Walk into any movie theater or turn on a sci-fi show and you'll see them. Humanoids. From the forehead-ridged Klingons to the blue-skinned Na'vi, the "rubber suit" alien is a trope that has dominated our imagination for a century. But honestly, it’s not just a Hollywood budget-saving trick. There is a growing body of serious scientific discussion around the idea of convergent evolution. The question isn't just "are they out there?" but rather, "would we recognize them in a mirror?"
The Case for Convergent Evolution
Convergent evolution is basically when unrelated species develop similar traits because those traits just work. Look at dolphins and sharks. One’s a mammal, one’s a fish. Totally different lineages. Yet, they both have that sleek, torpedo-shaped body and dorsal fins because if you want to move fast through water, that’s the blueprint physics demands.
Astrobiologists like Simon Conway Morris, a paleobiologist at Cambridge, have long argued that if life exists elsewhere, it might follow a predictable path. He suggests that certain "evolutionary bottlenecks" force life toward specific solutions. If an alien planet has gravity similar to Earth’s, an atmosphere, and liquid water, the "humanoid" shape might not be an accident. It’s a functional toolkit.
Think about it. You need a brain near your primary sensory organs (eyes, ears, nose) to minimize signal delay. That’s a head. You need a way to manipulate the environment. Opposable thumbs are the gold standard there. You need to be upright to free those hands for tool use. Suddenly, you've built a human.
📖 Related: The British Emergency Alert System: Why Your Phone Screamed and What Happens Next
Why the "Gray" Archetype Sticks
When people talk about aliens looking like humans, they often drift toward the "Grays"—those spindly, large-headed beings from 1950s encounter lore. While skeptics point to sleep paralysis or cultural osmosis to explain these sightings, some evolutionary theorists find the morphology interesting.
If a species spent millions of years in a low-light environment or relied entirely on technology, their eyes might get larger and their muscles might atrophy. It’s a trope, sure. But it's a trope rooted in our own fears of where human evolution is heading.
The Chemistry of Life is Pig-Headed
We used to think life could be based on anything. Silicon? Ammonia? Maybe. But carbon is the "promiscuous" element. It bonds with almost everything. Water is the "universal solvent." Most scientists, including the late Carl Sagan and current researchers at the SETI Institute, lean toward the idea that biology across the universe likely relies on the same basic building blocks.
If the chemistry is the same, the biology might be too.
DNA—or a molecule that behaves exactly like it—is incredibly efficient at storing information. If you start with carbon and water, and you subject that soup to four billion years of natural selection, you might not end up with a sentient gas cloud. You might end up with a bipedal creature that likes to build skyscrapers and complain about the weather.
The Problem with the "Star Trek" Theory
There’s a flip side.
The "Rare Earth" hypothesis suggests that the specific conditions that made us—the Moon’s tide-stabilizing presence, our specific tectonic plate activity, the exact distance from a G-type star—are so unique that any life out there would look nothing like us.
💡 You might also like: The Motorola DynaTAC 8000X: Why the First Mobile Phone Was Actually Kind of a Disaster
Richard Dawkins has mentioned that while certain traits (like eyes) evolve independently over and over again, the "human" shape might just be a fluke. We have four limbs because our lobe-finned fish ancestors happened to have four fleshy fins. If they’d had six, we’d probably be insects with briefcases.
Technosignatures and Morphological Constraints
When we look for "technosignatures"—signs of advanced technology like Dyson spheres or radio bursts—we are looking for a mirror of ourselves. We assume aliens would use radio because we do. We assume they would build structures because we do.
If aliens looking like humans is a reality, it changes how we search. It means we aren't just looking for life; we're looking for a specific kind of peer.
Avi Loeb, the Harvard professor who made waves with his study of 'Oumuamua, often suggests we should be open to finding "space junk" from other civilizations. If those civilizations were humanoid, their junk would look like ours. Satellites. Probes. Maybe even cameras.
What the Fossil Record Tells Us
On Earth, intelligence has evolved in many shapes. Octopuses are incredibly smart, yet they are basically "aliens" living in our oceans. They have three hearts and blue blood. Their brains are distributed throughout their arms.
But octopuses can't discover fire.
You can’t have metallurgy underwater. To build a spaceship, you need fire, which means you need to be on land. To be on land and move efficiently while using tools, you almost have to be bipedal or at least have specialized limbs that aren't used for walking.
This brings us back to the humanoid form. It might be the only form capable of leaving its home planet.
Biological Constraints on Other Worlds
Gravity is the big boss. On a high-gravity planet, life would likely be squat, thick-boned, and multi-legged to distribute weight. On a low-gravity moon, like Europa, life could be wispy, long, and fragile.
But even then, the need for "centralized processing" (a brain) and "specialized effectors" (hands/tentacles) remains constant.
We also have to consider the "social" aspect of evolution. Humans became "human" because we are social. We talk. We cooperate. That requires a face capable of expression. It requires a voice or a way to transmit complex data.
Insights for the Curious
So, where does this leave us? Is the universe a hall of mirrors or a freak show of incomprehensible monsters?
✨ Don't miss: Will the USPS Text You? What Most People Get Wrong
The reality is likely somewhere in the middle. We probably won't find humans with green skin. But we very well might find creatures with two eyes, two arms, and a tendency to sit in chairs.
Actionable Next Steps for Enthusiasts:
- Track the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) Data: Look specifically for reports on "atmospheric biosignatures" in the TRAPPIST-1 system. This system has Earth-sized planets in the habitable zone where convergent evolution is most likely to be tested.
- Follow the "Technosignature" Research: Organizations like the Penn State Extraterrestrial Intelligence Center are moving away from just "listening" for radio and are looking for physical evidence of engineering.
- Read "The Runes of Evolution" by Simon Conway Morris: If you want the deep-dive academic defense of why the humanoid form might be inevitable, this is the definitive text.
- Observe Cephalopod Research: To understand how "alien" intelligence can be, watch documentaries like My Octopus Teacher or read Other Minds by Peter Godfrey-Smith. It helps frame what happens when intelligence evolves in a non-humanoid body.