second coming of Alexander McQueen.
Why We Still Talk About Him
It's easy to dismiss him as a reality TV relic. But the santino project runway designs actually predicted a lot of what we see in "ugly-chic" and maximalist fashion today. He wasn't afraid to be ugly. He wasn't afraid of bad taste. In a world of "clean girls" and "quiet luxury," Santino was loud, messy, and totally uncompromising.
After the show, he didn't exactly become a household name in high fashion. He went on to judge RuPaul's Drag Race, where he brought that same "harsh but honest" energy to a whole new audience. Eventually, he faded away from the fashion world, and if you look at his social media today, he’s more focused on controversial health takes and raw juice fasts than he is on the sewing machine.
But for a few months in 2005 and 2006, he was the center of the fashion universe.
Actionable Insights for Aspiring Designers
If you're looking at Santino's career as a case study, there are a few real-world lessons you can take away:
- Technical skills matter. You can be the most creative person in the world, but if your clothes fall apart on the runway, you won't last. Learn the "math" of pattern making before you try to break the rules.
- Branding is a double-edged sword. Santino's "villain" persona made him famous, but it also made it hard for the industry to take him seriously as a luxury designer. Decide if you want to be a "personality" or a "pro."
- Know when to listen to critiques. The biggest mistake Santino made was waiting until the finale to finally "edit" his work. By then, it was too late to find the balance between his crazy vision and the judges' expectations.
He might not have won the $100,000 or the mentorship, but Santino Rice proved that sometimes, a bold, flawed vision is more memorable than a perfect, boring one.
Next Steps:
If you want to see the specific evolution of his style, track down the Season 2 finale on a streaming service. Watch the way he handles the "makeover" challenge specifically—it's a masterclass in how to (and how not to) manage a client's expectations under pressure.