You ever play a game that feels like it’s actually rotting your brain? In a good way, I mean. Stygian: Reign of the Old Ones is that kind of game. It’s a messy, beautiful, deeply depressing love letter to H.P. Lovecraft that somehow manages to be both the best and worst RPG you'll ever install on your Steam deck. Honestly, most cosmic horror games just slap a tentacle on a monster and call it a day. Stygian goes deeper. It understands that Lovecraft isn't about jump scares; it's about the crushing weight of knowing you're absolutely, 100% screwed.
The world ended. That’s where you start.
The "Black Day" happened, and now the city of Arkham has been ripped out of our reality and tossed into some bleak, stinking pocket dimension. There’s no sun. There’s no hope. People are trading "Cigarettes" as currency because, well, what else are you going to do while the world dissolves? Developed by Cultic Games and released back in 2019, this title still occupies a weird, cult-status space in the CRPG community. It’s famous for its art and infamous for its ending. Or rather, its lack of one.
The RPG Mechanics That Actually Care About Your Sanity
Most RPGs treat "insanity" like a second health bar. You take "brain damage," you drink a blue potion, you're fine. Stygian: Reign of the Old Ones hates that trope. In this game, your mental state is a mechanical nightmare you have to manage alongside your actual guts spilling out.
If you choose the "Academic" background, you're going to see the world differently than a "Criminal" or a "Performer." It’s not just flavor text. It changes how you gain Sanity back. An Academic might feel better by solving a logical puzzle or reading a dusty tome, while a more nihilistic character might actually feel better when things go wrong because it confirms their worldview. It’s brilliant. It’s the kind of character-driven crunch that reminds you of Disco Elysium, though with a much darker, grime-coated lens.
Why the Combat Divides Everyone
The combat is turn-based, hex-grid stuff. It’s clunky. It’s slow. A lot of players bounce off it immediately. But here's the thing: it's supposed to feel desperate. You aren't a superhero. You're a fragile human trying to stab a shoggoth with a rusty knife. Every bullet you fire is a literal waste of money. Sometimes, the best move is just to run away and hope you don't go blind from the stress.
Magick is even worse. In Stygian, casting a spell isn't a "cool" power-up. It costs you permanent Sanity or physical health. You’re literally trading bits of your soul to cast a minor hex. It makes every encounter feel like a lose-lose situation, which fits the theme perfectly but, man, it can be frustrating if you’re used to power fantasies.
The Art Style is Doing the Heavy Lifting
Let’s be real for a second. The reason anyone still talks about Stygian: Reign of the Old Ones is the visuals. It looks like a 1920s storybook illustrated by someone who hasn't slept in three weeks and has seen things they shouldn't have. The hand-drawn aesthetic is gorgeous. It captures the "Dying Earth" vibe better than almost any other medium.
The character designs are grotesque in a way that feels intentional. You’ll meet a man who’s slowly turning into a fish (classic Innsmouth vibes) or a cultist who looks like he’s made of wet laundry. The color palette is all bruised purples, sickly greens, and dried-blood reds. It’s atmospheric as hell.
The Writing Doesn't Flinch
Cultic Games didn't play it safe with the script. The dialogue is dense, flowery, and appropriately bleak. It leans heavily into the existential dread. You'll find yourself in conversations where there is no "good" choice. Do you help the starving man, or do you save your last tin of meat because you know you’ll need it to bribe a guard later? The game forces you to be a jerk just to survive, and then it mocks you for it.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Ending
Here is the elephant in the room. The big, cosmic, multi-dimensional elephant.
If you look at the Steam reviews for Stygian: Reign of the Old Ones, you’ll see a sea of red. Why? Because the game just... stops. It’s not a cliffhanger. It’s a brick wall. You spend 15 to 20 hours building a character, navigating the ruins of Arkham, and uncovering a massive conspiracy involving the Great Old Ones, and then the credits roll right when it feels like "Act 2" should be starting.
💡 You might also like: Assassin's Creed Shadows Microtransactions: What’s Actually Changing This Time
The developers originally planned for this to be a much larger story. Financial issues and the realities of indie development meant they had to cut it short. For years, fans hoped for a sequel or a "Part 2" to finish the story. As of 2026, we’re still waiting, and honestly, we probably shouldn't hold our breath.
Does that make it a bad game? Not necessarily. It makes it a "truncated masterpiece." If you go in knowing that you’re playing a fragment of a larger vision, you can appreciate the journey for what it is. If you go in expecting a neat resolution, you’re going to throw your mouse at the wall.
Is It Still Worth Playing in 2026?
Actually, yeah. Despite the flaws, there hasn't been another game that captures this specific flavor of Lovecraftian RPG quite as well. Call of Cthulhu (2018) was okay, and The Sinking City had its moments, but they both felt like action games wearing a Cthulhu mask. Stygian feels like it was written by someone who actually read the source material and understood that the horror isn't the monster—it's the realization that the monster doesn't even notice you're there.
How to Actually Enjoy Stygian
If you're going to dive in, you need to play it a certain way.
- Don't try to win. You won't. Just try to see as much of the weirdness as possible before your character loses their mind.
- Focus on the "Outsider" or "Occultist" builds. They have the most interesting unique dialogue options.
- Read everything. The lore notes are where the real world-building happens.
- Accept the jank. The UI is a bit clunky, and the pathfinding is occasionally questionable.
It’s a game of vibes. If you’re a fan of the World of Darkness tabletop games or old-school Interplay RPGs, this is going to hit a very specific itch. It’s uncomfortable, it’s unfair, and it’s deeply cynical.
Practical Next Steps for the Aspiring Investigator
If you've decided to brave the streets of Arkham, don't go in blind. You’ll just end up as a sacrifice in some basement.
- Check the Community Patches: Since official support has been quiet, the Steam Community forums and Nexus Mods are your best friends. There are several fan-made tweaks that fix some of the more egregious bugs and rebalance the combat to be slightly less punishing.
- Manage Your Expectations on Length: Treat it as a "Season 1" that got cancelled. If you view it as a 15-hour experience rather than a 50-hour epic, the ending hurts less.
- Invest in the "Speech" Skill: Combat is a death sentence. Being able to talk your way out of a situation or manipulate an NPC is far more valuable than being able to fire a pistol you can't afford bullets for anyway.
- Watch the Sanity Thresholds: Your character changes as they lose Sanity. Sometimes, having a specific "affliction" actually opens up new ways to interact with the world. It’s one of the few games where "losing" a mental save can be more interesting than succeeding.
Stygian: Reign of the Old Ones is a flawed gem. It’s a reminder that sometimes, ambition outstrips budget, but the result is still more interesting than a hundred polished, boring AAA titles. Just remember: the void doesn't care about your completion percentage.