Walk down a city block in 1969 or 1970 and you didn't see shiny, sanitized playgrounds. You saw cracked pavement. You saw trash cans that actually had people—or monsters—living in them. You saw rusty pipes and peeling paint. When Sesame Street in the 70s first flickered onto heavy, tube-style television sets, it didn't look like a cartoon world. It looked like a neighborhood. Specifically, it looked like the Upper West Side or Harlem. It was loud. It was diverse in a way that felt almost revolutionary for the time.
Honestly, if you go back and watch those early episodes on Max or through the Paley Center archives, the vibe is startling. It’s gritty.
There’s this famous story about the show’s testing phases. The creators, led by Joan Ganz Cooney and the visionary psychologists at the Children's Television Workshop (CTW), originally thought they should keep the "fantasy" puppets and the "real" humans separate. They were worried that if Big Bird walked up to a group of kids on a real street, it would confuse their developing brains. They were wrong. During test screenings, the kids tuned out when only the humans were talking. They wanted the chaos. They wanted the giant 8-foot-tall yellow canary interacting with the mailman.
So, the producers pivoted. They mashed the Muppets and the humans together in a brownstone environment that felt lived-in. That decision changed television history forever, but it also created a version of the show that feels almost alien compared to the high-def, Elmo-centric world of modern PBS.
The Wild West of Early Educational TV
The 1970s were a decade of massive experimentation. You had the Nixon era, the end of the Vietnam War, and a crumbling economy in New York City. Sesame Street in the 70s reflected that tension. The show was funded largely by the federal government and private foundations with a very specific, almost desperate goal: close the "readiness gap" for low-income urban children.
📖 Related: Why the Cast of Netflix Series of Unfortunate Events Was Better Than the Books
It worked. Researchers from the University of Wisconsin and other institutions have spent decades tracking the "Sesame Effect." They found that kids who watched the show in the early 70s had higher high school GPAs than those who didn't.
But man, the content was bold.
Take Roosevelt Franklin. He was a purple Muppet voiced by Matt Robinson (who also played the original human Gordon). Roosevelt was cool. He taught in a classroom, spoke in scat-style rhymes, and was undeniably Black in his mannerisms and dialect. By 1975, he was gone. Some parents felt he was a stereotype; others felt he was too rowdy. The show listened, but in losing Roosevelt, it lost a bit of that raw, jagged edge that defined the early years.
Then there was the "Orange" Oscar the Grouch. People forget that in the very first season, Oscar wasn't green. He was a bright, muddy orange. He only turned green after a trip to Swamp Mushy Muddy. Why does that matter? Because it shows the show was still finding its feet. Jim Henson and Carroll Spinney were literally inventing the psychology of these characters on the fly.
When the Muppets Got Political (Sort Of)
You can't talk about Sesame Street in the 70s without talking about the 1970 ban in Mississippi. It’s a true story. A state commission voted to ban the show because they weren't ready for a "highly integrated" cast of children and adults.
They weren't used to seeing a Black man like Gordon and a white woman like Susan (who was actually played by Loretta Long, a Black actress, but the cast's overall integration was the point) living as equals. The ban lasted less than a month because the public outcry was deafening. Even in the 70s, people knew this show was the future.
The humans were just as important as the Muppets. Bob, Luis, Maria, David—they weren't just "presenters." They were neighbors. When Sonia Manzano joined the cast as Maria in 1971, she brought a specifically Puerto Rican perspective to the screen that millions of kids had never seen.
📖 Related: The Black Cat Edgar Allan Poe: Why This Story Still Haunts Our Dreams
That One Episode You Can't Watch
There is a legendary "lost" episode from 1976. Episode 0847. It featured Margaret Hamilton reprising her role as the Wicked Witch of the West from The Wizard of Oz.
She was terrifying.
She spent the whole episode trying to get her broom back from David. She threatened to turn Big Bird into a feather duster. After it aired, the CTW was flooded with letters from parents saying their kids were screaming in terror and hiding behind the couch. The episode was pulled and hasn't been aired on broadcast TV since. That’s the 70s in a nutshell: they weren't afraid to let kids be a little bit scared. They believed kids were resilient.
The Sound of the Street
The music wasn't "kiddie" music. It was funk. It was jazz. It was soul.
Joe Raposo and Jeff Moss were the geniuses behind the keys. Think about the song "C is for Cookie." That’s a blues track. "Bein' Green" is a sophisticated torch song about identity and self-acceptance that Frank Sinatra eventually covered.
When Stevie Wonder showed up in 1973 to perform "Superstition" in the courtyard, he didn't dial it down. He turned it up. The kids in the background were legitimately dancing to one of the greatest funk songs ever written. The show treated children like they had taste.
✨ Don't miss: Why Star Wars Diego Luna is the Most Important Actor in the Franchise Right Now
Why the 70s Era Still Matters
We live in a world of algorithmic content now. Everything is tested to be as "safe" and "engaging" as possible. But Sesame Street in the 70s was about the messy reality of living in a community.
- It taught us about death (though Mr. Hooper’s passing was in 1982, the foundation of that honesty was laid in the 70s).
- It taught us about poverty without being patronizing.
- It showed us that a "grouch" is just someone with a different personality type who you still have to share the sidewalk with.
The show was a social experiment disguised as a puppet show. It was funded because the government realized that if you don't educate kids before they hit kindergarten, they might never catch up.
Actionable Takeaways for the Nostalgic (or the Curious)
If you want to experience this era properly, don't just watch clips on YouTube. You have to look at the context.
1. Watch the "Street Gang" Documentary. If you haven't seen the 2021 documentary Street Gang: How We Got to Sesame Street, go find it. It uses a massive amount of 70s archival footage and explains the "why" behind the grit. It’s based on the book by Michael Davis, which is also a must-read for anyone who cares about TV history.
2. Listen to the original vinyl. The original cast recordings from the early 70s are available on streaming platforms. Listen to the arrangements. They used real studio musicians—the best in New York. The quality of the instrumentation is lightyears ahead of most modern children's media.
3. Look at the background details. When you watch an old clip, stop looking at Elmo (who wasn't even a main character yet) and look at the background. Look at the posters on the walls. Look at the clothes the kids are wearing. It’s a time capsule of a New York City that doesn't really exist anymore—a place that was rough around the edges but incredibly vibrant.
4. Introduce the "Old School" to your kids. There are "Old School" Sesame Street DVD sets (Volumes 1-3). They come with a disclaimer that they are "intended for grown-ups" and might not suit today's preschool standards. Watch them anyway. Your kids might actually enjoy seeing a world that isn't made of CGI and bright plastic.
The magic of the 70s wasn't that it was perfect. It was that it was real. It told kids that the world was big, sometimes loud, and occasionally frustrating, but there was always someone in your neighborhood who was willing to tell you how to get there.