It was 2006. The Xbox 360 was still the shiny new toy in everyone's living room, promising us "next-gen" everything. Then came the tie-in for Brandon Routh’s big debut. Honestly, playing Xbox 360 Superman Returns today is a trip. It's one of those rare games that managed to be both incredibly ambitious and deeply frustrating at the exact same time. You fly into the stratosphere, hear that iconic John Williams score swell, and for a second, you really feel like the Man of Steel. Then you realize you're fighting another generic robot. Again.
Most movie-licensed games from that era were total rush jobs, and while this one definitely feels unpolished, EA Tiburon—the Madden people, strangely enough—actually tried to do something different here. They didn't just want a brawler. They wanted a flight simulator where the pilot happens to have heat vision.
The Genius Idea of the Metropolis Health Bar
Here is the thing about Superman: he's invincible. Making a game where a stray bullet can kill Clark Kent feels wrong. It breaks the logic of the character. The developers of Xbox 360 Superman Returns understood this, so they made a choice that was honestly kind of brilliant. Superman doesn't have a health bar. Metropolis does.
If you take too long to stop a villain, or if you accidentally fly through a skyscraper at Mach 5, the city's "stamina" drops. When the city is rubble, it's game over. It forced you to actually care about collateral damage, which is a core part of the Superman mythos. You couldn't just spam area-of-effect attacks because you'd level a city block. It turned the game into a massive escort mission, which, okay, sounds like a nightmare on paper, but in practice, it gave the combat some much-needed stakes.
👉 See also: Why Games With Local Multiplayer PS4 Still Win Every Time
The scale was massive for 2006. We’re talking 80 square miles of open-world Metropolis. You could see the curvature of the earth if you flew high enough. That was huge. Most games back then were still using "invisible walls" or thick fog to hide the fact that the world ended three blocks away. Here? You just flew.
Why the Gameplay in Xbox 360 Superman Returns Was So Polarizing
Flying felt amazing. There’s no other way to put it.
The sound design played a huge role in that. When you broke the sound barrier, the audio would cut out for a split second before a massive boom echoed through your speakers. The screen would blur, Superman’s cape would snap violently in the wind, and you’d cover miles in seconds. Even by today’s standards, the flight mechanics in Xbox 360 Superman Returns hold up surprisingly well compared to modern attempts at the character.
But then you had to actually do stuff.
The mission variety was... lacking. It mostly involved punching robots. There were these "Warworld" segments that dragged on way too long, and the boss fights with Metallo or Mongul felt like they were from a different, much clunkier game. You had all these cool powers—freeze breath, multiple intensities of heat vision, super strength—but the game never really figured out how to make you use them creatively. It was usually just "punch the glowing bit until the cutscene starts."
The game also suffered from being a cross-generation title. It came out on the original Xbox and PS2 as well, and you could tell the 360 version was basically the old game with a fresh coat of high-definition paint. The citizens of Metropolis looked like cardboard cutouts, and the buildings were often repetitive. Yet, when you were 2,000 feet in the air looking down at the sun reflecting off the harbor, it looked like the future.
The Bizarre Connection to Superman Flyby
If you’re a DC nerd, the history of this game is actually pretty fascinating. A lot of the DNA for this project came from the cancelled Superman Flyby movie (the one J.J. Abrams wrote). You can see it in some of the concept art and the way the city was laid out. By the time Superman Returns the movie was finalized, the developers had to pivot hard to match Bryan Singer’s vision.
That’s probably why the game feels so disjointed. It’s a mix of a comic book brawler and a moody film tie-in. You’ve got Brandon Routh’s likeness and voice, but then you’re fighting villains like Bizarro who weren't even in the movie. Honestly, thank God for that. If the game had stuck strictly to the plot of the film, we would’ve spent three hours lifting an island made of Kryptonite and watching Kate Bosworth look concerned. Instead, we got to fight a 50-foot tall Metallo.
Technical Legacy and the "Superman Curse"
Is it a "good" game? That depends on who you ask. If you're looking for a tight, polished experience like Batman: Arkham Asylum, then no. Not even close. But if you want a sandbox where you can feel the raw power of a god, Xbox 360 Superman Returns is one of the only games that even attempts it.
✨ Don't miss: Solitaire Online Card Game: Why This Century-Old Obsession Is Actually Getting Better
The "Superman Curse" in gaming is real. Developers struggle with him because he’s too powerful. If you make him weak enough to die from a punch, fans get mad. If you make him as strong as he is in the comics, there’s no challenge. This game tried to solve that with the "City Health" mechanic, and while it wasn't perfect, it remains the most interesting solution any studio has ever come up with.
Interestingly, the game actually featured a "fast-travel" mechanic that was just Superman flying into space and then plummeting back down to a different part of the map. It was seamless. No loading screens (mostly). In 2006, that was witchcraft.
How to Play It Today
If you still have your old discs, you should know that Xbox 360 Superman Returns is unfortunately NOT on the official Xbox backward compatibility list for Xbox One or Series X|S. Licensing issues with the movie and the soundtrack usually keep these titles in legal limbo forever. To play it, you need:
- A physical copy of the game (usually cheap on eBay or at local retro shops).
- An original Xbox 360 console.
- A lot of patience for the mid-2000s motion blur.
It’s worth the ten bucks just to experience the flight mechanics. We haven't had a standalone Superman game since this one, which is wild considering it's been nearly two decades. Every time a rumor pops up about Rocksteady or Monolith making a new one, people go back and look at this 2006 title as the blueprint of what to do—and what to avoid.
Actionable Takeaways for Retro Collectors
If you are going to pick this up, don't go in expecting a masterpiece. Go in for the spectacle. Focus on mastering the flight controls early; the game becomes much more enjoyable once you stop crashing into the sides of the Daily Planet. Also, ignore the side challenges unless you’re a completionist. They are repetitive and mostly involve flying through hoops, which felt dated even when the game was new.
Stick to the main story just to see the boss encounters, and spend the rest of your time seeing how fast you can actually go. There is a specific joy in hearing that sonic boom and realizing you’ve just crossed the entire city in the time it took to blink. It’s a flawed, weird, beautiful mess of a game that deserves to be remembered for its ambition rather than its polish.
Next Steps for Players: Check your local used game store for the "Collector's Edition" which came in a tin case; it doesn't add much content, but it's a great display piece for DC fans. If you're on PC, there are community-made mods for other games like Grand Theft Auto V or Megaton Rainfall that try to replicate this flight feel, but nothing quite captures the specific weight of the EA Tiburon version.