Growing up as the daughter of "America's Sweetheart" sounds like a dream, but for Shayla Rae Kelley, it was basically a crash course in high-stakes discipline. You probably recognize her name because her mom is Mary Lou Retton, the first American woman to snag that Olympic individual all-around gold. But honestly? Shayla’s been carving out her own lane for a long time now. She isn't just "the daughter." She’s a former Division I athlete, a fitness competitor, and more recently, a voice of stability for a family that’s been through the ringer in the public eye.
Born in Houston back in April 1995, Shayla was the first of the four Kelley girls. While the world saw the gold medals, Shayla saw the grind. She didn't just inherit the name; she inherited the work ethic. But she didn't just carbon-copy her mom's career. She tweaked it. She made it hers.
From the Vault to the Mat: The Baylor Years
Most people assume Shayla was a "traditional" gymnast forever. Sorta, but not really. She was a powerhouse Level 10 gymnast in high school at Second Baptist, even grabbing state and regional vault titles. But when it came time for college, she took a detour that caught some people off guard. She didn't go for the standard uneven bars and floor routines.
Instead, she joined the Baylor University Acrobatics & Tumbling team.
It’s a different beast entirely. It’s more about team power, toss heats, and pyramid flips. Shayla was a standout "top" (the person usually being thrown or at the peak of the pyramid). During her 2016 season, she was part of a squad that actually nailed a perfect 10.0 in a pyramid event against Alderson Broaddus. Can you imagine the pressure of being Mary Lou's kid and trying to hit a "perfect 10"? She did it.
Her college career wasn't all highlights, though. Her freshman year in 2014 was basically a wash because of a nasty knee injury. That's the part people forget—the sitting out, the physical therapy, the mental game of wondering if you’re "done." She wasn't. She came back and competed in every single meet of her junior year.
👉 See also: Menendez Brothers Then and Now: What Really Happened to Lyle and Erik
The Shift to Bodybuilding and the NPC Circuit
Once the Baylor lights dimmed, Shayla didn't just stop training. She transitioned into something even more intense: competitive bodybuilding. This wasn't just "going to the gym." She dove into the NPC (National Physique Committee) Bikini division.
- She trained under Alejandro Martinez Jr.
- She documented the whole grueling process on her YouTube channel.
- She dealt with a random bout of the flu right before her 2022 NPC Battle of Texas debut.
Despite the setback, she absolutely crushed it. She took home first-place medals in three different classes. It was a massive moment because it proved she could dominate a sport that had nothing to do with her mom's shadow. It was just her, a strict meal plan, and a lot of heavy lifting.
Family Crisis and the 2023 Turning Point
If you follow sports news, you know 2023 was a nightmare for the Kelley family. Mary Lou Retton was hospitalized with a super rare form of pneumonia, fighting for her life in the ICU. This is where Shayla Rae Kelley really stepped up.
She became the family's unofficial spokesperson. While her sisters McKenna, Skyla, and Emma were right there with her, Shayla was often the one posting the raw, difficult updates on Instagram. She was the one managing the Spotfund page that eventually raised over $450,000 for her mom's medical bills (since Retton didn't have health insurance at the time—a detail that sparked a massive national conversation).
It was a heavy mantle to carry. She described 2023 as a year where the "highs were so high, but the lows were the lowest lows." It wasn't just about PR; it was about survival.
Life in 2026: Marriage and Motherhood
Fast forward to today. Shayla is now Shayla Schrepfer. She married her college sweetheart, Wyatt Schrepfer (a former Baylor football player), in January 2020. They’ve been together forever—they got engaged way back in 2018.
The biggest news? Shayla officially entered her "boy mom" era. On February 11, 2025, she and Wyatt welcomed their first child, Sullivan Wyatt Schrepfer.
"Our everything," she called him.
It’s a new chapter. She’s navigating being a first-time mom while her sisters are also starting their own families. Her sister Skyla actually had a baby girl just months before Sullivan was born. It's a total generational shift for the family. Mary Lou is now officially "LouLou" (her preferred grandma name), and the focus has shifted from Olympic glory to diaper changes and family walks with their spaniel, Champ.
Why Shayla’s Story Still Resonates
We love a legacy story, but we love an "individual identity" story even more. Shayla Rae Kelley could have just lived quietly off the family name. Instead, she’s been incredibly transparent about:
- Her Parents' Divorce: She posted a very honest YouTube video years ago about Shannon and Mary Lou’s 2018 split.
- Health Struggles: She’s been open about her own heart surgery for Wolff-Parkinson-White syndrome.
- The Reality of Athletics: She shows the sweat, the bruises, and the "boring" parts of training.
Honestly, she’s the blueprint for how to handle being a "nepo baby" with grace. She doesn't deny the privilege, but she clearly puts in the work.
Actionable Takeaways from Shayla’s Journey
If you're looking at Shayla’s life and wondering what the "expert" takeaway is, it's about pivoting.
- Diversify your identity: Don't let your "brand" be just one thing (like "gymnast" or "daughter"). Shayla moved into health science, tumbling, bodybuilding, and motherhood.
- Use your platform for good: When things got dire for her mother, she used her social media reach to actually save a life. That's real-world impact.
- Honesty over perfection: People connected with her more when she talked about her heart surgery and her parents' divorce than when she was just winning trophies.
If you're interested in keeping up with the family's next moves, following Shayla's YouTube or Instagram is your best bet for the most authentic, non-tabloid updates. She’s proved that she’s the anchor of that family, and as Sullivan grows up, we’re likely going to see a whole new side of the Retton-Kelley legacy.
Check out Shayla’s older vlogs if you want to see the actual work that goes into NPC bikini prep—it’s a lot less glamorous than the stage photos make it look.