We've all been there. It’s a rainy Tuesday, the power might be flickering, and someone pulls out the yellow box. You reach for the little plastic pawn. You want to be the Professor, or maybe the Femme Fatale. But have you ever actually looked at who these people are? I’m talking about the characters in the board game Clue—those six suspicious guests who have been trapped in Tudor Mansion since 1949.
They aren't just colors.
The game, originally patented by Anthony E. Pratt as "Cluedo" in the UK, wasn't just some random logic puzzle. It was a reflection of post-war British archetypes. Pratt was an attorney’s clerk who spent his time watching people in courtrooms. He saw the drama, the lies, and the weird social hierarchies of the era. When you pick up a character today, you’re playing a piece of history that’s been redesigned, rebooted, and occasionally murdered in cold blood.
The Evolution of the Classic Suspects
Most people don't realize that the original 1940s lineup was a bit different. There was a "Mr. Brown" and a "Miss Grey." They got cut. The survivors became the legends we know. Let's look at Miss Scarlett. In the early days, she was often depicted as a sophisticated socialite. By the 1980s, she was the "femme fatale." In the 2023 Hasbro refresh, she’s a savvy investigative journalist or a high-powered influencer type depending on which version you buy.
It’s a shift in power dynamics.
Then you have Colonel Mustard. He’s the most consistent. Usually a military man with a mustache that could sweep a chimney. In the early lore, he was a Great War vet. Later, he became a "Great Game" adventurer. Honestly, he’s usually the guy people pick when they want to look authoritative but slightly confused. He’s the brawn, but rarely the brains of the operation.
Why Professor Plum is the Real Wildcard
Professor Plum is an interesting case study in how we perceive intelligence in games. In the 1949 version, he was a bit of a ditz. An absent-minded academic. But fast forward to the 1985 movie—shoutout to Christopher Lloyd—and he becomes a disgraced psychiatrist who worked for the World Health Organization.
That’s a huge jump.
When you’re looking at characters in the board game Clue, Plum represents the "threat of the intellectual." He’s the one who knows how to use the Lead Pipe without getting blood on his tweed jacket. Or maybe he’s just a guy who spent too much time in the Library. Interestingly, in the Clue: Discover the Secrets (2008) edition, he was briefly rebranded as a billionaire video game designer. People hated it. It felt wrong. We want our Plum to be a bit dusty and a lot cynical.
Mrs. White and the Great Disappearance
We have to talk about the 2016 controversy. Hasbro did something that genuinely shocked long-time fans: they killed off Mrs. White. Well, they didn't kill her, they just replaced her.
Enter Dr. Orchid.
Dr. Orchid was the first new character added to the primary lineup in decades. She’s the adopted daughter of Samuel Boddy (the victim), and she has a PhD in plant toxicology. It was a move to modernize the game. Mrs. White, the loyal housekeeper, felt like a relic of a bygone era of domestic service. By bringing in a scientist with a potential motive—she was homeschooled by the victim and then sent to Switzerland—the game added a layer of psychological tension that the "tired maid" trope just didn't have.
But for many of us, Mrs. White is the GOAT. She knew where all the bodies were buried because she was the one cleaning the floors. There’s something inherently suspicious about someone who is "invisible" in a house.
The Mystery of Mr. Boddy (and Dr. Black)
Depending on where you live, the guy who actually dies has a different name. In the US, it’s Mr. Boddy. Very literal. In the UK, it’s Dr. Black.
But who is he?
He’s the quintessential "cipher." He exists only to be the catalyst. In most versions of the characters in the board game Clue, Boddy is a blackmailer. This is the glue that holds the game together. Why would a socialite, a colonel, and a professor all be in the same house at night? Because they all have secrets.
- Scarlett: Financial ruin or a scandalous past.
- Mustard: Cowardice on the battlefield.
- Peacock: Political corruption or a hidden inheritance.
- Green: Fraud or religious hypocrisy (depending on if he's a "Reverend" or a "Mr.").
When you play, you aren't just moving pieces. You're navigating a room full of people who all have a reason to want the host dead.
Mrs. Peacock: The Hidden Matriarch
Don't sleep on Mrs. Peacock. She is often portrayed as a bird-like, nervous socialite, but she’s frequently the most dangerous person at the table. In the 1985 film, she was the wife of a Senator, knee-deep in bribes. In the newer board games, she’s often a wealthy widow with a penchant for expensive things and a very sharp tongue.
She uses the Dagger. Or the Poison, if you’re playing a version that includes it.
The "Reverend" Green Identity Crisis
Outside of North America, Mr. Green is usually Reverend Green. When the game came to the US, the publishers thought a murderous man of the cloth might be a bit too scandalous for 1940s American families. So, he became "Mr. Green," a shady businessman or a mobster-lite figure.
It changes the vibe entirely.
💡 You might also like: Las Vegas Parlay Calculator: Why Your Math Is Probably Wrong
A Reverend in a murder mystery suggests a fall from grace. A businessman in a murder mystery is just... Tuesday. This is why the characters in the board game Clue are so fascinating; they are containers for whatever cultural fears we have at the time. Today, Green is often a "tech mogul" or a "shady venture capitalist," which feels just as appropriate as the corrupt priest was in 1949 London.
Strategic Thinking: Choosing Your Character
Does it matter who you pick? Mathematically, no. In the standard game, everyone starts with the same odds. But psychologically? Absolutely.
I’ve seen players who always pick Miss Scarlett because she typically moves first in many editions. That’s a real tactical advantage. If you can get to the first room and make a suggestion before anyone else, you’re setting the pace of the game. You’re narrowing down the cards while others are still trying to figure out if they can reach the Conservatory.
On the other hand, playing as someone like Professor Plum or Mrs. Peacock often puts you in a different headspace. You play more defensively. You watch the other players’ faces. You look for the "tell."
How to Win Using Character Logic
If you want to actually win at Clue, stop thinking about the characters as people and start thinking about them as data points. But, if you want to have fun, lean into the archetypes.
- Track the "Starting" Rooms: If you’re playing a version where characters start in specific spots, memorize the distance to the nearest "Secret Passage." The Kitchen and the Study are the most valuable rooms because they allow you to jump across the board without relying on a lucky dice roll.
- The "Fake Suggestion" Play: Use your own character in your suggestions. If you are Miss Scarlett and you have the Lead Pipe card, suggest "Miss Scarlett in the Ballroom with the Lead Pipe." It confuses everyone. They’ll look at their cards, see nothing, and assume you’re onto something.
- Watch the "Redherrings": In newer versions like Clue: Signature Collection, the art is so detailed it can distract you. Focus on the cards, not the vibes.
- Note the Discards: Whenever a player fails to disprove a suggestion, that is a massive piece of information. Most people only write down what is disproven. You should write down what isn't.
The Legacy of Tudor Mansion
The characters in the board game Clue have survived for over 75 years because they are simple enough to understand but deep enough to iterate on. We see ourselves in them—or at least, the parts of ourselves we don't usually show at dinner parties. We see the greed, the jealousy, and the desperate need to keep our secrets hidden.
🔗 Read more: Why You’ll Probably Die Trying to Confront Dagan at Koboh Observatory
Next time you open that box, don't just grab a pawn. Look at the face on the card. Think about why they’re in the mansion. Maybe they didn't do it this time. But they definitely thought about it.
Actionable Next Steps for Clue Enthusiasts
To elevate your next game night, try these specific adjustments to how you interact with the game:
- Rotate the "First Move" Advantage: If you are playing an older edition where Miss Scarlett always goes first, house-rule it so the person who last "solved a mystery" (or just the person to the left of the dealer) starts. This balances the board for characters like Mrs. Peacock who are traditionally far from the high-traffic rooms.
- Audit Your Deck: Before playing, ensure you have exactly 21 cards (6 suspects, 6 weapons, 9 rooms). If you're missing a character card, you can't play a fair game. If you've lost one, use a "blank" index card as a proxy—just make sure it’s the same size so it isn't obvious when someone is holding it.
- Study the "Dead Zones": Look at the board layout. Notice the spaces between the Lounge and the Dining Room. These "hallway" spots are where games are lost. Always aim for the rooms with two doors or secret passages to maximize your "Suggestion" frequency per turn.