You’re staring at a graveyard. It’s huge. It’s basically a second library, and your opponent is currently flipping half their deck into it while you’ve barely played a second land. If you’ve spent any time in the Modern or Legacy streets of Magic: The Gathering, you know this feeling. It’s dread. But lately, there’s been a specific, almost annoying consistency to how these decks operate, and it often comes down to the scrap of paper dredge players use to track their triggers.
Dredge is weird. It’s not "playing Magic" in the traditional sense. You aren't casting spells so much as you are managing a literal heap of cardboard trash that somehow wins games.
Honestly, the "scrap of paper" isn't just a physical object. In the community, it’s become shorthand for the meticulous, often messy tracking required to pilot one of the most complex archetypes in TCG history. When you’re dealing with Prized Amalgams crawling out of the dirt and Narcomoebas hitting the board because a Stinkweed Imp hit the bin, things get chaotic. You need a system. Without that literal or metaphorical scrap of paper, the deck falls apart under its own weight.
The Mechanics of the Scrap of Paper Dredge Strategy
Let’s be real: Dredge is a math problem disguised as a fantasy card game. The keyword itself is simple enough. If you would draw a card, you can instead put exactly X cards from the top of your library into your graveyard and return the card with Dredge to your hand. Simple, right? Wrong.
It’s a nightmare.
The strategy relies on a critical mass of "free" value. You aren't paying mana for your creatures. You're paying in library depth. The scrap of paper dredge players keep on the table usually tracks "active" triggers. Did the Silversmote Ghoul see you gain 3 life? Is the Creeping Chill exile trigger on the stack? If you miss one, you lose. It’s that binary.
Most people get Dredge wrong by thinking it's an aggressive deck. It isn't. It’s a combo deck that uses the combat phase as its win condition. You’re looking for a specific sequence:
- Get a "discard outlet" like Cathartic Reunion or Thrilling Discovery on turn two.
- Dump Golgari Grave-Trolls (if you're in a format where they aren't banned) or Stinkweed Imps.
- Use those replacement effects to mill 5 or 6 cards per draw.
- Hit your "payoffs."
The payoffs are where the tracking gets hairy. Prized Amalgam is the king of "wait, when does that come back?" It returns at the beginning of the next end step. If you trigger it during your opponent’s turn, it comes back on theirs. If you trigger it on yours, it waits. This is why you see pros scribbling notes. They’re tracking the "lag" of their own deck.
Why Complexity is a Feature, Not a Bug
Dredge has survived countless bans. Faithless Looting? Gone. Bridge from Below? Nuked. Golgari Grave-Troll? Banned, unbanned, then banned again for its sins. Yet, the deck persists. Why? Because the graveyard is the hardest zone for Wizards of the Coast to balance.
Interaction is the problem. Most decks are built to interact with the hand or the battlefield. When you play scrap of paper dredge styles, you move the game to a zone where 80% of your opponent's main deck is useless. Their Fatal Pushes look silly against a Vengevine that just comes back next turn.
💡 You might also like: Why Everyone Is Obsessed With the Dress to Impress Lady Gaga Update
But there’s a cost. The mental load is exhausting.
I’ve seen players at Grand Prix events lose games not because they were outplayed, but because they forgot a Bloodghast trigger when they played a land. They forgot to check their scrap of paper. In high-level Magic, the "Game State" is sacred. If you miss a mandatory trigger, the judge gets called. If you miss a detrimental one, you might get a warning. If you miss a beneficial one? Too bad. It’s gone.
The Evolution of Dredge Tracking
In the early days (we’re talking Ravnica: City of Guilds era, circa 2005), people just winged it. You’d flip cards, move them around, and hope for the best. It was "Kitchen Table" chaos.
Then came the "Bridgevine" era and the "Hogaak Summer" of 2019. The deck became so fast—turning through 30 cards by turn three—that the human brain just couldn't keep up with the triggers. Players started using dice, but dice get knocked over. Hence, the scrap of paper dredge method became the gold standard.
What Actually Goes on the Paper?
It’s usually a mess of shorthand that looks like an ancient ritual.
- "PA - End": Prized Amalgam returning at end step.
- "BC - Land": Bloodghast waiting for a Land Drop.
- "Chill - 3": Reminding the player they have three Creeping Chills left in the deck to hit.
This isn't just about memory; it's about probability. A seasoned Dredge pilot knows exactly how many "hits" are left in the library. If you have 20 cards left and you haven't seen a Narcomoeba, the odds of your next dredge hitting one are high. You play differently based on those numbers.
Countering the Scrap: How to Fight Back
If you're on the other side of the table, the scrap of paper dredge represents your ticking clock. You can’t out-grind them. You have to go under them or lock them out.
Leyline of the Void is the nuclear option. It starts on the battlefield. It says "Your graveyard doesn't exist." For a Dredge player, this is the equivalent of someone taking their scrap of paper and setting it on fire.
But good players plan for this. They bring in Nature's Claim or Wear // Tear. The sub-game of "Can I find my removal before they mill their whole deck?" is what makes Modern a "Turn 3 format." If you don't have the hate, you lose. If they have the answer, they win.
✨ Don't miss: Getting Stuck on Mashable Hint Today Connections? Here Is How to Actually Solve It
Common Misconceptions About the Deck
One big myth is that Dredge is "easy." People call it a "brain-dead" deck because you just put cards in the trash. That’s nonsense.
Knowing what to dredge is a skill. Do you dredge the Life from the Loam to guarantee land drops, or the Stinkweed Imp to maximize mill depth? If you're at 5 life, do you risk dredging and hitting no Creeping Chills? These are the micro-decisions that separate the 5-0 players from the 2-3 players.
Another misconception: "Rest in Peace" wins the game instantly.
Actually, no. A smart Dredge player can sometimes pivot to a "hard cast" plan. I have personally seen someone win a game by manually casting Stinkweed Imps and flying over for 1 damage a turn while their opponent sat behind a Rest in Peace doing nothing. It’s ugly, but it works.
The Psychological Aspect of "The Scrap"
There is a certain level of intimidation that comes with a prepared opponent. When you sit down and your opponent lays out their playmat, sets a clean scrap of paper dredge tracker down, and checks their pen, you know you’re in for a long round.
It signals competence. In TCGs, information is everything. If I see you tracking your Ox of Agonas escapes meticulously, I know I can't bait you into a bad sequence. You know your outs.
Real World Example: The 2019 Hogaak Meta
Look back at the Pro Tour (or Mythic Championship) data from the Hogaak era. The players who excelled weren't just the ones who drew the best; they were the ones who managed the triggers perfectly. Hogaak, Arisen Necropolis required delving cards and convoking creatures. If you did it in the wrong order, you couldn't cast him.
The "scrap of paper" was often a list of creatures on board and cards in grave that could be "spent" as currency. It turned the game into a resource management sim.
Technical Depth: The Math of the Mill
Let’s talk numbers. If you have a 60-card deck and you've drawn your opening 7, you have 53 cards left.
A turn 1 Hedge Maze (the new Surveil lands are a godsend for this deck) puts a card in the bin.
A turn 2 Cathartic Reunion discarding two Golgari Grave-Trolls allows you to dredge 12 cards.
By the end of turn 2, you have seen:
7 (Hand) + 1 (Draw) + 1 (Surveil) + 12 (Dredge) = 21 cards.
You have seen more than a third of your deck by turn two. This is why the deck is so consistent. You aren't looking for a "1-of" in your library; you're looking for any of the 12-16 "hits" you've packed into the list.
Actionable Insights for Aspiring Dredge Pilots
If you want to master the scrap of paper dredge lifestyle, you need to move beyond just knowing the rules. You need a process.
👉 See also: Solving the Bumper on a Racing Car Crossword Clue: Why It’s Tricker Than You Think
- Physicality Matters: Use a physical notepad. Apps are fine, but there is something about the tactile act of crossing off a Narcomoeba that keeps your brain locked into the game state.
- The "End Step" Habit: 90% of Dredge mistakes happen at the end of the turn. Make it a habit to look at your graveyard every single time a phase changes.
- Know Your Math: Memorize the "Dredge count" of every card in your deck. You shouldn't have to look at Darkblast to know it's a Dredge 3.
- Goldfish 100 Times: Play the deck against a wall. If you can't execute the "Turn 3 win" without thinking, you aren't ready for a tournament. The mechanics should be muscle memory so your brain can focus on what the opponent is doing.
- Sideboarding is a Trap: Don't over-sideboard. The deck needs a critical mass of dredge cards to function. If you take out too many "enablers" to bring in "answers," you'll end up with a hand that does nothing. Keep the engine running.
The reality is that Dredge is one of the few decks in Magic that feels like you're cheating while following every rule perfectly. It’s a beautiful, messy, frustrating way to play the game. Whether you’re using a literal scrap of paper or a high-end tracking app, the goal remains the same: turn your graveyard into a weapon.
To get started, map out your first three turns on paper. Write down every possible trigger that could occur from a single Stitcher's Supplier death. Once you can visualize the branches of that tree, you'll stop playing against your own deck and start playing against your opponent. The "Scrap" isn't a crutch; it's the blueprint for the win.
Stop worrying about what’s in your hand and start obsessing over what’s in your trash. That’s where the real power is.