:quality(85):upscale()/2022/03/13/872/n/45101125/0763dd9e622e4c8fdd7dd6.32190060_.jpg)
Andrew Garfield is a bit of a mystery. Honestly, for someone who has played one of the most famous superheroes in history, he manages to keep his personal life remarkably quiet. He doesn’t do the whole "Instagram official" thing. You won't find him posting mushy anniversary photos or tagging his partners in travel vlogs.
He basically treats his private life like a vault. In a late 2024 interview with Esquire, he was pretty blunt about it, saying he will never confirm or deny anything about his personal life with anyone, ever. That's a bold line to draw when you're an A-list actor, but it hasn't stopped the world from watching.
Because when you're Andrew Garfield, people notice. They notice who you're grabbing coffee with in London or who is sitting next to you at a random play. From long-term romances that felt like a movie script to quiet relationships with "professional witches" and rising stars, the list of who has Andrew Garfield dated is a mix of high-profile Hollywood love and very low-key, private connections.
🔗 Read more: Who is Gavin Casalegno married to? What most fans got wrong
The Monica Barbaro Era (2025–Present)
Right now, the name everyone is talking about is Monica Barbaro. If you caught her as Joan Baez in the Bob Dylan biopic A Complete Unknown or remember her from Top Gun: Maverick, you know she’s a powerhouse. Rumors started swirling in early 2025 when fans spotted them together at a performance of Richard II in London.
By February 2021, People confirmed they were officially a thing, though "quietly." They’ve been seen at the Oscars after-parties and even shared a quick, cute moment caught on TikTok after the 2025 Met Gala. It seems like a match of equals—both are deeply respected in their craft and seem to value the same level of discretion.
The "Professional Witch" and the Philosopher
Before the current buzz around Monica, there was Dr. Kate Tomas. This one caught everyone off guard. She wasn’t a model or an actress; she’s a philosopher and a "spiritual mentor" with multiple degrees from Oxford. They were first linked in March 2024 after being spotted on a double date with Phoebe Bridgers and Bo Burnham.
It felt different.
Sources at the time said Andrew appreciated how "down-to-earth" she was. But by October 2024, Tomas confirmed the split herself on Instagram, telling a fan they had broken up months prior. She didn't hold back about the experience of dating a celebrity either, criticizing the "misogynistic nature" of the public interest in her life and how she didn't want to live in anyone's shadow.
The Relationship Everyone Still Talks About: Emma Stone
We have to talk about Emma Stone. It’s unavoidable. For a lot of fans, this is still the "Roman Empire" of celebrity relationships. They met on the set of The Amazing Spider-Man in 2011, and the chemistry was basically explosive. Andrew later described meeting her as "waking up" or "diving into white-water rapids."
They dated for about four years. They were the couple everyone rooted for—photobombing paparazzi with signs for charity and looking genuinely happy. They split in 2015, reportedly due to the strain of their massive work schedules. Andrew was filming Silence at the time and was reportedly deep into the character.
Even though Emma is now married to Dave McCary and has a child, she and Andrew remain close. He was even spotted at the premiere of her film Poor Things in late 2023. It’s one of those rare Hollywood breakups that actually stayed friendly.
The Mid-Career Romances: Models and Musicians
After Emma, Andrew took a bit of a breather from the public dating scene. Around 2018, things picked up again. He was briefly linked to Jessica Jones actress Susie Abromeit after they were seen together in Malibu.
📖 Related: Florence Henderson Cause of Death: What Really Happened to America’s Favorite Mom
Then came Rita Ora.
They were spotted holding hands in London around Christmas in 2018. It was a brief, high-energy pairing that reportedly "fizzled out" by early 2019. Shortly after that, there were whispers about Irish actress Aisling Bea after they were seen together at a performance of Hamilton.
The Alyssa Miller Timeline
- November 2021: First spotted holding hands in New York City.
- February 2022: They made it "official" (by Hollywood standards) at the SAG Awards.
- April 2022: Reports surfaced that they had split.
Alyssa, a successful model, actually poked fun at the breakup rumors on Instagram, posting a photo of them and telling people to "at least use a cute photo." Despite the joke, they did end up going their separate ways shortly after.
Short-Lived Sparks and Rumors
There’s always a bit of noise when Andrew is single. In late 2022, he was linked to Bridgerton star Phoebe Dynevor. They reportedly hit it off at the GQ Men of the Year Awards. It seemed like a "flash in the pan," as Andrew might say.
Then there was Olivia Brower in early 2024. Photos of them hugging and kissing outside his London home made the rounds, but the relationship didn't seem to transition into something long-term before he was seen with Kate Tomas just a few months later.
Why Does He Keep It So Private?
You've probably noticed a pattern. Andrew rarely talks. He fights for what he calls his "right to be ordinary." He told Bustle in 2021 that he's not in the public eye more than he has to be because he designed it that way. He wants the freedom to "be a mess" or "be sorrowful" without a camera lens catching every moment.
📖 Related: Famous People Birthday in August: Why This Month Breeds Icons
This privacy actually makes him more relatable to a lot of people. In a world where every celebrity relationship is a "brand partnership," Andrew Garfield’s dating life feels... well, human. It's messy, sometimes short, sometimes profound, and usually hidden away from the red carpet.
How to Navigate Your Own Privacy
If you’re looking to take a page out of the Andrew Garfield playbook for your own life, here are some actionable steps:
- Set Digital Boundaries: You don't have to post your partner to prove the relationship is real. Try keeping the big milestones offline for a month and see how it changes the dynamic.
- Value the "In-Between": Andrew often talks about the "fun stuff" happening between the big moments. Focus on the quiet Tuesday nights rather than the "red carpet" events of your life.
- Maintain Friendships Post-Breakup: If it's healthy, follow the Garfield-Stone model. Respecting an ex as an individual can lead to a long-term friendship that's more valuable than the romance was.
Understanding who has Andrew Garfield dated isn't just about gossip; it’s about seeing how a high-profile person navigates the very normal, very human struggle of finding connection while everyone is watching. Right now, it looks like he's found a good rhythm with Monica Barbaro, and if history is any indication, they’ll keep us guessing as long as they can.