Magic: The Gathering is a cruel game. It’s a game where you can make every single "correct" play and still lose because the top of your deck decided to betray you. That’s why talking about all time magic players is so exhausting and wonderful at the same time. You aren't just measuring trophies; you’re measuring a human's ability to stare down variance for thirty years and come out on top.
If you ask a veteran who the GOAT is, they’ll probably bark "Jon Finkel" or "Kai Budde" before you even finish the sentence. But the game has changed. The era of the "German Juggernaut" dominating with a limited card pool is gone, replaced by an era of data-crunching, digital grinders, and a Pro Tour circuit that looks nothing like it did in 1998.
The Finkel vs. Budde Debate That Never Ends
It’s the Magic equivalent of Jordan vs. LeBron.
Jon Finkel is often called "Jonny Magic" for a reason. He didn't just win; he saw the game differently. There’s a famous story from the early days where Finkel was playing a match, and his opponent made a play that seemed fine. Finkel just looked at him and basically explained why, in six turns, that one land drop would lose him the game. He was right. Finkel’s longevity is what stays with people. He made Top 8s in the 90s, and he was still making Top 8s in the 2010s. That kind of consistency over decades is basically unheard of in a game with this much "luck."
Then you have Kai Budde.
If Finkel was the artist, Kai was the machine. During a stretch from 1999 to 2002, Kai was essentially unbeatable. He has seven Pro Tour titles. To put that in perspective, most Hall of Famers have one or two. When Kai made a Top 8, you basically assumed he was going to win the whole thing. He had this terrifying efficiency. He didn't care about being flashy; he just cared about the win condition. It’s hard to argue against seven trophies, even if he didn't play as long as Jon.
The Modern Era and the Rise of Paulo Vitor Damo da Rosa
For a long time, the "Mount Rushmore" of all time magic players was just guys from the early days. Then Paulo Vitor Damo da Rosa (PVDDR) happened.
📖 Related: How to access Apple Arcade: Why you're probably making it harder than it needs to be
Honestly, Paulo might be the actual best to ever touch a card. He’s from Brazil, and he had to fight through a lot more logistical hurdles than the US or European players did early on. He has the stats to back it up: double-digit Pro Tour Top 8s and a World Championship title in 2020. What makes Paulo different is his transparency. He’s written hundreds of articles explaining his thought process. While Finkel’s skill felt like innate genius and Kai’s felt like inevitable force, Paulo’s feels like peak technical perfection. He rarely, if ever, makes a mechanical error.
He’s also the guy who proved that the "old guard" could be dethroned. When he won the World Championship, it wasn't a fluke. It was a masterclass in positioning.
The Specialists and the Silent Killers
We can't just talk about the big three.
Take Luis Scott-Vargas (LSV). If you've ever watched a Magic stream, you know LSV. He’s probably the most influential player in the history of the game because of his content creation with ChannelFireball. But don't let the puns fool you. The man went 16-0 at a Pro Tour. That’s statistically insane. In a game where the best players in the world usually win 60-65% of their matches, going undefeated in a room full of sharks is like flipping a coin sixteen times and having it land on its edge every time.
Then there’s Seth Manfield. Seth is the player other pros are actually afraid to sit across from. He plays a style that is incredibly dense and difficult to pick apart. He’s a World Champion and has a consistency rating that rivals Finkel’s prime.
And we have to mention Reid Duke. Reid is often called the "Final Boss" of Magic. Not because he’s mean—he’s actually famously the nicest guy in the room—but because his fundamentals are so rock-solid that you can't "trick" him. He plays fair Magic better than anyone else plays unfair Magic.
Why Stats Don't Tell the Whole Story
If you just look at a leaderboard, you miss the nuance.
- Era Differences: In the 90s, information moved slowly. If you found a "broken" deck, you could ride it to a win because nobody on the other side of the world knew about it yet. Today, a winning decklist is online ten minutes after the round ends.
- Field Size: Winning a Pro Tour with 300 people is hard. Winning an Arena Championship with 100,000 people trying to qualify is a different kind of grind.
- The "Pro Player" Lifestyle: Many of the best players ever, like Gabriel Nassif or Patrick Chapin, had to balance the game with shifting professional scenes.
The Complexity of the "Best" Title
What makes someone one of the great all time magic players? Is it just the trophies?
I don't think so. It’s the impact on the "meta."
🔗 Read more: Nail Upgrades Hollow Knight: Why Most Players Struggle With Pure Nail Scaling
Think about Shota Yasooka. The Japanese legend is known for building decks that shouldn't work and then piloting them to Top 8s. He plays at a speed that is genuinely uncomfortable to watch. He makes decisions in three seconds that would take me three minutes. That kind of mental processing is a specific type of greatness that doesn't always show up in a "total wins" column, but every pro knows he’s a genius.
Then you have the innovators. Players like Zvi Mowshowitz or Patrick Chapin. They didn't just play the game; they wrote the literal books on how to think about it. Chapin’s "Next Level Magic" changed how an entire generation of players approached the stack. Can you be a GOAT if you taught everyone else how to play? Most would say yes.
Acknowledging the Shift to Digital
We're in a weird spot now. The legends of the past are mostly retired or playing casually. A new crop of players is emerging from the MTG Arena ranks. These "Arena Rats" play more games in a month than Finkel played in a year during his peak.
The sheer volume of practice available now has raised the floor of competitive play. It’s much harder to be "better" than everyone else today because everyone has access to perfect information and AI-driven simulators. This is why the achievements of players like Nathan Steuer are so significant. Winning a World Championship at 20 years old in the most competitive era of the game suggests that the ceiling for "all time" status is still moving upward.
What Most People Get Wrong About Pro Magic
People think the best players are just lucky. Or they think they have some "secret" deck.
The truth is much more boring. The best all time magic players are the ones who are best at losing. They don't "tilt." If they lose a game to a bad draw, they don't complain about it for the next three rounds. They reset. They look at the one decision they made on turn two that might have changed the outcome on turn ten.
It’s about "tight" play. It’s about not giving your opponent a single percentage point of an opening. If you watch a replay of Kai Budde from 2000, you'll see a man who just doesn't make mistakes. It’s not flashy. It’s just correct.
Taking Action: How to Level Up Your Own Game
If you're looking at these legends and wondering how to get on that path, you have to stop playing for fun and start playing for information.
- Record your matches. You cannot see your own mistakes in the heat of the moment. Watch the replay. You’ll be embarrassed by how many obvious lines you missed.
- Read the archives. Go back and read PVDDR’s articles on "The Philosophy of Fire" or "Who's the Beatdown?" by Mike Flores. These are the foundational texts that every pro knows by heart.
- Focus on one deck. The "specialist" route is the fastest way to gain an edge. Don't hop from deck to deck every week. Learn the matchups for one deck until you can play it in your sleep.
- Join a testing group. None of the players mentioned above did it alone. They all had teams—Team ChannelFireball, Team Pantheon, the Japanese "Peach Garden Oath." Magic is a team sport disguised as an individual one. Find people smarter than you and let them tell you why your deck sucks.
The pursuit of becoming one of the great all time magic players isn't about the cards. It's about the discipline. Whether you prefer the raw dominance of Kai, the natural brilliance of Finkel, or the modern precision of Paulo, the common thread is an obsession with the tiny details. Every land drop matters. Every sideboard choice matters. And most importantly, every loss is a lesson you paid for with your entry fee. Make sure you get your money's worth.