Walk down Derby Street in Salem and you’ll smell it before you see it. It’s not the smell of "witch city" kitsch or overpriced souvenirs. It is the scent of pulled sugar and history. Ye Olde Pepper Companie Salem MA is tucked right across from the House of the Seven Gables, and honestly, if you walk too fast, you might miss the oldest candy company in America. That isn’t marketing fluff. Since 1806, they’ve been making the same stuff. While other businesses fold after five years, this place has survived the War of 1812, the Great Depression, and the rise of massive corporate chocolate empires.
Most people think Salem is just about the trials. It’s not.
🔗 Read more: Smyrna Beach FL Shark Attacks: What Actually Happens at the World’s Shark Bite Capital
The story of the Pepper Companie actually starts with a shipwreck. Mary Spencer, a woman from England, arrived in Salem in the early 1800s with basically nothing but a barrel of sugar and a recipe. She started making "Salem Gibraltars." These aren't your typical soft gummy bears. They are hard, lemon or peppermint flavored candies that feel like a rock but melt into a weirdly satisfying creaminess. They became the first commercially made candy in the United States. You've got to respect a business that started because a neighbor lent a woman a bucket of sugar so she wouldn't starve.
The Weird Science of the Salem Gibraltar
What really kills me about the Gibraltar is how simple it is. It's just sugar, water, and flavor. But the process is what keeps it alive. You can’t just mass-produce these in a factory in the Midwest and expect them to taste the same. They are hand-pulled.
Kinda like how a baker treats sourdough starter, the folks at Ye Olde Pepper Companie keep the tradition specific. The texture of a Gibraltar is distinctive because it ages. Seriously. If you eat one fresh off the line, it’s just a hard candy. But if you let it sit for a few weeks—or months—the sugar crystals break down and it gets that "melt-in-your-mouth" vibe that sailors used to love. Because they didn't spoil, these candies were the perfect snack for long sea voyages.
Think about that. In the 1830s, a sailor headed to Canton or Calcutta probably had a tin of these in his pocket. It’s a direct link to the maritime history of Massachusetts that most museums can’t touch.
Black Jacks and the Burnt Sugar Obsession
If the Gibraltar is the famous sibling, the Black Jack is the moody, dark one. It’s made from stick liquorice and molasses. It’s an acquired taste. Honestly, most kids today who are used to high-fructose corn syrup might find it "too much," but it’s a deep, rich flavor that takes you back to a time when candy wasn't just a sugar bomb.
🔗 Read more: Rocky Mountain National Park Timed Entry: What Most People Get Wrong About Booking Your Visit
- They use large copper kettles. These aren't for show. Copper distributes heat in a way stainless steel just can't, which is vital for preventing the molasses from scorching.
- The pulling machines in the back look like something out of a steampunk novel.
- Everything is wrapped by hand or on vintage machinery that has been maintained for decades.
Why the Burley Family Kept It Going
Mary Spencer didn't keep the shop forever. Eventually, it passed to the Pepper family (hence the name Ye Olde Pepper Companie Salem MA), and later to the Burley family. Currently, the Burleys are the fourth generation of their family to run the shop. That kind of continuity is rare. You see it in some European bakeries, but in America? It's practically unheard of.
Bob Burley and his family didn't try to "disrupt" the industry. They didn't try to become the next Hershey. They stayed small. They stayed in Salem. They kept the recipes in a safe. There’s something deeply respectable about a business that knows exactly what it is and refuses to change for the sake of a trend.
When you walk in today, you’ll see the modern stuff—truffles, fudge, and saltwater taffy—because they have to pay the bills. But the heart of the shop is still those clear jars of Gibraltars. They even have the old ledger books and original scales on display. It feels less like a retail store and more like a working archive.
The Survival Strategy Most People Miss
The "secret sauce" of their longevity isn't actually the sugar. It’s the location. Being right next to the House of the Seven Gables means they get a steady stream of tourists, sure. But the real reason they survive is their refusal to cut corners.
In the mid-20th century, when everyone else was switching to artificial flavorings and cheaper corn syrup, the Pepper Companie stuck to the expensive stuff. They realized that if they became "just another candy shop," they were dead. Their value is in the heritage. If you change the recipe to save five cents a bag, you aren't the oldest candy company anymore. You're just a store selling cheap sweets.
Visiting Derby Street: A Reality Check
If you’re planning a trip to Salem to visit the shop, don't expect a polished, Disney-style experience. It’s a real building. It’s old. The floors might creak. The staff is usually busy actually making things.
- Parking is a nightmare. Especially in October. If you’re coming for the candy, come in April or May. You’ll actually be able to breathe.
- The Gibraltars are an experience. Don't bite them immediately unless you want to see a dentist. Let them sit on your tongue.
- Try the fudge. While the Gibraltars are the "history," the fudge is what keeps the locals coming back. It’s insanely creamy.
The shop is located at 122 Derby Street. It’s a bit of a hike from the commuter rail station, but the walk takes you past some of the best architecture in the city. You pass the old customs house where Nathaniel Hawthorne worked. You see the masts of the Friendship of Salem in the distance. By the time you get to the shop, you're already in the 19th-century mindset.
Beyond the Sugar: The Business Model of Legacy
Businesses today are obsessed with "scaling." If you aren't growing, you're dying, right? Ye Olde Pepper Companie proves that’s a lie. They have remained a single-location operation for over two centuries.
They haven't franchised. They haven't opened a shop in every mall in New England. By keeping it small, they control the quality. They also control the brand. You can only get the "real" experience in that one room on Derby Street. That scarcity creates a destination. People don't just "buy candy" there; they "visit the shop." It’s a subtle but massive difference in how a brand operates.
Actionable Steps for Your Visit
If you want the real experience at Ye Olde Pepper Companie Salem MA, don't just grab a bag of jelly beans and leave.
Start by asking the staff which batch of Gibraltars is the "oldest." They might look at you funny, but the ones that have sat for a bit have the best texture. Grab a box of the Assorted Gibraltars—it usually comes with a little history pamphlet that explains the Mary Spencer story. It’s the best $15 history lesson you’ll ever buy.
📖 Related: Who Drives on the Right Side of the Road: Why Our World is Split and How it Stayed That Way
Next, walk across the street to the harbor. Sit on the benches and eat a Black Jack while looking at the water. It’s the exact same view (minus the modern yachts) that the original customers had 200 years ago.
Finally, check out their seasonal offerings. While they are famous for the old-school stuff, their handmade chocolates and turtles are legitimately top-tier. They use high-quality cacao that stands up to any boutique chocolatier in Boston or New York. Just because they’re old doesn't mean they're out of touch. They’ve managed to balance being a museum piece with being a functional, profitable business. That’s the real miracle of Salem.