Back in 2018, the internet basically broke for about twenty-four hours. No, it wasn't a trailer for a $200 million Marvel movie or a surprise Beyoncé drop. It was a 14-minute YouTube video. Specifically, it was the Uncharted fan film cast reveal that fans had been screaming for since the first game hit the PS3 in 2007.
Nathan Fillion finally put on the half-tucked shirt.
Honestly, it felt like a collective fever dream coming true. For over a decade, Fillion had been the internet's "unanimous" choice to play Nathan Drake. He had the jawline, the hair, and that specific brand of "charming loser who somehow survives a collapsing building." When director Allan Ungar finally released the short, it wasn't just a fun project; it felt like a statement.
The industry usually ignores fan-casting. They think it's too obvious or too pandering. But Ungar leaned into it. He didn't just get Fillion; he assembled a group of people who actually looked and sounded like the pixels we’d been controlling for years.
The Nathan Fillion Factor
Let's be real: the heart of this thing is Fillion. Most people know him from Firefly or Castle, but for the gaming community, he is Nathan Drake. The way he delivers a line while getting punched in the face? Pure Nate.
In the short, Fillion plays an older, slightly more weathered version of the character. He’s tied to a chair, getting interrogated by a guy named Diego. Even in a hostage situation, he’s cracking jokes about the guy's breath. That’s the "Uncharted" DNA. Fillion’s performance reminded everyone why the Tom Holland casting felt so jarring to the hardcore base later on. Holland was a great "Young Drake," sure, but Fillion was the Drake from the games.
He also produced the thing. This wasn't just a gig for him; it was a "scratch an itch" project. He and Ungar reportedly met over vegan Thai food (weird detail, but true) and decided to just go for it because the official movie was stuck in development hell for the tenth year in a row.
Who Else Was in the Uncharted Fan Film Cast?
While Fillion took the headlines, the supporting cast was equally "on the nose" in the best way possible.
👉 See also: Love After Lockup Lizzie and Scott: Why This Messy Saga Still Keeps Us Talking
Stephen Lang as Victor "Sully" Sullivan
If Fillion was the perfect Nate, Stephen Lang was the cosmic-level choice for Sully. Lang, known for playing terrifying villains in Avatar and Don’t Breathe, flipped the switch to play the cigar-chomping, shirt-wearing mentor. When he shows up in that final scene in the Jeep, it’s uncanny. He didn't just play Sully; he inhabited the guy's soul. The mustache alone deserved its own billing.
Mircea Monroe as Elena Fisher
Monroe had the unenviable task of playing the moral compass of the series. Elena is tough, smart, and usually the only person in the room with a plan. While her screen time was limited to the very end of the short, she nailed the "bickering couple" energy with Fillion instantly.
Geno Segers as Diego
Every Uncharted story needs a heavy. Segers, with that booming bass voice, played the interrogator. He’s the one trying to get Nate to talk about the Flor de la Mar. He provided the perfect physical foil for Fillion’s wisecracking.
Ernie Reyes Jr. as El Tigre
Action fans probably recognized Reyes Jr. from Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles II or The Rundown. He played one of the henchmen, bringing some serious martial arts legitimacy to the fight choreography.
Why the Fan Film Cast Still Matters in 2026
You've probably seen the 2022 big-budget movie starring Tom Holland and Mark Wahlberg. It made money. It was a fine popcorn flick. But if you ask a fan of the Naughty Dog games which version they prefer, they’ll point to the 15-minute YouTube video every single time.
Why? Because the Uncharted fan film cast understood the assignment.
💡 You might also like: Hunter Hunter female characters and why Togashi writes them differently
The official movie felt like a generic action-adventure film that happened to have the name "Uncharted" slapped on it. The fan film felt like a lost level of the game. It proved that you don't need a hundred million dollars if you have the right people in the right roles.
The Production Secrets
Allan Ungar didn't have a Sony-sized budget. They shot the whole thing in five days.
- The Locations: They used spots in Palmdale, Santa Clarita, Beverly Hills, and Malibu.
- The Combat: Fillion did most of his own stunts. That one-shot camera move where he jumps out of a window and starts a fistfight? They did that 11 times. They used the 7th take because the gun jammed in the first five.
- The Accuracy: Even the way the camera follows Fillion—over the shoulder, slightly tilted—mimics the third-person gameplay style.
What You Can Learn From This
If you’re a creator or just a fan, there’s a massive takeaway here: authenticity wins. The reason this cast resonated so deeply is that they weren't trying to "reimagine" the characters for a broader audience. They were trying to honor the source material.
If you haven't seen it yet, or if it's been a few years, go back and watch it on YouTube. It’s a masterclass in how to do a live-action adaptation.
Next Steps for Uncharted Fans:
Check out Allan Ungar’s social media or interviews from around 2018. He frequently discussed the "what ifs" of a full-length sequel. Also, if you’re into the technical side, look for the behind-the-scenes "Bloopers" video. Seeing Fillion and Lang break character while trying to act out a scene involving "medical-grade halitosis" is arguably as entertaining as the film itself.
Don't wait for Hollywood to give you the perfect version of your favorite story. Sometimes, a group of passionate actors and a director with a clear vision can do more in 14 minutes than a studio can do in a decade.