Sinnoh is a weird place. It’s cold, it’s mountainous, and it’s arguably the most lore-heavy region in the entire Pokemon mythos. When ILCA and Nintendo finally dropped Pokemon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl, the hype was genuinely through the roof. People had been begging for these remakes since the 3DS era. But then we actually got them. And, well, the reaction wasn't exactly what you'd call "unanimously positive."
The thing is, these games are a direct time capsule. They aren't reimagining the Sinnoh region in the way Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire overhauled Hoenn. Instead, they’re "faithful" remakes. Depending on who you ask, that word "faithful" is either a badge of honor or a massive disappointment. If you grew up with a DS Lite in your hands, the chibi art style probably felt like a punch of nostalgia. If you were looking for a Sword and Shield style glow-up? You were likely left scratching your head.
✨ Don't miss: Looking into the Distance Hitman: Why the World of Assassination Fans Can't Stop Talking About It
The Chibi Controversy and the Art Direction
Let's talk about the elephants in the room—the tiny, bobble-headed elephants. The art style of Pokemon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl was a massive departure from the direction the series had been taking. Moving from the realistic proportions of Let's Go or Sword and Shield back to a 3D version of the original sprites was a bold move. Honestly, it's kinda polarizing.
In the overworld, your character looks like a Funko Pop. In battle, they suddenly scale up to realistic proportions. It’s jarring at first. But there’s a logic to it. By keeping the grid-based movement and the squashed characters, ILCA was able to preserve the exact layout of the original maps. This means every secret path and every rock placement is exactly where you remember it from 2006.
Does it look "modern"? Not really. But it does look clean. The water effects and the lighting in places like Oreburgh City or the Eterna Forest are actually quite beautiful. It’s just that the character models themselves didn't land for everyone.
What They Actually Changed (And What They Left Out)
One of the biggest gripes fans have revolves around the Platinum content. Or rather, the lack of it. Pokemon Platinum is widely considered the definitive way to play the Sinnoh games. It fixed the abysmal pacing, added the Distortion World, and fixed the "Fire-type problem" where there were basically no Fire Pokemon available until the post-game.
In Pokemon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl, we essentially went back to the original Diamond and Pearl pokedex. This was a baffling choice. Why would you release a remake that has less content than the "third version" that came out over a decade ago?
🔗 Read more: Cloud9 League of Legends: Why the Spark Finally Came Back
However, it’s not all bad news. The Grand Underground is a massive upgrade. In the originals, the Underground was mostly for digging up fossils and decorating a secret base. Now, it’s a sprawling network of "hideaways" where you can catch wild Pokemon walking around in the open. This actually fixes the Fire-type scarcity issue. You can find Houndoom or Magby in the volcanic rooms way before you reach the Elite Four. It’s a smart pivot that keeps the core game "faithful" while actually making it playable for a modern audience.
The Difficulty Spike Nobody Expected
For about 90% of the game, Pokemon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl is a breeze. The EXP Share is permanently on, which means your whole team is usually over-leveled. You’re breezing through gyms. You’re crushing Team Galactic. You think you’re a god.
Then you hit Cynthia.
Suddenly, the game turns into a competitive VGC match. Cynthia’s Garchomp isn't just a high-level dragon; it’s a perfectly EV-trained, IV-bred killing machine holding a Yache Berry to survive your Ice-type moves. Her Milotic has a Flame Orb to trigger Marvel Scale. This is arguably the hardest boss fight in the history of the main series.
It’s a bizarre difficulty curve. One minute you’re playing a game designed for seven-year-olds, and the next you’re being forced to understand competitive stat-weighting just to see the credits roll. For veteran players, it was a welcome challenge. For casual fans? It was a brick wall.
The QOL Changes That Actually Matter
Let’s be real: HMs sucked. Carrying around a "HM Slave" like Bibarel just so you could cut down trees or smash rocks was the worst part of the old games. Pokemon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl finally killed this. Now, you just use your Poketch to call a wild Bidoof to do the work for you. It’s seamless. It’s fast. It makes exploring Mt. Coronet significantly less of a chore.
The movement is also 360 degrees now, rather than the old four-way grid. This sounds small, but it changes the feel of navigating the world entirely. Though, ironically, because the world is still built on a grid, you'll find yourself getting stuck on corners more often than you’d like. It’s a weird clash of old-school design and new-school tech.
Following Pokemon and Customization
People love having their Pokemon walk behind them. It started in Yellow, peaked in HeartGold, and it’s back here. Mostly. The scaling is... well, it’s hilarious. An Entei will be the same size as a Pikachu. Some of the larger Pokemon have trouble keeping up with you and constantly teleport to your side. It feels a bit unpolished, honestly.
Then there’s the clothing. You can finally change your outfit in Veilstone City, which is a nice touch. But you can't mix and match pieces. You have to buy full sets. It’s a "one step forward, two steps back" situation that defines a lot of the experience in these remakes.
The Competitive Meta and the Post-Game
If you were looking for a new competitive hub, this wasn't it. The official competitive scene stayed on Sword and Shield until Scarlet and Violet launched. Pokemon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl exists in its own little bubble.
👉 See also: Teen Goku Sparking Zero: Why This Dragon Ball Classic Is Actually a High-Tier Threat
The post-game does have Ramanas Park, which replaces the Pal Park. It’s a place where you can catch legendary Pokemon from previous generations by finding special slates. It’s a grind, but for collectors, it’s a goldmine. There’s also the Battle Tower, which is as punishing as ever. It doesn't have the variety of the old Battle Frontier, but it’s a solid time-sink if you enjoy high-stakes AI battles.
Why You Should (Or Shouldn't) Play It Now
Look, these aren't perfect games. They have bugs. Some of them were fixed, some of them are just part of the charm now. But if you want to experience the Sinnoh story without the agonizingly slow health bars of the original DS games, this is the way to do it.
The soundtrack is also incredible. The remastered versions of the Route 209 theme or the Cyrus battle music are top-tier. It captures that lonely, cold atmosphere of Sinnoh perfectly.
If you’re a purist who wants the Platinum experience, you might be better off sticking to an emulator or an original cartridge. But if you want a cozy, visually crisp trip down memory lane with a genuinely challenging endgame, Pokemon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl delivers exactly what it promised: a faithful, if flawed, recreation of a classic.
Immediate Next Steps for Your Journey Through Sinnoh
- Prioritize the Grand Underground early. Don't wait until the late game to explore. The "Hideaways" contain Pokemon you won't find anywhere else in the wild, which is crucial for balancing your team before the second and third gyms.
- Plan for Cynthia from the start. Do not neglect your team’s held items and natures. You will need a specific counter for her Garchomp (Fairies or a fast Ice-type with a Focus Sash) if you want to avoid a total party wipe.
- Check the mystery gift daily. While many launch events have passed, Nintendo occasionally drops statues or items that assist with the Grand Underground mechanics.
- Use the Poketch for more than HMs. The Item Finder app is essential in Sinnoh, as many of the best items (like Rare Candies and PP Ups) are hidden in the snow or behind rocks in Mt. Coronet.
- Talk to everyone in Hearthome City. This is where most of the "flavor" of the game is located, including the Poffin House and the entrance to Amity Square, which unlocks the ability to have Pokemon follow you throughout the rest of the game.