Nom Nom Vs Ollie Dog Food
This page contains affiliate links. We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission. Learn More
Because I want nothing but the best for my dog, I am always trying new fresh dog food services. With so many benefits to giving dogs fresh human grade dog food, it is important to know which brands are more balanced in comparison to others.
In this article we compared Nom Nom to Ollie Dog Food and highlighted the key differences between these two dog food brands.
To properly compare Nom Nom and Ollie Dog Food, we have evaluated both brands on up-to-date nutrition, recall history, product variety, price information and other important criteria.
How We Tested
- We purchased service from both Nom Nom and Ollie dog food services mentioned in this article
- We spent several weeks testing each dog food service and their recipes
- We did not receive these products in exchange for a favorable review
| Metric |  |  |
| Price per Pound | $3 | $3 |
| Recall History (Yes/No) | No | No |
| Location | California | New York |
| Shipping time | 1 week | 2 weeks |
| # of Delivery Plans | 3 | 2 |
| Eco-Friendly Packaging (Yes/No) | Yes | Yes |
| Discount Available (Yes/No) | 50% Off First Box | 50% Off First Box |
| Online Support (Yes/No) | Yes | Yes |
| Refund policy (Yes/No and # of days/weeks) | Yes, 30 days | Yes or Exchange |
| # Of Recipes | 4 | 4 |
| Avg. Protein Content | 9.1% | 11% |
| Avg. fat content | 5.4% | 7.7% |
| Avg. Fiber content | 1% | 2% |
| Avg. Moisture content | 73.5% | 71% |
| Overall Score | 94% | 93% |
Crude Protein Comparison For Dog Food
Protein plays a key role in your dog’s diet and helps with immune function, oxygen transport and maintaining strong muscle tissue. Without the right amount of protein, dogs can develop a wide-range of serious health issues.
Nom Nom recipes contain an avg. of 9.1% protein while Ollie’s recipes contains an average of 11%. This difference in protein content is a notable difference between Nom Nom and Oliie.
Crude Fat Comparison For Dog Food
Dietary fats play a wide range of roles when it comes to your dog’s development and overall body function. Fat provided in your dogs food helps maintain healthy skin and a shiny, healthy coat.
Nom Nom recipes contain an avg. of 5.4% protein while Ollie’s recipes contains and avg. of 7.7%. This difference in crude fat is a notable difference between Nom Nom and Ollie.
Also Read: The Best Fresh Dog Food Delivery Services
Now that we’ve reviewed the key factors, let’s have a closer look at each dog food brand
- Very easy to order
- Smells and looks like real food
- Pre-portioned servings
- Veterinary nutritionist ensures meals are nutritionally balanced
- It is on the pricey side
- Must be refrigerated
- Packets can be difficult to open
- Very easy to order
- Smells and looks like real food
- Pre-portioned servings
- Veterinary nutritionist ensures meals are nutritionally balanced
- It is on the pricey side
- Must be refrigerated
- Packets can be difficult to open
Overview
Location: Facilities in San Francisco, California and Nashville, Tennessee
Available Recipes:
- Chicken Chow
- Beef Mash
- Turkey Fare
- Pork Potluck
Nom Nom’s meals are made with restaurant-quality ingredients, no artificial preservatives or fillers and portions are optimized to provide your dog with the ideal balance for his age, weight, activity level, breed, as well as any known health issues.
The recipes were developed by the company’s Chief Nutrition Officer, board-certified veterinary nutritionist. The unprocessed meals are made in small batches and with whole foods, to retain more nutrients and exceeds AAFCO standards for dog food formulation for all life stages.
Nom Nom asks you to create a profile for your dog and provide their current weight, target weight, birthday and your recipe preference. You can choose one of four recipe flavors or mix them up and even change them with every order.
Cost
The cost ultimately depends on the the desired size of your dog which is determine in the profile. Basically for every pound of pup you enter, the price will go up.
Here is an estimate based on weight:
- 15 pounds – $32- $39 weekly or $4 -$5 a day
- 55 pounds – $47-$66 weekly or $6 -$9 a day
- 95 pounds – $63 -$92 weekly or $9-$13 a day
Delivery Options
The weekly deliveries come with a shipment of 14 meal packs (two meals per day), bi-weekly deliveries come with 28 meals, and monthly deliveries come with 56 meals.
Managing your account is easy and you are able to pause or skip, up to your next 4 deliveries in your account.
When your Nom Nom delivery arrives you will find all meal packages neatly organized with rubber bands inside of the box and chilled with dry ice. Your first order will contain a bonus like jerky treats and a booklet on transitioning your dogs food.
If you need to cancel your subscription you will need to contact customer service via email or by phone. You are also able to request extra meals for travel or even have meals delivered to a different address. Nom Nom does offer a sample box, which allows potential customers to receive four meals choices for only $15 per pack.
- Meals are customized based on your dogs profile
- Four different meal flavors available
- Free shipping and delivered right to your door
- Recipes overseen by a vet and are human grade ingredients
- Price on the high side as compared to other fresh dog foods
- Food comes frozen solid
- Profile only accounts for allergies not health issues
- Meals are customized based on your dogs profile
- Four different meal flavors available
- Free shipping and delivered right to your door
- Recipes overseen by a vet and are human grade ingredients
- Price on the high side as compared to other fresh dog foods
- Food comes frozen solid
- Profile only accounts for allergies not health issues
Overview
Location: New York (HQ), Facility in Pennsylvania
Available Recipes:
- Turkey Recipe
- Beef Recipe
- Chicken Recipe
- Lamb Recipe
Ollie pet food is designed with the help of a veterinary nutritionist to ensure that each recipe is complete and balanced in keeping with Association of American Feed Control Officials requirements for dogs. All of Ollie’s products are free from by-products, fillers, artificial flavors, and preservatives.
The sign up process begins with a series of questions about everything from your dogs breed, if he has been spayed or neutered, his activity level, allergies and even the type of food he is currently eating.
Cost
Price depends on the size of your dog and meals selected. It is calculated by how much food he needs based on the exact number of calories he should consume daily, which dictates your subscription cost, but shipping is free.
Based on a fairly active and healthy 4 year old dog, your cost would be approximately:
- 15 pounds – $28 – $32 weekly or $4 – $5 a day
- 55 pounds – $59 – $66 weekly or $9 – $10 a day
- 95 pounds – $96 – $106 weekly or $14 – $15 a day
Delivery Options
Ollie has only two main delivery plans. The “All Ollie” meal plan means you receive 14 trays delivered every two weeks and the second plan, “Mostly Ollie” is meant to supplement your dog’s meals with 28 smaller packs of food delivered every four weeks.
If at any time you need to pause, skip, or cancel your orders, you can log into your account and do so from there. You can also update your dog’s profile at any time in the event there is changes in weight, activity level or even to try different meal flavors.
Ollie pet food is shipped in a white cardboard box with plenty of recyclable padding and dry ice to keep the food very cold. Each package is vacuum sealed for freshness and frozen.
Ollie recipes come in plastic packets that are fairly easy to open by peeling back the top of the packet and dropping the food into your dogs dish.
The Bottom Line
After weighing the pros and cons of both dog food brands we made the difficult decision of picking just one. It was a really close call since both Nom Nom and Ollie are excellent dog food brands and my dog ate both foods in record time.
Our top pick for fresh dog service in this article, goes to Nom Nom based on several criteria. In the end, Nom Nom’s pricing is reasonable, delivery time is faster and they offer extra items like dog treats. They also offer more recipe varieties and allow you to mix them up which keeps my dog satisfied and interested.
