If you think Eli Manning is still hunkered down in a high-rise with a view of the Hudson, you’re basically living in 2012. People often assume that retired NFL royalty stays in the heart of the city, rubbing elbows with Wall Street's finest at five-star Manhattan bistros. Honestly, that’s just not Eli. He’s always been the "low-key" Manning, the one who’d rather be at a backyard BBQ than a red-carpet gala. So, where does Eli Manning live exactly?
The short answer is Summit, New Jersey. But there is a lot more to the story than just a pin on a map. Between beach houses in the Hamptons and a stubborn piece of real estate in Mississippi that just won't sell, his living situation is a bit more spread out than you'd expect.
✨ Don't miss: Jeanine Pirro Grandchildren: What Most People Get Wrong About Her Family Life
The Summit Setup: Why New Jersey?
Eli has called Summit home for a while now. He and his wife, Abby McGrew, moved their family out to the suburbs back in 2014. They bought a massive 9,000-square-foot mansion for about $4.7 million. Then, they did what every rich person does—they gutted it. Total renovation.
The house is basically a fortress of comfort. It’s got six bedrooms and nine bathrooms. Think about that for a second. Nine bathrooms! You could go a week without using the same toilet twice. But the real "Eli" touch is the basement. He had a 750-bottle wine cellar put in and a golf simulator. If you’ve seen the ManningCast, you know he doesn't like to travel much for work. He often films his segments right there in Jersey.
A Quick Reality Check on the "For Sale" Rumors
Here is where it gets confusing. Back in 2020, Eli actually listed this Summit mansion for $5.25 million. The news went everywhere. Everyone thought he was leaving the state or heading back to New Orleans.
But guess what? He’s still there.
Whether he changed his mind or just decided he didn't want to deal with the hassle of moving four kids, Summit remains the Manning home base in 2026. The town itself is perfect for him. It's "she-she" but quiet. He can go to the local coffee shop, and while people know who he is, they aren't mobbing him for autographs while he's trying to get a latte.
The Beach House: Quogue and the Hamptons
When the New Jersey humidity gets too thick in July, Eli heads to the water. In 2017, he dropped a cool $8.5 million on a beachfront spread in Quogue. Now, Quogue isn't the flashy part of the Hamptons. It’s not East Hampton where you’re trying to spot Kardashians.
✨ Don't miss: Is Park Hae Jin Married? The Real Story Behind the Rumors
It’s a three-story house on Dune Road. It has:
- Five bedrooms
- A private deck that leads straight to the sand
- A pool (because apparently the Atlantic Ocean isn't enough water)
- 1.2 acres of prime real estate
He actually used a shell company to buy it called "Mr. Chester LLC." If you’re a real fan, you know Chester was the name of his beloved Cavalier King Charles spaniel. It’s those little details that make you realize he’s just a regular guy with a really big bank account.
The Mississippi "Fumble"
You can’t talk about where Eli lives without mentioning the Oxford, Mississippi house. This is the one that just won't go away. He built this sylvan, farmhouse-style mansion back in 2009. It’s beautiful—7,450 square feet on 1.7 acres.
But he has been trying to sell it since 2019.
He listed it for $3.8 million. Then $3.9 million. Then back to $3.8 million. As of late 2025 and early 2026, he’s still technically a Mississippi homeowner because the right buyer hasn't bitten yet. It’s a bit of a real estate "fumble," but when you’ve made hundreds of millions in the NFL, you can afford to let a house sit on the market until the perfect offer comes along.
Life in the Garden State
Why stay in Jersey? Accessibility.
Even though he’s retired, Eli is still heavily involved with the Giants. He’s in their Ring of Honor. He’s doing brand deals with Knob Creek bourbon—like the 2026 Batch "Eli's Bold Pick" that just launched. Being in Summit means he’s a short drive from MetLife Stadium and a quick train ride into the city for business meetings or TV spots.
Plus, he’s a dad. He has mentioned in interviews that he loves "car time" with his kids—Ava, Lucy, Caroline, and Charlie. Driving them to practices and school in a town like Summit gives him that "normal" life his brother Peyton (who lives in Denver) and his parents (who are still in New Orleans) also value.
What This Means for You
If you're looking to catch a glimpse of No. 10, don't go looking in the Manhattan skyscrapers. Look for him at a suburban high school track meet or a quiet beach in Quogue.
📖 Related: Billy Bob Thornton Photos: The Secret History of Hollywood's Most Authentic Outlaw
Actionable Insights for Fans and Real Estate Observers:
- The Suburbs Win: Even for the ultra-wealthy, the move from places like Hoboken (where Eli lived until 2016) to the suburbs is a common trend for families.
- Privacy is Currency: Using an LLC (like Mr. Chester LLC) is the standard way high-profile athletes protect their home addresses from being public record.
- Market Patience: If you have the capital, you don't have to "fire sale" a property. Eli’s Mississippi house is proof that sometimes, stars are willing to wait years for the right price.
Eli Manning has successfully transitioned from the face of a New York franchise to a suburban dad who just happens to have two Super Bowl rings in his nightstand. He’s a Jersey guy now, through and through.