It’s easy to roll your eyes at another Cinderella retelling. Honestly, the market is basically flooded with them. But then you sit down, maybe with a mug of way-too-sweet cocoa, and you realize A Cinderella Story: Christmas Wish hits differently than the dozens of other versions clogging up Netflix and Freeform every December.
You’ve got the usual tropes. There’s the overworked girl, the mean stepmother, and the "disguise" that somehow fools everyone despite her face being completely visible. It stars Laura Marano as Kat Decker, an aspiring singer-songwriter who is essentially a servant to her step-family. She’s stuck working as a singing elf at Santa’s Land. It sounds cheesy because it is. But here is the thing: the movie knows exactly what it is and leans into the holiday spirit with a sincerity that most of these sequels lack.
Unlike the original Hilary Duff classic from 2004, which felt like a high-stakes high school drama, this 2019 entry—the fifth in the A Cinderella Story series—replaces the early-2000s angst with pure festive vibes. It’s directed by Michelle Johnston, who actually choreographed and produced several of the previous films. You can tell she knows the "formula" inside and out. She isn't trying to reinvent the wheel; she's just trying to make the wheel look like a giant peppermint candy.
What Most People Get Wrong About A Cinderella Story Christmas Wish
Most critics dismiss this film as "just another teen movie." That's a mistake. If you look at the production, it’s actually a pretty tight musical. Laura Marano isn't just an actress playing a singer; she’s a legitimate musician who wrote some of the tracks on the soundtrack. When her character, Kat, is singing about her dreams, there’s a layer of authenticity there that you don't get when a studio just dubs a random pop star's voice over a lead actress.
The plot kicks off when Kat meets Nick, played by Gregg Sulkin. He’s the new Santa at the park. Predictable? Totally. But Sulkin and Marano have actual chemistry. It’s not that forced, wooden acting you see in some of those "royal" Christmas movies where the leads look like they’ve never met before the camera started rolling.
The Step-Family Dynamic: Cruelty vs. Comedy
Johnette Wilde plays the stepmother, Deirdra, and she goes full ham. It’s glorious. In the original 2004 film, Jennifer Coolidge gave us an iconic, comedic villain. Wilde does something different here—she’s more of a cartoonish social climber. Her daughters, Joy and Grace, are less "evil" and more "pathologically self-absorbed."
📖 Related: Why Tormund Giantsbane and the Gingers of Game of Thrones Became Cultural Icons
There is a specific scene where they are trying to get invited to the Winter Garden Gala. It’s the centerpiece of the movie. Most people think the "Christmas Wish" in the title refers to some magical fairy godmother moment. Nope. It’s actually about Kat’s desire to just be seen for who she is, rather than the "elf" or the "maid."
The "wish" element is grounded. Sure, there’s a gala and a fancy dress, but the stakes feel personal. Kat isn't just trying to marry a prince—mostly because Nick isn't a prince, he's just a rich kid who wants to do good. That’s a subtle but important shift from the traditional Cinderella narrative.
Why the Soundtrack Matters More Than You Think
Music is the soul of A Cinderella Story: Christmas Wish. If the songs were bad, the movie would be unwatchable.
- "Everyone Loves Christmas": This is the big, sugary opening number. It sets the stage for the Santa’s Land setting.
- "Toys": A more upbeat, playful track that showcases Marano’s vocal range.
- The Original Ballad: This is where Kat pours her heart out.
Most holiday movies use stock music or cheap covers of "Jingle Bells." This film actually invested in original songwriting. It makes the "Winter Garden Gala" performance feel like a real climax rather than just a plot point.
A Cinderella Story Christmas Wish: Behind the Scenes Reality
This movie was filmed in Vancouver, like basically every other Christmas movie in existence. If you look closely at the outdoor scenes, you can tell they were fighting the "greenery" of the Pacific Northwest by dousing everything in fake snow. It’s a staple of the genre.
Gregg Sulkin mentioned in interviews around the release that he actually enjoyed the "Santa suit" aspect because it allowed him to play a character within a character. Nick is hiding his wealthy identity to see if people like him for him, while Kat is hiding her identity behind an elf mask. It’s a double-blind trope.
Is it realistic? No.
Is it charming? 100%.
The film was released by Warner Bros. Home Entertainment, which tells you it wasn't meant for a massive theatrical run. It was designed for the "Home for the Holidays" crowd. It’s the kind of movie you put on while wrapping presents. It doesn't demand your full intellectual attention, but it rewards you with genuinely catchy tunes and a surprisingly sweet ending.
Comparing the Franchise: Where Does It Rank?
If we are being honest, nothing beats the 2004 original. That’s just facts. However, A Cinderella Story: Christmas Wish is arguably better than Once Upon a Song (the Lucy Hale one) or If the Shoe Fits (the Sofia Carson one).
Why? Because the holiday theme gives it a structure that the other sequels lack. Christmas is a built-in deadline. The "ball" makes sense as a Christmas Gala. The "magic" makes sense in the context of holiday miracles. It feels more cohesive.
Facing the "Cringe" Factor
Look, there are moments that will make you wince. The step-sisters' "influencer" aspirations are a bit on the nose. The dialogue occasionally veers into "how do you do, fellow kids" territory. But that is part of the charm of the teen-romance-holiday genre. If it weren't a little bit cringe, it wouldn't be a Cinderella story.
🔗 Read more: Why Interstellar 4th Dimension Memes Still Break the Internet
The "Winter Garden Gala" itself is a masterclass in low-budget elegance. They managed to make a Vancouver ballroom look like a high-society event with just enough glitter and lighting. When Kat finally shows up in her gown—which, let's be real, is much better than her elf costume—the payoff works because the movie spent 80 minutes making her life miserable.
Practical Takeaways for Fans of the Genre
If you are planning a movie night or just want to understand why this film keeps popping up in your recommendations, keep these points in mind:
Focus on the Music, Not Just the Plot
The film is essentially a "stealth musical." If you skip the songs, you’re missing half the character development for Kat. Listen for the lyrics in the final act; they actually tie back to her father’s legacy, which is the only "heavy" part of the movie.
Look for the Cameos
Keep an eye out for nods to the previous films. While the stories aren't directly connected by plot, they share a "vibe" and often have the same creative team behind the camera.
Manage Your Expectations
This isn't Citizen Kane. It’s a movie where a girl in an elf costume falls in love with a guy in a Santa suit. Accept the premise, and you'll have a much better time. It’s about the "cozy factor."
Check the Streaming Platforms
Availability shifts every year. Usually, it lands on Netflix or Max around November. If you can’t find it there, it’s a staple on digital rental platforms. It’s worth the $3.99 if you need a hit of pure, unadulterated holiday cheer.
Host a Franchise Marathon
If you really want to see how the series has evolved, watch the 2004 original followed by Christmas Wish. The jump from early-2000s flip phones to modern social media culture is a fascinating (and slightly jarring) time capsule of how teen movies have changed over two decades.
The real "magic" of this movie isn't in the slippers or the songs. It’s in the fact that it manages to be a sweet, harmless, and genuinely fun addition to a franchise that many people thought had run out of steam years ago. It’s the ultimate "comfort food" movie.
Actionable Next Steps
- Listen to the Soundtrack First: If you're on the fence, find Laura Marano’s "Everyone Loves Christmas" on Spotify. If you hate it, you’ll hate the movie. If you find yourself humming it, you’re the target audience.
- Double-Feature It: Pair this with A Cinderella Story (2004) for a nostalgia-meets-modern-holiday night. It highlights the evolution of the "Cinderella" archetype from the lonely outcast to the modern creative entrepreneur.
- Verify the Rating: It’s rated PG. It is one of the few "teen" movies that is actually safe for younger kids without being totally boring for adults. It makes it a solid choice for multi-generational family gatherings where nobody can agree on what to watch.