If you grew up in the 90s, Bayside High wasn’t just a fictional school. It was the place where we all wanted to be. We wanted Zack’s giant cell phone, Kelly’s cheerleading outfits, and maybe even Screech’s... okay, nobody actually wanted to be Screech. But when Lifetime dropped The Unauthorized Saved by the Bell Story in 2014, it promised to rip the neon-colored veil off our childhood nostalgia.
The movie was basically the fever dream of Dustin Diamond. Or, at least, it was based on his 2009 tell-all book, Behind the Bell. Because Diamond was an executive producer on the film, the saved by the bell unauthorized cast had a very specific, and often controversial, job: they had to play the real actors (Mark-Paul, Mario, Tiffani, etc.) through the lens of Diamond’s often bitter memories.
Honestly, the casting was a mixed bag. Some of these kids looked like they’d just stepped out of a Bayside locker, while others felt like they were in a completely different movie.
Who Actually Played Who?
Let’s get into the names. If you watched it and thought, "Wait, I know that guy," you probably did. Lifetime didn't go for big stars, but they found some talented Canadian up-and-comers.
- Dylan Everett as Mark-Paul Gosselaar (Zack Morris): Dylan was already a bit of a teen star in Canada from Degrassi and Wingin' It. He had the unenviable task of playing the guy who played the "coolest kid in school." While he nailed the blonde hair and the brown eyebrows—which Diamond's book weirdly obsessed over—critics at the time felt he was a bit too short to capture the lanky Gosselaar energy.
- Sam Kindseth as Dustin Diamond (Screech): Since the movie is told from Dustin’s perspective, Sam Kindseth is really the star. He had to play a version of Diamond that was constantly brooding, drinking from a flask, and practicing karate in his trailer. It’s a pretty dark take on the guy we knew as the goofball nerd.
- Alyssa Lynch as Tiffani-Amber Thiessen (Kelly Kapowski): Alyssa Lynch took on the role of the girl-next-door. This was one of her first big breaks, and she later popped up in The Unauthorized Beverly Hills, 90210 Story.
- Julian Works as Mario Lopez (A.C. Slater): Playing Mario Lopez is basically just a contest of who has the best dimples and who can wear a tank top. Julian Works had the swagger, though the movie portrayed "young Mario" as a bit of a competitive hothead.
- Tiera Skovbye as Elizabeth Berkley (Jessie Spano): Many fans actually thought Tiera was the standout. She had to re-enact the infamous "I'm so excited! I'm so... scared!" caffeine pill breakdown. It’s meta as heck—an actress playing an actress acting out a scene about a nervous breakdown. Tiera later went on to star in Riverdale (as Polly Cooper), so she’s definitely the one who "made it" most from this group.
- Taylor Russell as Lark Voorhies (Lisa Turtle): Taylor Russell is a powerhouse now (Bones and All, Lost in Space), but back then, she was just starting out. She was widely praised for getting Lark’s specific vocal cadence and mannerisms down perfectly.
Why the Real Cast Hated It
You can’t talk about the saved by the bell unauthorized cast without talking about the bridge-burning that happened behind the scenes. Mark-Paul Gosselaar, Mario Lopez, and Elizabeth Berkley didn't exactly roll out the red carpet for this movie.
The problem? Most of the "facts" in the movie were disputed. Diamond's book alleged that the cast was constantly hooked on drugs and sleeping with each other in every combination imaginable.
Years later, Diamond actually apologized. He admitted that the ghostwriter of his book had "fabricated" or "greatly exaggerated" many of the most scandalous parts. This makes the movie a weird artifact—it’s a biopic of a book that even the author eventually said wasn't entirely true.
When you watch the saved by the bell unauthorized cast perform these scenes, you aren't watching the history of Saved by the Bell. You're watching a dramatized version of Dustin Diamond’s regrets.
The Manny Jacinto Connection
Here’s a fun piece of trivia for the fans of The Good Place or The Acolyte. Did you know Manny Jacinto is in this? He’s not playing one of the main six, but he shows up in a minor role as "Eric." It’s wild to see how many people from this random Lifetime movie ended up becoming huge stars a decade later.
Is It Even Accurate?
Short answer: Sorta. Long answer: Not really.
The movie gets the "vibe" of the era right. It nails the stress of a show that was constantly on the verge of cancellation. Did you know Saved by the Bell was actually a spin-off/rebrand of a show called Good Morning, Miss Bliss? The movie covers that transition well, showing how Brandon Tartikoff (played by Adam Greydon Reid) helped shape the show.
But the "unauthorized" part of the title is doing a lot of heavy lifting. Because the producers didn't have the rights to the actual show's music or specific scripts, they had to "re-create" iconic scenes in ways that felt just a little bit off. It’s like buying the "generic brand" version of your favorite cereal. It looks the same, but the taste is definitely different.
What to Take Away From Bayside’s Dark Side
If you’re looking to dive into the history of the show, this movie is a fascinating watch, but it shouldn't be your only source. It’s a character study of fame and isolation. It shows how Dustin Diamond felt like an outsider even when he was part of the most famous group of teens on the planet.
For a more "accurate" look (or at least one the other cast members agree with), check out the 2020 revival series on Peacock. It’s much more self-aware and actually features the original actors poking fun at their own "squeaky clean" history.
If you’re a die-hard fan, your next move should be tracking down the "Zack Morris is Trash" web series or listening to Mark-Paul Gosselaar’s podcast, Zack to the Future. Those give a much more nuanced (and hilarious) look at what was actually happening on those sets without the Lifetime-movie melodrama.
📖 Related: Why the Amityville Horror movie 1979 remains the most unsettling haunted house story ever told
The saved by the bell unauthorized cast did the best they could with the material, but at the end of the day, the real story of Bayside remains a lot more complicated—and a lot more "90s"—than any TV movie could capture.
Next Steps for Bayside Fans:
- Watch the 2020 Reboot: It’s actually surprisingly good and treats the legacy of the original characters with a mix of love and brutal honesty.
- Listen to "Zack to the Future": Hearing Mark-Paul Gosselaar watch the show for the first time as an adult is the ultimate "behind the scenes" experience.
- Check out Taylor Russell’s later work: If you want to see what a "star is born" moment looks like, watch her in Bones and All to see how far she’s come since playing Lisa Turtle.