So you’ve made it to Neely’s Bar. You’re wandering through the fog of East South Vale, dodging those twitchy Lying Figures, and you finally find a moment of "peace" inside this dingy pub. Then you see it—the jukebox. It's broken, obviously. Everything in this town is broken.
The silent hill 2 remake jukebox puzzle isn't just some throwaway fetch quest. It's actually a pretty clever addition by Bloober Team that forces you to explore the local shops and apartments. Honestly, it’s one of the first times the remake makes you feel like a real detective instead of just a guy looking for his dead wife. If you’re stuck staring at the mechanical guts of that machine or can’t find that last piece of vinyl, don't sweat it. Most people miss a specific interaction or a hidden key that stalls their progress for an hour.
Finding the Pieces (Because Nothing is Ever Easy)
You can't just "fix" the jukebox by hitting it. You need three specific items scattered across the map. If you haven't checked the jukebox yet, do that first. James will pull out a Broken Vinyl Record (half of one, anyway) and find a note that basically tells you the machine is trashed.
Groovy Music: The Vinyl and Glue
Head north to Groovy Music on Neely Street. You’ll have to smash the front window to get in, which is satisfying but also feels like a dinner bell for every monster in a two-block radius. Go to the back room. On the table, you’ll find the other half of the Broken Vinyl Record and a bottle of Vinyl Glue.
Open your inventory. Combine the two halves with the glue. Now you’ve got a "Glued Up Vinyl Record." It looks sketchy, but in Silent Hill logic, it's basically brand new.
✨ Don't miss: Pick Four NJ Winning Numbers: What Most People Get Wrong
Texan Cafe: The Coin
Next, hustle over to the Texan Cafe at the east end of Katz Street. Go behind the counter and look for the cash register. This bit trips people up: you have to actually interact with the key on the register first, then hit the "Cash" button to pop the drawer. Grab the Neely’s Bar Coin.
Saul Street Apartments: The Button
This is the part everyone hates. Head to the Saul Street Apartments. You’ll need to find the key for Apartment 5 in the manager's office first. Once you’re in the actual apartment on the second floor, you’ve got to crawl through a vent to get to the back areas. Eventually, you’ll end up on the third floor in a bathroom.
There’s a hole in the wall. A gross, fleshy, "why-would-you-put-your-hand-in-there" hole. Stick your hand in. You have to interact with it three times. James will eventually pull out the Jukebox Button (specifically the '2' button).
Solving the Mechanical Mess
Back at Neely's Bar, the real silent hill 2 remake jukebox puzzle begins. You aren't just slotting items in; you have to fix the internal mechanism.
- The Green Cylinder: Look at the bottom of the machine. Rotate the green cylinder until the little red arm can hook onto it.
- The Blue Cog: Once they're connected, you need to lower the blue cog. This moves the record tray into position.
- Insert the Goods: Pop your repaired record onto the tray.
- The Interface: Move up to the front of the machine. Insert the Jukebox Button into the empty #2 slot. Then, drop your Neely’s Bar Coin into the slot on the right.
The Winning Combo
The note you found earlier (or the clues on the record) hint at the selection. You need to play record C2.
- Press the C button (it’s the blue one).
- Press the 2 button (the one you just found in the wall-slime).
If you did it right, the record will play a haunting tune, a cutscene triggers, and you’ll get the Neely’s Bar Key. This opens the door in the back of the bar, leading you toward the Wood Side Apartments.
Why This Puzzle Actually Matters
In the original 2001 game, Neely’s Bar was mostly just a place for a cryptic message on the wall. The remake turns it into a hub. By forcing you into Groovy Music and the Saul Street Apartments, the game ensures you see the environmental storytelling—the notes about people disappearing, the creeping rot in the hallways.
It’s also a test of your patience. Silent Hill 2 isn't an action game; it's a "look in every corner" game. If you try to rush the silent hill 2 remake jukebox puzzle, you’re going to get frustrated. Take your time. Listen to the radio static.
Actionable Tips for the Road Ahead
- Don't ignore the Saul Street roof: While you're at the apartments for the button, there are some supplies nearby that make the upcoming apartment section much easier.
- Check your map: The game actually marks these locations once you read the note at the bar. If you don't see the icons, you probably didn't "inspect" the jukebox closely enough.
- Save your ammo: You’ll face at least three or four enemies getting these items. Use the wooden plank when you can; you'll want those handgun bullets for the bosses later.
Now that you have the Neely’s Bar Key, your next stop is the Wood Side Apartments. Make sure you’ve topped off your health. Things are about to get a lot more cramped and a lot darker.