Honestly, it’s kinda wild that Super Mario Maker 2 - US Version is still the gold standard for creative platforming years after its debut. You’d think the novelty of building your own levels would’ve worn off by now, or that some indie clone would’ve snatched the crown. But it hasn't. The community is still obsessively uploading thousands of courses every single day, ranging from absolute "Kaizo" nightmares that require frame-perfect precision to charming, story-driven adventures that feel like they were ripped straight out of a lost Nintendo archive.
Nintendo didn't just iterate on the Wii U original; they basically blew the doors off the hinges.
The US version, specifically the physical and digital releases for the North American market, carries that specific NTSC-region charm with full English localization for the quirky dialogue of characters like Undodog and Yamamura. If you’ve ever spent three hours trying to align a single Shellmet jump, you know exactly what I’m talking about. It’s a loop of frustration and pure, unadulterated dopamine.
📖 Related: Why Solitaire Classic Free Online Is Still the Best Way to Kill Time Without Losing Your Mind
What Most People Get Wrong About the US Release
A common misconception is that the Super Mario Maker 2 - US Version is functionally different from the Japanese or European editions in terms of gameplay mechanics. It isn't. The physics engine is universal. If a Japanese creator builds a level using a specific "3D World" cat-suit glitch, it’ll work exactly the same on your US-bought copy. However, the regional differences usually come down to the eShop ecosystem and the Nintendo Switch Online requirements.
In North America, the game was a massive tentpole release for the Switch. You’ve probably seen the specific box art featuring Mario and Luigi in construction gear, which became an instant icon of the late 2010s gaming era.
The real meat of the game is the Course World. This is where the US player base truly shines, contributing some of the most innovative "troll" levels and "music" levels in existence. While the game technically supports global play, the social meta-game—YouTube creators like Ryukahr or PangaeaPanga—mostly centers around the English-speaking community, which keeps the US version’s ecosystem incredibly vibrant.
The 3D World Style and Why It Changed Everything
When Nintendo announced that Super Mario 3D World would be a selectable style, the community lost its collective mind. It was a huge deal. Unlike the classic styles—Super Mario Bros., SMB3, Super Mario World, and New Super Mario Bros. U—the 3D World style operates on a completely different engine.
You can't just swap a 3D World level into a Super Mario World skin.
The assets are unique. You get the Clear Pipes. You get the crates. You get Meowser. It added a layer of verticality and movement depth that the older, tile-based styles couldn't touch. For creators in the US, this meant a massive shift in how "speedruns" were designed. Suddenly, we weren't just jumping over Piranha Plants; we were long-jumping across gaps and using the Cat Suit to climb walls in ways that felt revolutionary for a 2D-plane creator.
✨ Don't miss: Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon Classes Explained (Simply)
The Power-Up Evolution
Think about the Link power-up for a second. That wasn't just a skin. It turned Mario into the protagonist of an entirely different franchise. Adding the Master Sword to Super Mario Maker 2 - US Version via the Version 2.0.0 update changed the fundamental logic of level design.
- The Bow: Allows for hitting distant switches.
- The Shield: Blocks projectiles that would normally kill Mario.
- The Downward Thrust: A classic Zelda II move that breaks blocks beneath you.
- Bombs: Essential for "metroidvania" style progression within a Mario level.
This kind of variety is why the game doesn't get old. One minute you're playing a traditional platformer, and the next, you're in a puzzle-heavy dungeon that feels more like The Legend of Zelda than anything involving a plumber.
Story Mode: Not Just a Tutorial
A lot of people skip the Story Mode in games like this. Don't do that.
The Story Mode in Super Mario Maker 2 - US Version is actually a brilliant masterclass in level design theory. It follows Mario as he helps rebuild Princess Peach's castle after Undodog accidentally resets the world (it’s a whole thing). Nintendo’s designers used these 100+ levels to show off exactly what the engine can do.
They use the "On/Off Switches" in ways that are genuinely mind-bending. They show you how to use "Snake Blocks" to create tension without making the game feel unfair. For a US player looking to get into serious building, the Story Mode is basically a free degree in game design. It’s conversational, funny, and surprisingly challenging toward the end.
Night Themes and Experimental Physics
One of the weirder additions was the "Night" theme. It’s not just a palette swap. Depending on the environment, the night theme introduces unique, sometimes frustrating, physics changes:
- Ground: Mushrooms turn into Rotten Mushrooms that chase you.
- Underground: The entire screen flips upside down.
- Forest: The water turns into purple poison.
- Desert: Wind storms push you around.
- Snow: Everything becomes incredibly slippery, even for Mario standards.
These tweaks forced creators to think outside the box. You couldn't just build a standard level and turn it to night; you had to design for the chaos.
The Multiplayer Chaos Factor
Let’s be real: the multiplayer Versus mode in Super Mario Maker 2 - US Version is a beautiful disaster. It is notoriously laggy at times, which has become a bit of a meme within the community. Yet, despite the occasional stutter, it’s one of the most addictive ways to play.
Four players racing through a level designed for one person? It’s pure salt. You’ll be throwing people into pits, stealing their power-ups, and jumping off their heads to reach the flagpole. It’s the "Mario Party" effect—it ruins friendships, but you can’t stop playing. The US servers are consistently populated, so finding a match usually takes seconds, regardless of the time of day.
Dealing with the "Boo" System
Nintendo's approach to curation is... interesting. They use a "Like" and "Boo" system. If your level gets too many Boos, it disappears from the "Endless Challenge" rotation. This is a bit controversial. Some creators feel it stifles innovation because players might "Boo" a level simply because it’s too hard, not because it’s poorly designed.
However, from a player's perspective, this system generally keeps the absolute garbage out of your hair. You won't see as many "Enemy Spam" levels—those nightmare rooms filled with 50 Bowsers—as you did in the first game. The algorithm in the Super Mario Maker 2 - US Version is much more aggressive about surfacing quality content.
Why Technical Skill Matters More Than Ever
In the early days, you could get a "Popular" level just by making a simple auto-mario course where you don't touch the controller. Those are still around, sure. But the US community has moved toward "Technical" and "Aesthetic" tags.
We’re seeing levels that look like high-art pixel paintings. We’re seeing "Uno Mas" levels—short, one-screen puzzles that require you to understand a very specific, often hidden, game mechanic to win. This level of depth is why the game stays relevant. It’s an educational tool as much as it is a game. It teaches you about hitboxes, spawn cycles, and player psychology.
Real Examples of Community Legends
If you want to see what's possible, look up creators like PangaeaPanga or Grand Poo Bear. These guys have built levels that have taken the community weeks to clear. The level "Pit of Panga: P-Break" from the first game set the stage, but the sequels found in Super Mario Maker 2 - US Version are even more complex. They utilize "shell jumps," "mid-airs," and "item abuse" in ways that Nintendo likely never intended.
And that’s the beauty of it. The "US Version" isn't just a product on a shelf; it's a gateway to a massive, global competition of "can you beat this?"
The Final Update and Its Legacy
Nintendo officially stopped releasing major content updates for the game after the "World Maker" update. Some fans were bummed. They wanted Super Mario Bros. 2 (USA) as a full style, or maybe a Galaxy theme.
But even without those, the World Maker was a massive parting gift. It allowed you to string up to 40 levels together into a custom map. You can literally create your own full Mario game and share the "Super World" with the planet. This effectively gave the game infinite life. As long as the servers stay up, the Super Mario Maker 2 - US Version remains the most comprehensive 2D Mario experience ever created.
Actionable Steps for New and Returning Players
If you're just picking up the Super Mario Maker 2 - US Version or dusting off your cartridge, here is how you actually get the most out of it without getting overwhelmed.
🔗 Read more: In Stars and Time: Why This Time-Loop RPG is Ruining My Sleep
Start with Yamamura's Dojo. It’s easy to ignore the tutorial bird, but the lessons on "Level Flow" and "Fairness" are gold. They explain why you shouldn't put a "Hidden Block" right where a player is likely to jump—a cardinal sin in level design.
Use a Stylus. Seriously. Building with a controller in docked mode is fine, but the handheld touch-screen experience is 10x faster. Any cheap capacitive stylus will work, and it makes placing individual coins or tiles much less of a chore.
Filter by "Detailed Search." Don't just play what’s on the front page. Use the search filters to find "Standard" levels if you want a classic Nintendo feel, or "Puzzle-solving" if you want to use your brain. This is the best way to avoid the "Hot Garbage" that occasionally slips through the cracks.
Upload and Iterate. Don't wait until your level is "perfect" to upload it. Watch the "Failure Points" in the course menu after people have played your level. If everyone is dying at the exact same spot, your jump is probably too hard or your indicator is misleading. Fix it and re-upload.
Join the Community. Follow the SMM2 subreddits or Discord channels. The "Level Exchange" threads are the best way to get your first 10-20 plays, which helps the algorithm "see" your level and start showing it to strangers.
The game is a masterpiece of user-generated content. It’s a toolset that feels like a toy, and despite its age, there is still nothing else quite like it on the market. Whether you’re a builder or a player, the Super Mario Maker 2 - US Version is a mandatory piece of any Switch library.