You know that feeling when you're watching a Hallmark movie and you just know you’ve seen the lead actress somewhere before? That’s exactly what happens five minutes into watching the A Maple Valley Christmas cast do their thing on screen. It’s a 2022 Hallmark Movies & Mysteries original, but it still pops up every single holiday season because, honestly, the chemistry between the two leads is actually decent. It isn't just another cookie-cutter ranch movie. Well, it is a ranch movie, but the actors bring a certain weight to it that keeps it from being totally forgettable.
The story follows Erica Holden, played by Peyton List, a dedicated rancher who has spent her whole life working the family land in Maple Valley. Then enters Aaron, played by Andrew Walker, who represents a big developer looking to buy a chunk of that land. You’ve seen this plot a thousand times. Big city guy meets small-town girl, they argue about "progress" versus "tradition," and eventually, they’re drinking cocoa by a fire. But the reason this one sticks is the cast.
Peyton List and the Weight of Erica Holden
Most people see the name Peyton List and think of the younger actress from Cobra Kai or Jessie. Different Peyton List. This Peyton List is the one from Mad Men (she played Jane Sterling) and The Tomorrow People. She has this very specific, grounded energy. In A Maple Valley Christmas cast, she plays Erica with a kind of weary resilience that feels real. She isn't just a "movie rancher" who looks like she’s never touched dirt; she carries the character like someone who actually worries about property taxes and fence lines.
List has been in the industry forever. Seriously. She started as Lucy Montgomery on As the World Turns back in the early 2000s. Because she’s done so much soap work and intense drama, she doesn’t overplay the "holiday cheer" aspect of the film. She plays the conflict straight. When her character is faced with the possibility of losing the family legacy, you actually see the stress in her face. It’s a subtle performance for a Christmas movie, but that’s why it works.
Andrew Walker: The King of Hallmark Cameos
If there was a Mount Rushmore for Hallmark leading men, Andrew Walker’s face would be right there in the middle. The guy is a machine. He’s been in over 20 Hallmark films, and there's a reason the network keeps calling him back. He’s charming, sure, but he also has this "regular guy" vibe that makes the absurdly fast romances in these movies feel almost plausible.
In this film, he plays Aaron. He’s the "antagonist" for about fifteen minutes before he inevitably falls in love with the town. What’s interesting about Walker’s role in the A Maple Valley Christmas cast is that he doesn't play Aaron as a corporate shark. He’s more of a guy doing a job who realizes he might be on the wrong side of things. Walker and List have worked together before—notably in Girlfriend's Guide to Divorce—so they already had a rapport coming into this. You can tell. They aren't awkward around each other, which is a common pitfall in these "strangers meet" holiday scripts.
The Supporting Players You Might Miss
It isn't just the leads holding up the barn. Frances Flanagan plays Krista Holden, Erica’s mother. Flanagan is a veteran of the Vancouver acting scene, which is where most of these movies are filmed. She brings a warmth that isn't cloying. Then you have Ella Cannon as Heidi, Erica’s sister.
Cannon is an Australian actress who has been carving out a niche in North American TV, appearing in shows like iZombie and The CW's Dynasty. In Maple Valley, she provides the necessary contrast to Erica’s workaholic nature. While Erica is focused on the logistics of the ranch, Heidi is the one pushing for the "Christmas spirit." It’s a classic character foil, but Cannon plays it with enough sincerity that she doesn't feel like a plot device.
Why the A Maple Valley Christmas Cast Stands Out
Most holiday movies are shot in about 15 days. It’s a sprint. Often, you can see the actors struggling to remember their lines or looking like they’d rather be anywhere else. But the A Maple Valley Christmas cast feels like they actually like each other.
The film was directed by Paul Ziller. If you look at Ziller’s credits, the man has directed everything from creature features like Yeti: Curse of the Snow Demon to dozens of romances. He knows how to move a camera and how to get professional performances out of a tight schedule. He focuses on the landscape—the actual Maple Valley vibes (though it was filmed in British Columbia)—which gives the actors a real sense of place.
- Location: Filmed primarily in and around Maple Ridge, B.C.
- Source Material: Based on the novel by Catherine Roland.
- Release: Premiered on Hallmark Movies & Mysteries, which usually leans slightly more "drama" than the main Hallmark Channel.
The writing, handled by a team including the novelist, stays pretty close to the "ranch in jeopardy" trope, but the dialogue between Aaron and Erica is snappier than usual. They actually banter. It’s not just long stares across a stable.
The Reality of Making a Holiday Hit
Let’s be real for a second. These movies are comfort food. No one is looking for The Godfather. However, the actors in the A Maple Valley Christmas cast are all pros who have survived decades in a brutal industry. Peyton List has transitioned from soaps to peak TV to holiday movies without losing her edge. Andrew Walker has built a massive, loyal fanbase that will watch literally anything he is in.
There is a specific skill to acting in these films. You have to be "on" all the time. You have to make a sudden life-changing realization feel earned in the span of 84 minutes (minus commercials). The cast here does that. They treat the material with respect, which in turn makes the audience respect the story.
Common Questions About the Cast
People often confuse the two Peyton Lists. To be clear: the Peyton List in this movie is the one born in 1986. She’s the one who was in FlashForward and Star Trek: Picard. She isn't the one from Cobra Kai. It’s a common mix-up that even IMDb has had to fix a few times.
Another thing people ask is if Andrew Walker actually knows how to work on a ranch. He’s a pretty athletic guy in real life—he used to play football—so he looks natural in the outdoor scenes. He’s not faking the physicality of the role, which helps the "city guy learns to love the land" arc feel a bit more grounded.
📖 Related: Dean Martin Greatest Hits: Why Most Collections Miss the Real Story
Actionable Insights for Fans of the Movie
If you enjoyed the chemistry in this film, there are a few things you should actually do to find similar content without wading through the "bad" ones.
First, look for other collaborations between these actors. Since many of these performers belong to the same Vancouver-based talent pools, they often pop up together. Andrew Walker has a great filmography with Nikki DeLoach that carries a similar vibe to his work here.
Second, check out the original book by Catherine Roland. Movies often have to cut the "boring" logistics of ranching to make room for the romance, but the book goes much deeper into why Erica is so obsessed with saving her land. It adds a lot of context to Peyton List’s performance.
Finally, if you’re a fan of the scenery, look up film tours for Maple Ridge, British Columbia. A lot of the "Maple Valley" locations are real places you can visit, including the barns and the main street areas. It’s a huge hub for the "North Hollywood" film industry.
To get the most out of your holiday movie marathons:
- Verify the Peyton List: Ensure you're following the 1986 Peyton List if you want to find her other dramatic work like Frequency.
- Follow Andrew Walker on social media: He is one of the few Hallmark stars who is very transparent about the filming process, often sharing "behind the scenes" looks at how they fake snow in the middle of a 80-degree July.
- Explore the Hallmark Movies & Mysteries app: This specific film is often filed under the "Miracles of Christmas" branding rather than the standard "Countdown to Christmas," meaning it has a slightly higher production value and a more serious tone.
The A Maple Valley Christmas cast succeeded because they didn't wink at the camera. They played the stakes like they mattered, and in the world of holiday TV, that’s the difference between a movie you turn off halfway through and one you watch every year while wrapping presents.