Third Party Switch 2 Joycons: Why You Shouldn't Rush to Pre-order Yet

The hype is basically deafening at this point. With Nintendo finally pulling back the curtain on the "Switch 2"—or whatever the marketing team eventually lands on—everyone is obsessing over the hardware specs and that rumored magnetic attachment system. But honestly? The real conversation needs to be about the controllers. Specifically, the inevitable wave of third party Switch 2 Joycons that are going to flood Amazon and AliExpress the second the console hits shelves.

Nintendo has a bit of a track record here. The original Joycons were, frankly, a bit of a mess for a long time. Joy-Con drift turned from a niche complaint into a full-blown class-action headache. While the new console is expected to fix the internal sensor issues by switching to Hall Effect sticks or a more robust proprietary design, there’s always a catch. Early reports suggest the new connection method is magnetic. That changes everything for accessory makers.

If you're thinking about grabbing a pair of cheap knock-offs or even "pro" alternatives from brands like NYXI, Mobapad, or Hori on day one, you might want to slow down.

The Magnetic Shift and Why it Matters

The current Joycons use a physical rail. It’s simple. It’s mechanical. You slide it in, the pins connect, and you're gaming. But the rumors—backed by leaked manufacturing renders from late 2025—point toward a magnetic suite for the successor. This isn't just a cosmetic choice. It's a fundamental change in how the console handles input and power delivery.

For third party Switch 2 Joycons, this represents a massive technical hurdle. Magnets aren't just magnets in high-end electronics. They have to be precisely calibrated so they don't interfere with the internal storage or the display's logic boards. If a third-party manufacturer uses "dirty" magnets or fails to shield the signal properly, you aren't just looking at a disconnected controller. You're looking at potential hardware interference.

Most people don't realize that the original Switch rails were relatively easy to replicate. That’s why we saw a billion different versions of the same plastic shell. With a magnetic interface, the handshake between the controller and the tablet becomes way more complex. We're talking about induction charging hurdles and data transfer protocols that might be encrypted.

👉 See also: World of Warcraft Draenei: Why They Are Still the Most Misunderstood Race in Azeroth

Hall Effect Sticks: No Longer an "Extra"

Let’s talk about the sticks. If you’ve spent any time in the gaming community over the last three years, you know Hall Effect sensors are the gold standard. They use magnets (there's that word again) to detect movement instead of physical contact points that wear down. No friction means no drift.

By the time the Switch 2 launches in 2026, Hall Effect sticks won't be a luxury; they'll be the baseline expectation. Any third party Switch 2 Joycons that ship with traditional potentiometers are basically e-waste waiting to happen. Serious players are looking at companies like Gulikit. They were the ones who really pushed the Hall Effect tech into the mainstream for the original Switch.

But here is the kicker: Nintendo might actually include Hall Effect sensors in the official "Pro" version of their new Joycons. If they do, the third-party market loses its biggest selling point. Why buy a third-party peripheral if the official one doesn't drift? The answer usually comes down to ergonomics.

Ergonomics vs. Portability

Nintendo likes things sleek. They want the Switch 2 to fit in a slim carrying case. But humans have hands, and those tiny rectangles aren't exactly comfortable for a five-hour Monster Hunter session. This is where the third-party market usually wins.

Think about the Hori Split Pad Pro. It’s huge. It lacks rumble and motion controls. And yet, people love it. Why? Because it actually feels like a controller. For the Switch 2, we’re likely going to see a split in the market:

1. The Budget Clones: These will look exactly like the official magnetic Joycons but will probably feel light and "clicky" in a bad way.
2. The Ergonomic Titans: These will be the bulky attachments that make the console look like a Steam Deck.
3. The Feature-Rich Contenders: Brands like Binbok or NYXI will try to pack in macros, turbo buttons, and RGB lighting.

The problem with the early "Budget Clones" is the firmware. Nintendo is notorious for pushing system updates that brick third-party controllers. If the third party Switch 2 Joycons you buy don't have a USB port for firmware updates, they’re a ticking time bomb.

Backwards Compatibility: The $60 Question

The biggest question on everyone's mind is whether our old Joycons will work on the new system. Most industry analysts, including those following the supply chain leaks in Asia, suggest that while the software is backwards compatible, the physical connection is not.

If the Switch 2 uses magnets, your old rail-based Joycons won't slide on. Period.

However, they will likely still work via Bluetooth. This creates a weird niche market for "bridge" accessories. Expect to see third-party manufacturers selling magnetic-to-rail adapters. Honestly, they'll probably be clunky and ugly. It’s a classic Nintendo move—making your expensive old tech just slightly inconvenient enough that you'd rather buy the new stuff.

What to Look for When the Market Explodes

Don't buy the first thing you see on a sponsored Instagram ad. Just don't. When the third party Switch 2 Joycons start appearing, you need a checklist that goes beyond "it looks cool."

First, check the weight. Cheap controllers feel like hollow shells because they use tiny batteries and thin plastic. A good Joycon alternative should have some heft. Second, look for "HD Rumble" support. Most third-party options use "Linear Resonant Actuators" or just basic vibration motors. It feels muddy. If you're playing something like Super Mario Odyssey 2 (or whatever the launch title is), you'll miss that tactile precision.

Third—and this is the big one—is the wake-up function. A lot of early third-party controllers for the original Switch couldn't actually wake the console from sleep mode. You had to physically get up and press the power button. It sounds like a small thing. It’s actually infuriating.

The Connectivity Gamble

We also have to consider the wireless protocol. If the Switch 2 moves to a newer version of Bluetooth or a proprietary 2.4GHz low-latency signal for handheld mode, third-party companies will be playing catch-up.

• Official Nintendo Tech: Guaranteed 1ms latency.
• High-End Third Party: 5-10ms (unnoticeable for most).
• Cheap Knock-offs: 20ms+ (you will feel this in Smash Bros).

Real Talk: The Price of Convenience

We’ve seen the pricing trends. Official Joycons have stayed stubbornly at $70-$80 for nearly a decade. It's safe to assume third party Switch 2 Joycons will try to hit the $40-$55 sweet spot.

But you get what you pay for. In the original Switch era, the "cheap" $30 Joycons often had terrible deadzones. If you tried to aim a bow in Zelda, the cursor would jump pixels. For the Switch 2, with its presumably higher-resolution screen and more detailed assets, these input flaws will be even more obvious.

If you're a competitive player, you're better off waiting for a licensed "Pro" alternative from a company like PowerA. They work closely with Nintendo, meaning their chips are usually white-listed and won't get killed by a random 12.0.1 system update.

Actionable Steps for the Switch 2 Launch

If you're planning on being a day-one adopter, the accessory market is a minefield. Here is how you should actually handle the controller situation:

1. Stick to Official at Launch: Buy the console with the official Joycons first. You need a "control" to know how the system is supposed to feel.
2. Wait for the Tear-Downs: Wait for YouTubers like Spawn Wave or JerryRigEverything to tear apart the first wave of third party Switch 2 Joycons. You want to see if they actually have Hall Effect sensors or if they’re just using marketing buzzwords.
3. Prioritize Firmware Updates: Only buy third-party controllers that have a clear path for firmware updates via a PC or an app.
4. Ignore the "Amiibo Support" Clones: Most third-party controllers claim to support NFC (for Amiibos), but it rarely works well. If you care about Amiibos, just keep one official Joycon around for scanning.
5. Check the Return Policy: If you're buying from a site like Amazon, ensure it’s "Prime" eligible for easy returns. Third-party quality control is notoriously hit-or-miss in the first six months of a console's life.

The reality is that the Switch 2 is going to be a massive target for companies looking to make a quick buck on "close enough" hardware. Don't let your $500 console be ruined by a $30 pair of magnets and plastic. Wait for the reviews, check the sensor types, and for the love of everything, make sure they won't scratch that shiny new screen.

Next Steps for Savvy Gamers

• Audit your current gear: If you have a high-end Pro Controller, it is 99% certain to work with the Switch 2 via Bluetooth, so don't feel pressured to buy new "Pro" Joycons immediately.
• Watch the FCC filings: In the months leading up to the 2026 launch, keep an eye on FCC filings for brands like 8BitDo or Hori. These filings often leak the actual specs of the controllers months before they hit the market.
• Budget for the "Pro" tax: If the official Switch 2 Joycons use magnetic Hall Effect tech, expect a price hike. Budgeting $90 for a set of spares isn't unrealistic given the current economic climate and the cost of rare-earth magnets.