You’re driving through Holmes County, Ohio. It’s quiet. The rolling hills are basically a patchwork quilt of emerald green and deep brown. Suddenly, you round a bend near Walnut Creek and there it is—Hillcrest Orchard. It isn't just a fruit stand. Honestly, calling it a "stand" feels like an insult. It’s more like a hilltop cathedral dedicated to the humble apple.
People get confused about where they are when they visit this part of Ohio. You've got Berlin, Walnut Creek, and Sugarcreek all bunched together. But Hillcrest Orchard sits in a spot that feels specifically designed for a postcard. It's a family-owned operation that has been around for decades, and they’ve mastered the art of making you feel like you've stepped back into a simpler time without it feeling like a tourist trap.
Most people come for the view first. The orchard sits on a ridge. From the parking lot, you can see miles of the Mud Valley. It’s the kind of sight that makes you want to turn off your phone. But then, the smell hits you. It’s a mix of ripe peaches, cold cider, and that earthy, sweet scent of wooden crates.
The Reality of Hillcrest Orchard Walnut Creek
Let’s talk about the apples. That’s the core of the business—literally. While some places buy their fruit from big distributors and slap a "local" sticker on it, the folks at Hillcrest are the real deal. They grow over 25 varieties of apples. We’re talking about the classics like Gala and Honeycrisp, but also the ones that make bakers nerd out, like Northern Spy or Mutsu.
The season starts early. You might see peaches and plums in the late summer, but things really kick into high gear in September. That’s when the harvest schedule starts looking like a chaotic masterpiece.
Wait. Don't just walk in and grab a bag of Red Delicious. Please.
Talk to the people behind the counter. They know which apple is peaking today. Some apples are better for eating fresh while you’re walking through the rows, and others are meant to be buried under a mountain of cinnamon and butter in a pie crust. If you’re lucky enough to visit when the GoldRush apples are ready, buy twice as many as you think you need. They’re tart, crunchy, and they keep in a cold garage for months.
✨ Don't miss: Boyne Resorts Vermont Event Venues: What Most People Get Wrong
More Than Just Fruit
If you think you’re just getting a snack, you’re wrong. The market building itself is a massive, multi-level barn structure. It’s clean, organized, but still feels rugged.
Upstairs is where things get interesting for the decorators. They have a massive selection of home goods, silks, and seasonal decor. It’s very "Amish Country chic." You’ll find high-quality furniture pieces sometimes, but mostly it’s the kind of stuff that makes a farmhouse feel like a home.
Downstairs? That’s the food.
- Local cheeses from places like Guggisberg or Heini’s.
- Summer sausage that actually tastes like meat.
- Apple butter that isn't just sugar paste.
- Fresh cider that hasn't been pasteurized into oblivion.
The cider is a big deal. They press it right there. If you’ve only ever had the clear, filtered stuff from a grocery store, your first sip of Hillcrest cider will be a revelation. It’s cloudy. It’s thick. It tastes like someone liquified a harvest moon. They sell it by the glass or the gallon, and in the fall, they usually have a slushie machine running that is basically a local legend.
Why the Location Matters
Walnut Creek is a unique animal. Unlike Berlin, which can get a little crowded with buses, Walnut Creek feels slightly more spread out. Hillcrest Orchard takes advantage of that space.
The orchard sits at 2474 Township Road 444. It sounds like it's in the middle of nowhere, but it’s actually just a stone’s throw from the Coblentz Chocolate Company and Der Dutchman. You could easily spend a whole Saturday within a three-mile radius and leave five pounds heavier.
The Mersky family—who have run this place for years—haven't turned it into a theme park. There are no animatronic farm animals. There’s no loud music. It’s just a working farm that happens to let you buy the harvest. This authenticity is why locals still shop here. When you see a guy in a straw hat and suspenders buying a bushel of drops (the bruised apples used for sauce), you know you’re in the right place.
👉 See also: Monteleone Bar New Orleans: What Most People Get Wrong
The Seasonal Rhythm
Timing is everything. If you show up in June, you’re going to find a very quiet barn and maybe some early berries. The real magic happens from August through December.
- August: The peaches arrive. These aren't those hard, grocery store rocks. These are the "eat them over the sink" kind.
- September: The early apples like McIntosh and Cortland show up. The air starts to crisp up.
- October: This is the Super Bowl. Every weekend is packed. The pumpkin patch is full, the gourds are weird-looking, and the cider press is screaming.
- November/December: Gift basket season. They do a huge business in shipping fruit boxes across the country.
People often ask if they can pick their own. Usually, Hillcrest isn't a "U-Pick" operation in the way some suburban farms are. They prefer to do the heavy lifting to ensure the trees aren't damaged and the fruit is picked at the exact right moment of ripeness. It’s a quality control thing.
Things to Keep in Mind
Cash is king, but they take cards. This isn't 1920. However, cell service on that ridge can be spotty. Don't count on having 5G to look up pie recipes while you’re standing in the aisle. Download your stuff beforehand.
Also, the parking lot is paved, which is a blessing if it’s been raining. Nobody wants to trek through Ohio clay mud just to get a peck of apples. The facility is handicap accessible too, which is a big plus because the barn is quite large.
🔗 Read more: Family Things to Do in Corpus Christi: Why Most Tourists Get it Wrong
One thing people get wrong: they think Hillcrest is open all year. It’s not. They typically close up shop for the winter once the apple supply runs out, usually around Christmas or shortly after. They need the winter to prune the trees and prep for the next year. Always check their seasonal hours before you make the drive from Cleveland or Columbus.
The Verdict on the Experience
Is it worth the drive? Yes.
It's one of those rare places that manages to be a "tourist attraction" without losing its soul. You aren't being ushered through a gift shop queue. You’re walking into a barn that smells like wood and fruit. You're looking out over a valley that hasn't changed much in a century.
You go for the apples, sure. But you stay for the quiet. You stay because, for twenty minutes, the biggest decision you have to make is whether you want a bag of Jonagolds or Stayman Winesaps.
Practical Steps for Your Visit
- Bring a Cooler: If you’re buying cheese or cider, you don’t want it sitting in a hot car while you go eat a 2,000-calorie meal at a nearby buffet.
- Go Mid-Week: Saturday in Walnut Creek is beautiful but chaotic. If you can swing a Tuesday or Wednesday morning, you’ll have the view (and the best fruit) all to yourself.
- Ask for Samples: They usually have a tasting station. Use it. You might think you hate tart apples until you try a fresh Pink Lady from the limb.
- Check the Ripening Chart: They usually post which varieties are currently being harvested on their social media or website. If you want a specific apple for apple butter, make sure it’s in season before you drive two hours.
- Look Beyond the Fruit: Their bulk food section is great for finding flour and spices that are much cheaper than what you'll find at a big-box store.
Hillcrest Orchard represents the best of what Holmes County offers. It’s a mix of hard work, incredible natural beauty, and products that actually live up to the hype. Just make sure you leave room in your trunk. You’re going to buy more than you planned.