Xbox One Saints Row: Why the Reboot Still Divides the Community

Xbox One Saints Row: Why the Reboot Still Divides the Community

Look, the history of Xbox One Saints Row is messy. Really messy. If you go searching for a copy today, you aren't just looking for one game. You're actually looking at a decade-long identity crisis spread across four or five different releases.

You’ve got the 2022 reboot, which basically tried to wipe the slate clean. Then there are the remasters. And let’s not forget the 360-era classics that run on the console through backward compatibility. It's a lot to keep track of. Honestly, it’s kind of a miracle the series lasted as long as it did before Volition eventually shuttered.

The 2022 Reboot: What Went Wrong?

When people talk about Xbox One Saints Row lately, they usually mean the self-titled 2022 reboot. It was supposed to be a return to form. A fresh start. Instead, it became a lightning rod for controversy.

The game moves the action to Santo Ileso, a fictional Southwest city that looks great but often feels a bit hollow. You play as "The Boss," a roommate trying to pay off student loans. Yeah, student loans. It’s a far cry from the gritty, "king of the streets" vibe of the original 2006 title or the absolute madness of the later sequels.

Performance on the base Xbox One was... well, let's just say "challenging." While the Series X handles the desert sun and neon lights decently, the older hardware struggled. We're talking frame rate dips that make a firefight feel like a slideshow. Digital Foundry highlighted these tech issues early on, noting that even with patches, the engine felt dated.

🔗 Read more: That Mario Kart World Rainbow Road Leak: What's Actually Real?

The writing is the biggest sticking point. The new crew—Eli, Neenah, and Kevin—didn't exactly land with the old-school fan base. They felt like "corporate-approved" rebels. The dialogue often tried too hard to be relatable to a younger audience, resulting in "cringe" moments that became memes overnight. It’s not that the game is unplayable. The driving is actually quite snappy, and the wingsuit is a blast. But it lacks the "soul" people expected.

The Better Way to Play: Remasters and Backward Compatibility

If the reboot isn't your speed, the Xbox One Saints Row experience actually shines brightest when you look backward. This is the beauty of the Xbox ecosystem.

Saints Row: The Third Remastered

This is arguably the peak of the series on the console. Released in 2020, this wasn't just a resolution bump. Sperasoft basically rebuilt the lighting engine and updated almost every asset. Steelport looks moody, wet, and vibrant. It includes all the DLC, meaning you get the "Genkibowl VII" madness and the "Gangstas in Space" missions right out of the box. It’s loud, it’s stupid, and it knows exactly what it is.

The "Presidential" Era

Then there’s Saints Row IV: Re-Elected. If you want a traditional gang simulator, stay away. This is a superhero game. You are the President of the United States, you have super speed, and you’re fighting aliens in a Matrix-style simulation. It’s chaotic. It also includes Gat Out of Hell, which is a standalone expansion where you literally fly through the underworld. It runs surprisingly well on the Xbox One, mostly because it's an upscaled version of an older engine.

The Classics (Back-Compat)

The real "hidden gem" is that you can play the original Saints Row (2006) and Saints Row 2 on your Xbox One. These are the games that defined the "GTA Clone" era before the series went off the rails into sci-fi.

✨ Don't miss: Getting the Lightning Sword in BO6: Why Most Players Struggle With the Liberty Falls Quest

  • Saints Row (2006): Still an Xbox 360 exclusive technically, but runs via emulation. It’s much more grounded. You’re just a guy in a purple jersey trying to survive Stilwater.
  • Saints Row 2: Widely considered the best story in the franchise. It’s dark. It’s violent. The mission where you use a septic truck to spray houses? Legendary.

Getting the Most Out of Santo Ileso Today

If you decide to pick up the 2022 Xbox One Saints Row now, you’re actually getting a much better version than the one that launched. Volition released several massive "Quality of Life" updates before they were closed down.

  1. Check the Combat Settings: The default aiming is notoriously "floaty." Go into the settings and tweak the deadzones and acceleration. It makes a world of difference.
  2. Utilize Criminal Ventures: Don't just rush the story. The real meat of the game is in building businesses like "Shady Oaks" or "Castle Warren." This is how you unlock the best perks and cash flow.
  3. Co-op is Key: Like every game in this series, it is 100% better with a friend. The "pranking" mechanic in the reboot allows you to turn your partner into a mailbox or a toilet. It’s dumb fun.

The Technical Reality

Let's be real: playing the newest Xbox One Saints Row on an original 2013 Xbox One or an One S is a gamble. You will see pop-in. You will see textures that look like clay for a few seconds. If you have an Xbox One X, the experience is significantly more stable, but it still won't match the current-gen fluidity.

The community remains split. Some people love the customization—which is, to be fair, the best in the industry. You can change your skin to chrome, give yourself a prosthetic limb, or make your gun look like an umbrella. Others can't get past the fact that it doesn't feel like "Saints Row" anymore.

Actionable Next Steps

If you're looking to dive back into the Row, here is how you should approach it:

  • For the Story: Get Saints Row 2 through the Microsoft Store. It’s cheap, and the narrative stakes are higher than anything else in the series.
  • For the Visuals: Grab Saints Row: The Third Remastered. It’s frequently on sale for under $10 and looks genuinely "modern" on an Xbox One.
  • For the New Stuff: Only buy the 2022 reboot if it’s on a deep sale. It’s a decent weekend diversion, but don't expect it to change your life.
  • Performance Tip: If you're playing on any Xbox One model, install the games to an external SSD if you have one. It won't fix the frame rate, but it will drastically cut down the annoying load times and some of the texture streaming issues.

The Saints might be gone for now, but the games are still there. Whether you're running through the 2022 desert or the 2006 streets of Stilwater, there's still plenty of purple-clad chaos to go around.