Honestly, playing the Sly 2 Band of Thieves trophy guide experience feels like a time machine back to 2004, but with the added dopamine hit of that sweet, sweet Platinum notification. It’s a weirdly relaxing game. Unlike the first Sly Cooper, where you had to find every single clue bottle just to survive a hit, Sly 2 is way more chill. You’ve got a health bar now. You’ve got a crew. You’ve got gadgets. But if you’re looking at that trophy list, you might notice something a bit lopsided.
Most of the trophies are just... given to you. You finish a chapter, you get a trophy. You beat a boss, you get a trophy. It’s the kind of list that makes you feel like a gaming god for basically just sitting on your couch and enjoying a heist movie. But there are a few spots where things get a little hairy, especially if you aren’t paying attention to your coin count or those specific gadget requirements.
Why the Sly 2 Trophy List is Actually Better (and Easier) Than the Original
The first game was a masterpiece, sure, but those Master Thief Sprints were a nightmare for anyone without caffeine-infused reflexes. Sly 2 does away with the timed trials. It shifts the focus toward the "heist" vibe. You’re spending more time as Bentley and Murray, which means the trophy path is less about platforming perfection and more about exploration.
Most people get wrong the idea that you need to find every single clue bottle to get the Platinum. You don't. In the original PS3 HD Collection and the newer PS4/PS5 versions (ported via the PS Plus Classics catalog), the clue bottles are almost entirely optional for the trophies. You still want them for the safe upgrades—because who doesn't want the Music Box or Shadow Power—but if you're just hunting for that 100% completion mark, you can actually skip some of the more annoying ones.
The Big Money Problem
The real gatekeeper in any Sly 2 Band of Thieves trophy guide is the "Loot!" trophy. You need to collect 1,500 coins. That sounds like a lot, especially since most of the stuff you buy at ThiefNet—the in-game shop—is actually useful and you'll want to spend your cash immediately.
Here is the trick. Don't just smash crates. That's for amateurs. You need to pickpocket. Pickpocketing is the heartbeat of this game. You sneak up behind a guard, wait for the golden glow on their pocket, and hit Circle. Do it three times for the high-value loot. If you’re just running through missions, you’ll end up broke. If you spend five minutes in each hub world just stripping the guards of their jewelry, you’ll hit that 1,500 mark before you even reach the Contessa’s levels.
Breaking Down the Episode Trophies
Every episode in the game has a trophy attached to its completion. You can't miss these. It's impossible. If you finish the game, you have 80% of the trophies.
- Episode 1: The Black Heron. This is your tutorial. It’s Paris. It’s vibes. Dimitri is a legend. Just follow the markers.
- Episode 2: A Starry Knight. Rajan’s palace is where the game opens up. This is where you should start practicing your combat moves for Murray-specific trophies.
- Episode 3: The Predator Awakes. The jungle is a vertical nightmare. Use the paraglider often here.
- Episode 4: Jailbreak. This is where the difficulty spikes. The Contessa isn't playing around.
- Episode 5: A Tangled Web. Gothic horror meets heist.
- Episode 6: He Who Tames the Iron Horse. Canada. Trains. It's glorious.
- Episode 7: Menace from the North, Eh! More Canada, but with more ice.
- Episode 8: Dead Men Tell No Tales. The final push.
If you’re playing on the newer PlayStation Plus versions, remember you have a rewind feature. Use it. If you mess up a jump or get spotted during a delicate heist, just rewind ten seconds. It makes the "perfection" required for certain missions a total joke.
The Specific Stuff You’ll Actually Miss
Okay, let’s talk about the trophies that aren't tied to the story. These are the ones that keep you from the Platinum.
The "Watchful Eye" Trophy
You need to buy the Alarm Clock from ThiefNet. It’s cheap, but if you’re focused on buying "cool" upgrades like the Feral Pounce, you might ignore it. Buy it early. You don't even really have to use it effectively; just own it.
The "Sneaky Sly" Trophy
You need to perform a stealth hit on 15 guards. This is the Triangle + Square combo. You have to be behind them and undetected. Honestly, you should be doing this anyway because it's the most satisfying sound in the game. That "clink" of the cane hitting their head? Perfection.
The "Careful Training" Trophy
This one requires you to find a single "Special Move" in a safe. This is where those clue bottles do come in. You only need to complete one set of bottles in one level to get this. Episode 1 is the easiest. The bottles are all in relatively obvious places around the theater and the back alleys of Paris. Find them all, get the code from the Bentley's binocucom, open the safe. Boom. Trophy.
Managing the Grind in Canada and Beyond
By the time you hit the snowy levels in Canada, the game can feel like a bit of a slog. The maps are huge. The guards are tougher. To keep your trophy progress on track, you need to make sure you're swapping between characters at the safehouse frequently.
🔗 Read more: Dogfight? The Real Focus of an Airplane Battle NYT Crossword Fans Are Searching For
There are trophies for buying specific upgrades for Murray and Bentley too. You need the "Hover Pack" for Bentley and the "Turnbuckle Power" for Murray. If you aren't checking ThiefNet after every few missions, you'll miss the window where these become available.
Why the 2024/2025 Re-releases Changed Everything
If you are playing this on a modern console, you have the benefit of separate trophy lists. You can Platinum the PS4 version and the PS5 version separately. That’s two Platinums for one game. Since the Sly 2 Band of Thieves trophy guide is so straightforward, a lot of trophy hunters use this to pad their stats.
The emulation on the newer consoles is mostly great, but watch out for the "bottles" glitch. Occasionally, a bottle might clip through the environment. If you're counting 29/30 and you've searched the whole map, just restart the episode. It sucks, but it happens.
The Secret to Infinite Coins
If you find yourself at the end of the game and you're still short on the "Loot!" trophy, go to Episode 6 (the first Canada level). The guards here carry high-tier items like gold watches and pens. You can run a circuit around the trains, pickpocketing everyone, and then jump into the water to "reset" the guards. Or just enter and exit the safehouse.
Items you steal have to be sold at ThiefNet to count toward your "total coins," but the trophy usually triggers based on your current wallet balance, not your lifetime earnings. Keep that in mind. Don't spend a dime until the trophy pops if you're worried about it.
Common Misconceptions About the Platinum
- "I need to play the mini-games." No. Unlike Sly 3, which has those annoying 100% completion requirements for every mission, Sly 2 is very forgiving.
- "The game is missable." Nothing is missable. You can go back to any episode at any time from the main menu.
- "Bentley's bombs don't count for combat trophies." They don't. Most combat trophies require Sly's cane or Murray's fists. Use Murray for the "knockout" related tasks. He's a tank for a reason.
Actionable Steps for a Quick Platinum
To get this done in about 10-12 hours, follow this logic.
Start by focusing entirely on the story. Don't wander aimlessly. Every time you enter a new hub, pickpocket five guards before starting a mission. This ensures your bank account stays healthy. In Episode 1, commit to finding all 30 clue bottles. It’s the easiest map to navigate and it knocks out the "Careful Training" trophy immediately so you don't have to worry about bottles for the rest of the game.
When you get to the Contessa levels (Episodes 4 and 5), buy the paraglider. It makes movement so much faster and prevents frustrating falls that waste time. Always check ThiefNet after you finish a "Big Heist" at the end of an episode. New gadgets unlock based on story progress.
If you're playing the PS5 version, use the "Cloud Save" trick before buying expensive gadgets. Buy the gadget, let the trophy pop, then download your save to get your money back. It’s a bit cheesy, but it saves hours of grinding for coins.
Once you finish the final fight against Clock-La, if the Platinum hasn't popped, check your list for the "Coin Collector" or "Loot!" trophies. Those are almost always the last ones people need. Spend twenty minutes in the Paris level pickpocketing the easy guards near the start, and you're finished.
Check your progress in the "Job" menu often. It tells you exactly how far you are in each episode. This isn't a hard Platinum, but it's a rewarding one because Sly 2 is arguably the best game in the trilogy. The writing holds up. The art style is timeless. Just enjoy the ride and don't overthink the bottles.