Batman and Joker. It's the loop that never ends. Since the 8-bit era, developers have tried to bottle the lightning of this specific rivalry, and honestly, they usually succeed because the stakes are baked into the DNA of the characters. You’ve got the stoic detective and the agent of chaos. It’s a perfect setup for a video game. But if you look at the history of Batman and Joker games, it isn’t just a straight line of hits. There were some real stumbles before Rocksteady Studios changed everything.
People forget the 1989 Sunsoft tie-in on the NES. It was basically a Ninja Gaiden clone with a purple coat of paint. It was hard. Like, controller-breaking hard. But even back then, the final boss was the Clown Prince of Crime waiting at the top of a cathedral. We’ve been chasing that confrontation for decades.
The Arkham Shift: When Things Got Real
Before 2009, superhero games were mostly mediocre. They were "fine." Then Batman: Arkham Asylum dropped. It didn't just give us a good Batman; it gave us the definitive Joker performance by Mark Hamill. It’s weird to think about now, but that game was a massive risk. It trapped you in a psychiatric hospital with a guy who was constantly over the intercom, mocking your every move.
📖 Related: Why the Zelda Breath of the Wild Traveler's Sword is Actually Worth Keeping
The brilliance of the Arkham series—specifically Asylum, City, and Knight—was how it handled the Joker's presence even when he wasn't "alive." By the time we got to Arkham Knight, Joker was a hallucination. He was a blood-borne virus in Bruce Wayne's mind. That’s a bold narrative choice for a AAA title. It turned a standard action game into a psychological thriller. You'd be gliding across Gotham and suddenly Joker would be sitting on a gargoyle next to you, cracking jokes about your dead parents. It was uncomfortable. It was brilliant.
The Combat That Everyone Copied
Let's talk about the "Freeflow" combat. It’s the rhythmic dance of striking and countering that basically every game from Spider-Man to Shadow of Mordor stole. But in the context of Batman and Joker games, the combat served the story. When you fight Joker's thugs, you feel powerful. When you finally face Joker, the game usually strips that power away. Think about the boss fight in Arkham City. It wasn't just a physical brawl; it was a shell game involving clay doubles and a ticking clock.
Telltale’s Weird, Brilliant Experiment
If the Arkham games are about the physical struggle, the Telltale Series is about the mental one. It took a massive swing by changing the Joker's origin. In Batman: The Enemy Within, you meet "John Doe." He’s a patient at Arkham who is oddly charming and desperate for your friendship.
You actually get to decide if he becomes a vigilante or a villain.
Think about that. You can spend an entire season trying to "save" him. Most Batman and Joker games treat the Joker as an inevitable force of nature. Telltale treated him as a person. Watching John Doe slowly fracture because Bruce Wayne can't—or won't—be the friend he needs is genuinely heartbreaking. It’s a different kind of "boss fight." It’s an emotional one.
The Fighting Game Factor
Then there's Injustice. NetherRealms (the Mortal Kombat people) decided to see what happens when Joker actually wins. He tricks Superman into killing Lois Lane and blowing up Metropolis. It’s dark. Like, "why am I playing this?" dark.
But Joker’s move set in those games is a love letter to his comic history. He uses acid-spraying flowers, crowbars, and "BANG!" flags. He’s a "zoner" in fighting game terms—someone who keeps you at a distance with annoying projectiles. It perfectly captures his personality. He doesn't want to trade punches with a god; he wants to irritate you until you make a mistake.
Why We Keep Coming Back
It's the contrast. Batman is order. Joker is entropy. In a game, "order" means mechanics, rules, and leveling up. "Entropy" is the glitch in the system. The best Batman and Joker games lean into this. They make you feel like you're following a plan, only for the Joker to change the objective halfway through the mission.
✨ Don't miss: Zack Scott Games Age: Why Fans Are Still Searching 15 Years Later
There’s also the voice acting. For a generation of gamers, Kevin Conroy and Mark Hamill are these characters. Their chemistry in the recording booth translated into a digital rivalry that felt lived-in. When Joker dies at the end of Arkham City and Batman carries his body out in silence, it felt like the end of an era. Of course, it wasn't. Because in gaming, nobody stays dead if there's a sequel to be made.
What’s Next?
We’re in a weird spot now. Suicide Squad: Kill the Justice League introduced an "Elseworlds" version of the Joker. It’s a younger, more acrobatic version. Honestly? It’s been polarizing. Some fans feel it's a bit much, while others appreciate the fresh take. It shows that even without the "main" Joker, developers are terrified of leaving the character behind.
The industry is moving toward more "Live Service" models, which is a bit of a bummer for those of us who loved the tight, single-player narratives. But there’s always a rumor of a new solo Batman project. Whether it’s a soft reboot or a continuation, you can bet the Joker will be there, waiting in the wings with a prank that isn't funny.
🔗 Read more: Why You Should Play Free Battleship Game Online Instead of Buying the Box
How to Experience the Best of This Rivalry
If you’re looking to dive into the best Batman and Joker games right now, don't just go for the newest stuff.
- Start with Arkham Asylum. It’s compact, atmospheric, and still holds up graphically. It captures the "stuck in a box with a madman" feeling better than any other media.
- Play Telltale’s The Enemy Within. Even if you aren't a fan of "choice-based" games, the performance by Anthony Ingruber as John Doe/Joker is phenomenal.
- Check out Arkham Origins. It’s the "black sheep" of the series, but it actually features the best "first meeting" between the two. The hotel scene is a masterclass in character writing.
Stop looking for a "perfect" version of the story. The beauty of these games is that every developer has a slightly different take on why these two need each other. Batman provides the structure, and Joker provides the spark. Without the Joker, Batman is just a rich guy in a suit beating up burglars. With the Joker, he’s a symbol of hope standing against total nihilism. That’s a game worth playing every single time.
Actionable Next Steps
- Check your library: If you own the Arkham Collection, replay the "Joker's Funhouse" missions in Arkham City to see how the environmental storytelling highlights his obsession with Bruce.
- Toggle the settings: In Injustice 2, pay attention to the unique intro dialogue between Batman and Joker. There are dozens of variations that reference specific comic book runs like The Killing Joke and Death in the Family.
- Watch the credits: Look at the writing credits for Arkham City. Paul Dini, who wrote for the original 90s animated series, was heavily involved. Understanding the writer's background often explains why the Joker feels so "classic" in that specific game.
- Emulate the classics: If you have the means, track down Batman: Return of the Joker on the NES or Game Boy. It's a fascinating look at how developers tried to make a "Joker" game before 3D environments were even a thing.